Fossil Hunting at Big Brook Preserve, New Jersey

Fossil Hunting · New Jersey, MonmouthVerified Researched by Derek Voss

ALLOWED

No permit required

Fossil hunting at Big Brook needs no permit for small groups, but Monmouth County and Colts Neck each set their own limits on the same creek. Rules checked against primary sources in .

Key Conditions

  • No permit or fee for individuals or groups of 10 or fewer in the county park; larger county groups must register for a Naturalist-led program. Colts Neck's code has had no fossil permit since Ord. 2024-21 struck the group permit in September 2024.
  • Collect only in the stream itself. Both codes ban digging into or extracting fossils from the banks above the waterline.
  • Limits differ by jurisdiction: Monmouth County allows what fits in a 12-oz can or sandwich bag per person per day, while Colts Neck caps harvest at five fossils per person per day, with a 6-inch trowel and an 18-inch screen
  • Colts Neck's Hillsdale Road entrance has been closed by police order 'until further notice' since August 2025; use the county's Boundary Road lot in Marlboro
  • Archaeological items and modern valuables found in the county park must be turned over to Park System staff within 48 hours

Big Brook Preserve · 40.3262, -74.2242

The Colts Neck entrance on Hillsdale Road is closed

If your directions point to the Hillsdale Road entrance in Colts Neck, change them. On August 26, 2025, Colts Neck Township posted a public notice that, by order of the township police and "to ensure public safety," the Hillsdale Road entrance to Big Brook Preserve is closed until further notice. The notice was last edited March 5, 2026, and was still posted when we checked on October 23, 2026. The legal way in right now is Monmouth County's Boundary Road lot at Big Brook Park in Marlboro, where the county's fossil rules apply.

One Creek, Two Rulebooks

RuleBig Brook Park (Monmouth County, Marlboro)Big Brook Preserve (Colts Neck Township)
Legal sourcePark System Supplemental Fossil RulesColts Neck Code §§ 177-43 to 177-48, as amended by Ord. 2024-21
Permit for small groupsNone for 10 or fewerNo permit (group permit repealed 2024)
Larger groupsCounty: Naturalist-led program over 10Colts Neck: no permit in the code since Ord. 2024-21 — call Recreation and Parks (732) 780-6666
Daily take limit12-oz can or sandwich bag per person5 fossils per person
Digging toolHand tools ≤ 14 in. long; ≤ 6 in. deepTrowel blade ≤ 6 in.
ScreenNo mechanical sifters; no size set≤ 18 in. square
Where you may collectStreambed; no digging into banksWithin the stream waterline only
Access in 2026Open: Boundary Road lotHillsdale Road entrance closed

Compiled October 23, 2026 from the Monmouth County Park System's Supplemental Rules, Colts Neck Code Chapter 177 Article VII as amended by Ord. 2024-21, and the township's closure notice.

Big Brook's rules are unusual because the stream is regulated twice. Monmouth County manages Big Brook Park on the Marlboro side under its own supplemental rules. Colts Neck Township manages Big Brook Preserve under a municipal ordinance whose purpose section, § 177-43, says fossils "have been taken from the park in large quantities." Colts Neck's § 177-45 also declares that all fossils in the park belong to the township, the county and the State of New Jersey, so no fossils may be removed except under the ordinance's rules.

The numbers don't line up. A sandwich bag holds dozens of small shark teeth and belemnite fragments, all legal on the county side and many times the five-fossil Colts Neck limit. The stream doesn't come with boundary markers. So if you've walked a long way upstream or down, collect as if the stricter township rule applies.

The fossils come from Late Cretaceous marine sediments; the USGS documents the Navesink Formation cropping out along Big Brook. Because the banks are off-limits under both rulebooks, everything you keep has to come from material the stream has already carried into its bed.

If you're comparing East Coast shark-tooth sites, Maryland's Calvert Cliffs State Park and Purse State Park also keep their cliffs off-limits to collectors, under state park rules rather than county and township codes.

If You Find Something That Isn't a Fossil

  1. 1

    Recognize what triggers the rule

    County Rule 9 covers 'archaeological items of historic significance' (for example, Native American points or colonial-era artifacts) and 'modern items of value' such as a ring, phone or wallet washed into the brook. Shark teeth and shells don't count.

  2. 2

    Don't keep digging

    Note where you found the item. The bank-digging and 6-inch depth limits still apply, even if you think there's more of it.

  3. 3

    Contact the Park System within 48 hours

    Call the Big Brook Park Ranger office or the Park Superintendent's office at 732-842-4000, ext. 4382. For ranger assistance at the park, call 732-577-8700.

  4. 4

    Hand it over

    Rule 9 requires the item to be turned over to Park System staff within 48 hours of the find.

  5. 5

    Share notable fossils too

    It's voluntary, but the county encourages sharing fossil finds with its naturalists at the Manasquan Reservoir Environmental Center, 732-751-9453.

When to Hunt Big Brook

Spring (Mar–May)

Good

Wait for the water to drop after heavy rain, because county Rule 12 warns that stream conditions 'can change rapidly especially from rainfall.' The park opens at 7 a.m. year round.

Summer (Jun–Aug)

Fair

As a general rule, low, warm water makes wading easiest for kids. Closing time changes seasonally, so check the Park System's Big Brook Park page before an evening visit.

Fall (Sep–Nov)

Good

The park closes at 7:30 p.m. through October 31 and 5:30 p.m. from November 1. From October 1, portions of the park are open for archery deer hunting, though all areas stay open for other public use.

Winter (Dec–Feb)

Poor

Cold water and an early close: 5:30 p.m. through January 18, then 6 p.m. from January 19 to February 8. Numb hands and swift, cold water make it a short, careful outing at best.

Before You Go

Why the Colts Neck limit counts fossils, not weight

Most fossil limits on this site are written by weight, such as Michigan's 25 pounds a year on state land, or 25 pounds a day of common invertebrate fossils on BLM land. Big Brook's township rule is written by count, five fossils per person per day. § 177-43 says fossils "have been taken from the park in large quantities." For a family that screens for an afternoon, the practical effect is to keep your five best finds and put the rest back. The county's container limit works the other way: it doesn't care how many pieces you keep, only how much room they take up.

Getting to the Stream

Use this lotBig Brook Park, Boundary Road parking lot, Marlboro. The Park System says access for fossil hunting is from this lot. The Activity Center is at 80 Boundary Road, Marlboro, NJ 07746. The map pin marks the public gravel parking lot at the end of Big Brook Road.
ClosedBig Brook Preserve's Hillsdale Road entrance (Colts Neck) has been closed until further notice since August 26, 2025.
HoursOpens daily at 7 a.m., year round. Closes at 7:30 p.m. through October 31, 5:30 p.m. November 1 to January 18, and 6 p.m. January 19 to February 8; the closing time changes seasonally.
FeeNone for fossil collecting by individuals or groups of 10 or fewer (Supplemental Rule 1)
RangersMonmouth County Park Rangers: 732-577-8700. The Park System also warns visitors not to leave valuables in their cars.

Hours and access confirmed October 23, 2026 on the Monmouth County Park System's Big Brook Park page and the Colts Neck Township notice.

Who Sets the Rules Here

Permits & Licenses

PermitRequired?Notes
Individual or small-group fossil collectingNoMonmouth County Supplemental Rule 1: 'There is no permit or fee required for individuals or for groups of 10 or fewer.' Colts Neck's ordinance no longer provides for any fossil-collecting permit: Ord. 2024-21 (adopted September 11, 2024) struck the group permit from § 177-46A and the township's authority to issue permits from § 177-47A.
Monmouth County groups larger than 10YesCounty Supplemental Rule 11 limits groups to 10 people. Larger groups must register for a Naturalist-led program through the Monmouth County Park System rather than applying for a permit.

Time & Seasonal Restrictions

Equipment Notes

What People Find Here

Penalties for Violations

← Scroll to see all columns

ViolationStatutePenalty
Collecting more than five fossils a day, using oversized tools, or extracting fossils from the bank in the Colts Neck preserveColts Neck Code §§ 177-46, 177-48 (penalty under § 1-9); maximums set by N.J.S.A. 40:49-5Restoration or repair of any damaged property, plus a fine of up to $2,000, up to 90 days in jail and/or up to 90 days of community service (state maximum for municipal ordinance violations)
Failing to turn over archaeological items of historic significance or modern valuables found in Big Brook ParkMonmouth County Park System Supplemental Fossil Rule 9; County Rule 53; N.J.S.A. 40:12-6Violating county park rules is a disorderly persons offense: a fine of up to $1,000 (N.J.S.A. 2C:43-3) and up to 6 months in jail (N.J.S.A. 2C:43-8). Items must be surrendered to Park System staff within 48 hours through the Big Brook Park Ranger office or the Superintendent's office, 732-842-4000 ext. 4382.
Digging into the stream bank, damming the stream or using mechanical sifting equipment in Big Brook ParkMonmouth County Park System Supplemental Fossil Rules 3, 4 and 7; County Rule 53; N.J.S.A. 40:12-6Disorderly persons offense: a fine of up to $1,000 (N.J.S.A. 2C:43-3) and up to 6 months in jail (N.J.S.A. 2C:43-8). Park System employees are vested with police authority and can make arrests for park rule violations. Park Rangers: 732-577-8700.

Etiquette & Leave No Trace

Distances are straight-line, not driving distance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a permit to hunt fossils at Big Brook?

No, not as an individual, a family or a group of 10 or fewer. Over 10 people in the county park means registering for a Naturalist-led program. Colts Neck dropped its group permit in 2024 (Ord. 2024-21), so its code now has no fossil permit; larger groups planning to use the township preserve should call Colts Neck Recreation and Parks at (732) 780-6666.

Is the Hillsdale Road entrance to Big Brook Preserve open?

No. Colts Neck Township posted a public notice on August 26, 2025, last edited March 5, 2026, that the Hillsdale Road entrance is 'closed until further notice' by order of the township police for public safety. Fossil hunters currently use Monmouth County's Boundary Road parking lot at Big Brook Park in Marlboro.

How many fossils can I take home from Big Brook?

It depends on which jurisdiction you're standing in. In Monmouth County's Big Brook Park you can take whatever fits in a 12-ounce can or a sandwich-size zip bag per person per day. In Colts Neck's Big Brook Preserve, § 177-46 caps it at five fossils per person per day. If you're not sure which side you're on, stick to five.

Can I dig fossils out of the creek banks?

No. Colts Neck bans extraction from the streambed walls above the waterline, and the county bans digging into the stream bank. Everything has to come from material already in the stream.

What size sifting screen is allowed at Big Brook?

No larger than 18 inches square under the Colts Neck ordinance. The county sets no screen size but bans mechanical sifters, so a hand screen of 18 inches or smaller is legal throughout.

Can I keep a dinosaur bone if I find one?

Neither rulebook mentions dinosaur bone. The county rule allows 'small paleontological items' within the 12-ounce container limit, and Colts Neck caps fossils at five a day. The county encourages visitors to show their finds to its naturalists at the Manasquan Reservoir Environmental Center (732-751-9453).

Is Big Brook safe for kids?

With care. County Rule 12 warns that stream levels 'can change rapidly especially from rainfall,' and Rule 13 notes the streams contain sharp objects. Children under 14 must be accompanied by an adult who stays within sight at all times.

Materials Found Here

New to This? Start Here

Disclaimer

Information is provided for general guidance only. Regulations change frequently. Always verify current rules with the official jurisdiction before relying on this information for legal decisions. Permitted Pursuits is not a substitute for official agency guidance. Report an error.

Sources

Last verified: · Last updated: