Corrections

Last updated: November 2026

Our Corrections Policy

Accuracy is the foundation of everything Permitted Pursuits publishes. When a material error is identified — an incorrect permit requirement, a wrong penalty figure, an outdated restriction boundary — we correct it promptly and document it here.

Minor corrections (typos, formatting, broken links) are fixed silently. Material corrections that change a factual claim are logged in this register with a description of what changed and why.

How to Report an Error

If you believe an article contains incorrect information, please email hello@permittedpursuits.com with:

  • The URL of the article
  • The specific claim you believe is incorrect
  • A link or citation to the official agency source showing the correct information

We review all reported errors within 5 business days. If the error is confirmed, we correct the article and log the change below.

Corrections Register

216 corrections affecting 206 pages, newest first. Every corrected page also shows a correction notice linking back to its entry here.

Gulf Shores: Alabama's underwater act covers only National Register-eligible material, and Gulf State Park has beach accesses in Orange Beach

What was wrong
The Gulf Shores page said Alabama's Underwater Cultural Resources Act claims shipwrecks and other cultural material unclaimed for 50 years on state submerged lands, without the statute's further condition. Its Orange Beach answer and table row said detecting is allowed in Orange Beach without mentioning that four beach accesses there belong to Gulf State Park.
What it says now
Ala. Code § 41-9-291(3) limits protected cultural resources to material unclaimed for more than 50 years that is "eligible for, or listed in, the National Register of Historic Places". The page now says so. It also says that Romar Beach, Cotton Bayou, Alabama Point East and Shell Beach are Gulf State Park access points, where Ala. Admin. Code r. 220-5-.08(6) requires the Park Manager's permission to use a metal detector, and links the new Orange Beach page.
1 page corrected

Kauai: Hawaii's state park rule allows digging in beach sand and a few pebbles by hand

What was wrong
The Kauai page summarised the state parks rule as no digging out or removing sand, rock or coral.
What it says now
HAR § 13-146-23 bars removing sand, rock or coral "except for digging in sand areas of beaches or as provided in section 13-146-32 (f)", which allows small quantities of pebbles or small rocks gathered by hand for personal use outside posted areas. On the beach itself the shoreline statutes (HRS §§ 205A-44, 171-58.5) still bar taking rock. The same wording was corrected on the Hawaiʻi Volcanoes page in `hawaii-state-land-small-pebbles`.
1 page corrected

Key West: Florida State Parks' empty-shell exception applies at Fort Zachary Taylor

What was wrong
The Key West page said there was no published exception for empty shells at Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park and told readers to ask the park before keeping even an empty shell. That contradicted the Shell Island page, which relies on the agency's statewide exception.
What it says now
FAC 62D-2.013 bans removing natural materials from state parks, but the Florida State Parks FAQ excepts "empty seashells, sea glass or shark teeth found between the water line and toe of the sand dunes in coastal parks with beaches." The page now states that policy, keeps pebbles and rock off limits, and says to ask the park how it applies on Fort Zach's rocky beach.
1 page corrected

Key West: possessing a few turtle eggs isn't always a felony

What was wrong
The page said possessing sea turtle parts, eggs or hatchlings is a third-degree felony under Fla. Stat. § 379.2431(1)(d).
What it says now
Penalties are in § 379.2431(1)(e). Possessing 11 or fewer eggs is a first-degree misdemeanor on a first offense and a third-degree felony on a repeat; more than 11 eggs, or taking or disturbing a turtle, hatchling, parts, eggs or a nest, is a third-degree felony. A penalty of $100 per egg is added. The page also now says the 20-organism marine-life limit applies only to species on FWC's marine-life list.
1 page corrected

Sanibel: empty shells aren't unlimited everywhere in Manatee County

What was wrong
A comparison row on the Sanibel page listed empty shells at Manatee County beaches as "Unlimited". That conflicted with the Bradenton Beach page.
What it says now
FWC's rule sets no limit on empty shells, but Manatee County parks limit shell removal to a one-gallon bucket per person per day (County Code § 2-24-3(1)(b)), and Holmes Beach City Code § 66-26 makes it unlawful to remove sand or shell from its beach area, as the Bradenton Beach page records. The row now says so.
1 page corrected

Utah overview: the petrified wood limit doesn't apply in parts of the Moab area

What was wrong
The overview gave 25 lb plus one piece a day and 250 lb a year as the petrified wood rule on all BLM land in Utah.
What it says now
BLM's 2016 supplementary rules ban gathering petrified wood in the Colorado Riverway and at high-visitation sites in the Labyrinth Rim/Gemini Bridges area near Moab. The overview now says so. We found no later amendment; BLM Moab can confirm the current status.
1 page corrected

Hawaiʻi Volcanoes page: state land does have a small pebble allowance

What was wrong
The page said state parks ban removing rock and "We found no public place in Hawaii where taking rock is allowed", and that accidental carry-off is the only exception left to the shoreline statutes. It described the shoreline penalty as a fine plus restoration costs, and tied the shell exception to non-commercial use in the statute.
What it says now
HAR 13-146-32(f) and 13-221-28(e) allow "small quantities of pebbles or small rocks by hand for personal use" on state park and unencumbered state land, except in posted areas. The shoreline statutes still ban rock and sand. HRS § 205A-44(a) also excepts shells, driftwood, beach glass, seaweed and cultural practices; the commercial shell license comes from DLNR. HRS § 205A-32 sets a fine up to $100,000 or the cost of restoration, plus up to $10,000 a day.
1 page corrected

Rockhound State Park: the trust-land rule covers "valuable" rocks, and entry needs a permit

What was wrong
The page said collecting rocks or minerals on New Mexico state trust land is prohibited.
What it says now
19.2.19.18(A)(15) NMAC bars "collecting valuable rocks or minerals", and 19.2.19.9 requires a recreational access permit ($35 a year) to enter trust land at all. The page now says so.
1 page corrected

Oregon Beach Bill Guide: marine gardens, reserves and refuges rest on different rules

What was wrong
The Guide said loose agates and empty shells in marine gardens "still fall under" the gallon limits, and that reserves, marine protected areas, research reserves and refuges allow no collecting under one rule. It also gave the state-park found-property threshold as more than $250.
What it says now
The gallon rule has no marine-garden exclusion, but that is our reading, and at Haystack Rock the city's awareness program says collecting is prohibited. Reserves rest on OAR 736-029-0040 and refuges on 50 CFR 27.61. OAR 736-010-0040(16) says $250 or more.
1 page corrected

Revere Beach: the State Archaeologist permit also covers town land

What was wrong
The page described M.G.L. c. 9, § 27C as covering land owned or controlled by the Commonwealth, and contrasted that with other beaches.
What it says now
The statute covers land owned or controlled by "the commonwealth, its agencies or political subdivisions", as well as historic or archaeological landmarks and certain restricted lands, so it can reach town beaches too. The page now quotes the full scope.
1 page corrected

South Platte and Colorado overview: the forest's guide does address the canyon, and Fairplay sells a permit

What was wrong
The South Platte page said the Forest Service hadn't published how it treats casual panning in Eleven Mile Canyon, and cited Fairplay's 2022 fee schedule, which is no longer online. The Colorado overview said no Colorado agency issues a gold-panning licence.
What it says now
The Pike and San Isabel forests' June 2019 guide says some areas may be excluded even from non-commercial activities, with the South Platte below Elevenmile Reservoir and withdrawn areas among its examples. The page's verdict stays unclear. Fairplay's current schedule (effective January 1, 2024) charges $20 a day, $50 a week or $125 a year. The overview now says no state agency issues a licence, while the Town of Fairplay sells a local permit.
2 pages corrected

Ocean City: Assateague State Park's detecting season comes from park rules, not COMAR

What was wrong
The Ocean City page attributed Assateague State Park's rule that detecting is allowed only from the day after Labor Day to May 30, on the ocean side of the primary dune, to COMAR 08.07.06.18.
What it says now
COMAR 08.07.06.18D allows detecting for modern coins and jewelry on designated Maryland Park Service swimming beaches with the Service's permission, outside 9 a.m.–dusk from May 30 to Labor Day and "at the discretion of the park manager". The Labor Day–May 30 season and the ocean-side-of-the-dune limit are Assateague State Park's own posted rules under that discretion. The page now cites both; the practical rule is unchanged.
1 page corrected

North Carolina detecting overview: town beach rules are often civil, not criminal

What was wrong
The overview's landowner table said breaking a town beach ordinance is "generally a Class 3 misdemeanor" with a fine capped at $50 unless the ordinance sets more (G.S. 14-4(a)).
What it says now
Several towns enforce their beach rules with civil penalties instead: Topsail Beach charges a $100 civil charge for unattended or unfilled holes, Surf City a $50 civil penalty after a warning citation, and Atlantic Beach a $100 civil penalty after a warning, with its code saying civil-penalty provisions "shall not be enforced by criminal penalties". G.S. 14-4(a) applies only where an ordinance is enforced as a crime. The table now says the penalty varies by town.
1 page corrected

Gooseberry Falls: the Minnesota DNR's no-permit statement is about gold panning, not agates

What was wrong
The page said that outside state parks and scientific and natural areas, the Minnesota DNR "requires no permit for low-impact recreational collecting on state-owned lake and stream beds", quoted the DNR's geology page as banning collecting only in "state parks and state scientific and natural areas", and said Michigan's DNR extends the 25 lb rule to Great Lakes bottomland.
What it says now
The DNR's "The State does not require a permit for this type of recreational activity in the state-owned beds" answers a question about recreational gold panning; the DNR publishes no rule on taking agates from state-owned lake beds, so the page now says to ask. The geology page now reads "Rock collecting is not allowed in the state parks, state recreation areas, and state scientific and natural areas." The Great Lakes statement is EGLE's ("state-owned and public trust lands"), not the DNR's.
1 page corrected

Grand Marais: the public-trust line isn't the 601.5 ft elevation

What was wrong
The page described Michigan's public-trust land as Lake Superior bottomlands "below the ordinary high-water mark (601.5 ft)".
What it says now
601.5 ft is the ordinary high-water elevation the Great Lakes Submerged Lands Act sets for its own regulatory purposes (MCL 324.32502). In Glass v. Goeckel (2005) the Michigan Supreme Court found reliance on that act "misplaced" for the public trust and treated the ordinary high-water mark as a common-law line found from conditions on the ground. The page now says so.
1 page corrected

Edisto Beach shark-tooth page: map pin moved from a house onto the beach

What was wrong
The map pin sat at 32.4794, -80.3348, the town centroid OpenStreetMap uses for Edisto Beach, which falls on a house on Billow Street, about a mile from the sand. Distances to Folly Beach (26 mi) and Huntington Beach State Park (103 mi) were measured from it.
What it says now
The pin is now on the town beach at Beach Access 15 (32.4865, -80.3200), inside the OpenStreetMap beach and town-limit polygons and outside Edisto Beach State Park. Distances recomputed from it: Folly Beach 25 mi, Huntington Beach State Park 102 mi.
1 page corrected

Arizona rockhounding overview: national forests don't share one 10 lb rule

What was wrong
The overview said national forests in Arizona ("Prescott, Tonto, Coconino and others") allow rockhounding with no permit, "generally up to 10 lb/day", and its checklist said "about 10 lb/day on national forests". The only source was the Prescott National Forest's own page.
What it says now
Each national forest sets its own rule. Prescott publishes about 10 lb/day with no permit. Coconino publishes no allowance: its Red Rock Ranger District guide says "ALL plants, rocks, artifacts, insects, and animals should be left where you found them", the Forest Service's national guide (FS-1091) routes personal collecting through a free use permit, and 36 CFR 293.14(c) bars permits for common-variety mineral materials in wilderness. The overview's table, summary and checklist now say so, and the Sedona page covers Coconino.
1 page corrected

Presque Isle State Park: penalty, legal basis of the approval rule, artifact rule, Gull Point closure and history corrected

What was wrong
The page called the approval requirement a 'statewide DCNR rule' and gave the penalty for detecting without approval or in a closed area as a citation from park staff with no statute. It left out the state-park regulation against removing or disturbing historical artifacts without written permission (17 Pa. Code § 11.209(a)(8)) and DCNR's requirement to report finds that will be taken from the park. It said off-season beach detecting was 'guaranteed', in places from the 'day after Labor Day' to the 'day before Memorial Day'. It said the whole Gull Point Natural Area was closed and to give it a wide berth, without mentioning the open Gull Point Trail. It said Perry's vessels were built 'here' at a 'historic shipyard' on the peninsula, with an 'encampment', and that War of 1812-era material had been reported there. It said Presque Isle drew about four million visitors a year by itself, was the state's most-visited park by a wide margin and Pennsylvania's only National Natural Landmark of its kind, with eleven named beaches. It placed the park office separately from the Tom Ridge Environmental Center and called Peninsula Drive the only way onto the spit.
What it says now
The approval rule is DCNR's published state-park metal-detecting policy, not a regulation (17 Pa. Code ch. 11 has no detector section); it is enforceable through the park's closure and restriction rules (§ 11.208). Entering a closed area, detecting or digging against posted restrictions, or removing or disturbing a historical artifact or sand without written permission (§§ 11.209(a)(1), 11.209(a)(8), 11.211(a)(2)) is a summary offense under § 11.223 and 18 Pa.C.S. § 7506: up to a $300 fine (§ 1101) and 90 days in jail (§ 1105), and you can be ordered to leave the park (§ 11.205). DCNR says to report items found that will be removed from the park and, for historical objects, to contact the park manager and consult the PHMC. Beaches and lake swimming areas are open to detecting within a reasonable distance of shore from the Tuesday after Labor Day until the Saturday prior to Memorial Day, unless posted otherwise, still with prior approval. The easternmost part of Gull Point (the State Park Natural Area) is closed to all public use April 1–November 30; the Gull Point Trail is open, but from April 1 to October 31 you must stay on the trail surface. Perry's vessels were built on the mainland in Erie at the mouth of Cascade Creek; Little Bay was the fleet's temporary home and Presque Isle's shores protected it during construction (winters of 1812–1814). The History Code entry now cites 37 Pa.C.S. §§ 506 and 511, including Commonwealth-owned submerged land at Misery Bay, where DCNR says the Lawrence and Niagara hulls were sunk. DCNR reports about 4 million visits a year to Presque Isle and Erie Bluffs combined; the park is a National Natural Landmark of about 3,200 acres with eight numbered beaches plus the Mill Road beaches. The park office is inside the Tom Ridge Environmental Center; access is by PA 832 (Peninsula Drive) or by boat. The page also adds DCNR's underwater-detecting rule and Presque Isle's diving rules (certified divers register at the Public Safety Building; no snorkeling), and an alternative to Headlands Beach State Park, Ohio.
1 page corrected

Emerald Hollow Mine: state mining permit, prices, hours, record-emerald attributions and history corrected

What was wrong
The page said no government permit 'exists' for the site and called fee-digging here 'state-sanctioned'. It attributed the 1,438-carat stone (calling it the 'Carolina Emerald') and the 1,869-carat crystal to the 'North American Emerald Mine (historic Rist Mine)' next door and the Carolina Emperor to an 'Adams Mine', described both as actively worked posted private claims, and gave the Carolina Emperor as 64.83 carats from a 310-carat rough found in 2009. It said visitors keep everything under a 'stated policy' with no buyback clause, that sluice, creek and dig-site material together documented 60+ species, and that prices change with seasonal promotions. It listed the mine as closed on Christmas Eve (not New Year's Day), said everyone on the property needs a permit and said the § 145-8 designation exists because of this deposit. The history had George Warren finding the stones while playing, hiddenite 'first identified and named here in 1880', and Mike Watkins opening the fee-dig 'across the creek' in 1986; the geology described 600-million-year-old pegmatite dikes in Precambrian gneiss.
What it says now
Visitors need no government permit, but the mine operates under NC DEQ mining permit 02-04 (Emerald Hollow Mine LLC, active, first issued April 29, 1986, 47 acres); visitors work under it through the operator's day permit. The pricing page lists $30 adults (15+), $10 children (4–14), $27 seniors (50+) and military/veterans, free for 3 and under, all day with tools; the FAQ page still lists $25/$10 and a 10% discount, so the page says to confirm by phone. Permits are required for everyone at the sluiceway, creek or dig site; under-18s need a paying adult with an equal permit. Hours: every day except Thanksgiving, Christmas Day and New Year's Day, 8:30–5 Mon–Thu and 8:30–6 Fri–Sun. The page now says the mine's published rules set no buyback or sharing condition, that sluice buckets are enriched with gemstones from all over the world (only the creek's educational section is salted, on program days; the dig site is not), and that the mine lists more than 60 naturally occurring gems and minerals on the property. Creek-bank, roped-area and permit-revocation rules were added. Per NC DNCR, the largest emerald found in North Carolina was a 1,438-carat specimen from Hiddenite and the 'Carolina Emerald' is owned by Tiffany & Co.; per NCpedia an 1,869-carat crystal was found in late 2003 at a mine in Hiddenite; per CBS News the 64.82-carat cut Carolina Emperor came from the Adams family farm. None is reported as an Emerald Hollow find, and the mine attributions were removed. George Warren found the stones while plowing his father's field; hiddenite was identified in 1879 and named for W.E. Hidden. The geology now cites NCpedia (emeralds in pockets of quartz veins) and Smithsonian geologist Michael Wise via CBS (beryllium-bearing fluids through chromium-bearing rock).
1 page corrected

Sanibel Island shelling: Lee County's live-shell rule bans possession only in county waters; 1995 ban was a state rule; Turner Beach is outside the city and under the county park code

What was wrong
The page said FWC Rule 68B-26.004 prohibits harvesting or possessing live shellfish anywhere in Lee County, and that the rule took effect on March 1, 2002. It said Sanibel's original 1995 ban was a city ban that Ord. No. 17-001 replaced. It applied the City's '$500 fine and 60 days in jail for a first offense' to removing natural objects from the J.N. "Ding" Darling refuge, under 50 CFR 27.61 alone. It listed Turner Beach on Captiva as a City of Sanibel park where Sanibel's ordinance and the FWC rule both apply, and said empty shells, driftwood and sea glass could be taken with no permit everywhere, without mentioning Lee County Code § 20-23(a). It said beach parking pay stations had been offline since Hurricane Ian and payment was by mobile phone only, and that the license requirement for live shells was moot on Sanibel.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed' for empty shells: Sanibel Code § 74-184(b) exempts 'the collection of shells and specimens' from the beach-disturbance bans except as the state live-shelling rule (F.A.C. 68B-26.002–68B-26.004) and the city ordinance prohibit, and 68B-26.004(3) lets a person in Lee County harvest a shell that holds no live shellfish. 68B-26.004(1) bars harvesting a live shellfish anywhere in Lee County and possessing one 'in or on the Florida Waters within Lee County that are seaward of the mean high water line'; inside the city, § 74-183 also bans possession. The county-wide ban has been in force since March 1, 2002 and was recodified as 68B-26.004 effective September 1, 2013. The 1995 ban was a state rule the City petitioned the Marine Fisheries Commission for, covering Sanibel out to the city limits (half a mile offshore) from January 1, 1995; the City adopted § 74-183 by Ord. No. 17-001 on April 4, 2017. Refuge violations are punished under 16 U.S.C. § 668dd(f): up to 1 year and a title-18 fine for a knowing violation, otherwise up to 180 days. Turner Beach is owned by Lee County and maintained by the City but lies just outside the city limits, so 68B-26.004 and Lee County Code Ch. 20 apply there, not § 74-183. On Lee County park property, § 20-23(a) bars removing beach sand, rocks, live shells, downed timber or other wood or materials without a Director's special written permit and § 20-23(d) bars taking live shellfish without State authorization ($300/$400/$500 under § 20-32); whether Ch. 20 applies at Bowman's Beach (county-owned, city-run) is unclear, and the page says to call Lee County Parks. Visitors without a City beach parking permit pay through the City's mobile payment system. A saltwater fishing license matters on Sanibel for the excepted live species such as coquinas.m. and 7 a.m. The dredging and geometry claims were removed; the page now reports that all beach parks reopened after Hurricanes Ian, Helene and Milton (Turner Beach last, April 25, 2025) and the City's buried-debris warning.
1 page corrected

Venice Beach fossil hunting: offshore beds are state land, not county foreshore; fish vertebrae and ray barbs aren't exempt; Caspersen status and permit details corrected

What was wrong
The page said the Sarasota County ordinance reaches the offshore bone beds, and that the ordinances draw an exact line between loose surf-zone hash (exempt) and compacted sand (a misdemeanor), with sifting 'plainly' covered as 'accepted practice'. It stated the City and County exemptions for washed-up shark teeth without their 'except as otherwise prohibited by federal, state, or local laws' qualifier, and said shark teeth could be kept with 'no limit'. It listed stingray barbs as permit-exempt and fossil fish vertebrae without saying they need a permit. It described a 'fifty-year antiquities rule' under Chapter 267. It said the permit processing time was not published, and that the statute set a '$5 per year' fee. It said Caspersen Beach Park's access road and parking were destroyed by Hurricanes Debby, Helene and Milton, with no utilities and reopening projected for 2027. It said the city and county penalty structures differ, said parking was free at Brohard Park and Service Club Park, dated the source rock to the 'Miocene–Pliocene' Peace River Formation 'of the Hawthorn Group', and placed the map pin about half a kilometre south of the pier.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed' for washed-up shark and ray teeth: City of Venice Code § 46-62(b)(1) and Sarasota County Code § 90-33(a)(16)d exempt 'the collection of shells, sharks' teeth, and other natural materials that wash up' on the beach, 'except as otherwise prohibited by federal, state, or local laws', and the Florida Museum of Natural History says shark and ray teeth from state land may be kept without a permit. Neither code mentions tools; the page now labels sifting in the surf zone as its reading of the exemption and gives the City of Venice, (941) 486-2626, and Sarasota County, 311 / 941-861-5000, for confirmation. The county rule covers 'any foreshore area located immediately waterward thereof where waves crest and break'; the sea floor beyond is state submerged land (out to 9 nautical miles in the Gulf, per the museum), where teeth are exempt and other vertebrate fossils need the Florida Fossil Permit. State land here is the beach below mean high water and the sea floor; on city- or county-owned dry sand the state program doesn't apply, but the local codes bar removing fossils other than washed-up material. Ray dental plates are teeth; ray tail spines are not named in the exemption, so the page says to ask the museum, (352) 273-1821. Fossil fish vertebrae are vertebrate fossils and need the permit on state land. Chapter 267 gives the state title to historic objects abandoned on state-owned land and sovereignty submerged land, with no age threshold. Fla. Stat. § 1004.576 caps the application fee at $5; the $5-per-year charge, the up-to-four-weeks processing time and the 60-day claim period after reporting are the museum's. Caspersen now follows Sarasota County's wording: the Harbor Drive access washed out in the 2024 storm season; restrooms, vehicle parking and playground are closed until repairs; open 6 a.m.–10 p.m. to pedestrians and bicycles from South Brohard Park or the Venetian Waterway Park Trail at the Festival Grounds. Venice Beach, Service Club Park and South Brohard Park are city-owned and county-managed, so both codes likely apply (§§ 90-32(7)–(8), 90-39); the penalty cap is $500 and 60 days under either. Free parking is confirmed only for Venice Beach. The source is the Miocene Peace River Formation (Sarasota County Water Atlas). The page adds the 2026 USACE Venice Shore Protection Project (about 3.2 miles renourished from south of Venice Inlet to south of the pier; sand placement ended 8/16/26, remaining work expected through late October), the dune statutes (Fla. Stat. §§ 161.053(2)(a), 161.242) and the May–October sea turtle nesting season, and § 46-64(3) (no swimming or surfing within 150 feet of the pier centerline). Unsourced claims about the best stretches, dive depths, local branding and seasonal resupply were removed. The map pin moved to the shore end of the Venice Fishing Pier.
1 page corrected

Virginia Beach Oceanfront: corrections to state-owned bottom, drift property, dune law, military shoreline, refuge penalty, lighthouse access and Dictator history (City Code not re-read)

What was wrong
The page said Virginia had no general finder-reporting statute and that the Antiquities Act did not reach detectorists on the city beach, without mentioning that the bottom below mean low water is Commonwealth property and that underwater historic property belongs to the Commonwealth and needs a VMRC permit to recover. It described drift metal from the Virginia Capes wrecks as a find without the drift-property statute. It said the continuous public sand ran from Croatan north and that Sandbridge was the next city beach, without saying that Camp Pendleton and the Navy's Dam Neck installation lie between them, and told readers Croatan, the resort strand, the North End and Sandbridge were 'all city, all open'. It left out the state Coastal Primary Sand Dunes and Beaches Act. It gave the Back Bay NWR penalty as a 'federal citation; equipment subject to forfeiture'. It put Little Island parking at $3/day for residents and $5/day for non-residents and Sandbridge 'roughly 10 miles' south. It said Cape Henry was reached through 'Gate 8 at 89th and Atlantic' for the lighthouse and 'the historic trail', with a background check filed at least five days ahead. It said the Virginia Aquarium 'monitors and marks every nest'. It said the Dictator was bound for West Hartlepool with Georgia pine, wrecked off roughly 25th Street, and that her figurehead stood for sixty years. It placed First Landing State Park's boundary at 64th Street.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed' for the dry city beach (DHR: 'there is no general permitting process for metal detecting in Virginia'). A beachfront owner's rights extend to the mean low-water mark 'but no farther' (Va. Code § 28.2-1202(A)) and the shores of the sea remain Commonwealth property (§ 28.2-1200); underwater historic property is 'the exclusive property of the Commonwealth', and recovering it without a VMRC permit is a Class 1 misdemeanor with forfeiture (§ 10.1-2214). DHR says Atlantic coastal-zone bottomlands are state property and need permits for artifact removal. Drift property left on land with no indicia of ownership belongs, as against all but the true owner, to the landowner (§ 55.1-2700). South of Croatan the shore is Camp Pendleton (Virginia National Guard) and then Dam Neck; city beach resumes at Sandbridge, about 7 miles south (Little Island Park about 11). Beachfront owners hold title to mean low water and renourished land goes to the adjacent owner subject to the public's same right of use (§ 28.2-1202(C)); whether that use includes digging isn't established, so the page says to ask the City (Resort Management 757-385-4800 or 311). Virginia Beach is covered by the Coastal Primary Sand Dunes and Beaches Act (§ 28.2-1403): no altering a dune's contour or destroying its vegetation without a permit (§ 28.2-1408), a Class 1 misdemeanor (§ 28.2-1418) and a civil penalty of up to $25,000 a day (§ 28.2-1420). Back Bay NWR ('Metal detecting is not permitted at any time of year'): a fine under title 18 and up to 180 days, or 1 year for a knowing violation (16 U.S.C. 668dd(f)), with seized property forfeited on conviction (668dd(g)). Sandbridge parking is $4/day ($10 overnight) May 1–Sept. 30 and free Oct. 1–April 30, with no resident rate. Cape Henry Lighthouse, on Fort Story (per Preservation Virginia): every party member 18+ submits a SECNAV 5512 form 5–30 days before the ticket date, everyone over 16 shows a REAL ID or passport, visitors park and ride a shuttle from the base gate and must be accompanied by lighthouse staff; the Gate 8 location and trail access were removed, and 89th Street is given as an approximate boundary. The City manages nest monitoring through the Virginia Aquarium (DWR). The Dictator, carrying yellow pine from Pensacola to England, wrecked about 300 yards from shore near present-day 37th Street; the figurehead was preserved for 62 years and the Norwegian Lady statues were erected September 21, 1962. First Landing is at 2500 Shore Drive on the Chesapeake Bay (64th Street is its Narrows boat ramp). The map pin moved to the beach at 25th Street. The Virginia Beach City Code (Municode) could not be re-read in this pass; the page's existing City Code citations were left as they were and its verified date was not changed.
Sources
1 page corrected

Huron-Manistee National Forests: Kirtland's warbler closure runs to August 15, ramp and fiddlehead ban on state land, fee and season details corrected

What was wrong
The page said occupied Kirtland's warbler breeding areas are closed May 1 – July 15 (taken from the Forest Service's tour page) and cited only 36 CFR 261.53 and 261.1b for the closure penalty, and 36 CFR 261.6(h) and 261.1b for the forest-products penalty. It did not mention that Michigan DNR bars taking fiddleheads, ramps and other plants killed on harvest from state land. It said all Forest Service-operated trailheads, launches and picnic areas charge a $5 day-use fee and that walking in from a road pull-off does not trigger it. It put black morels in late April as the first of the season, called Verpa bohemica the most common early false morel, said Pacific Northwest forests usually set a gallon a day, and placed Mesick inside the Manistee National Forest.
What it says now
Signed Forest Order R904-14-20 closes the posted Kirtland's warbler areas from May 1 through August 15 under 36 CFR 261.53(a); the page now gives August 15 everywhere, notes the tour page's July 15, and cites the order, 36 CFR 261.53(a), 16 U.S.C. 551 and 18 U.S.C. 3559 and 3571 for the penalty (18 U.S.C. 3571 added to the 261.6(h) row). On DNR land, fiddleheads of ferns, ramps (wild onions) and all plants cut or killed on harvest may not be taken from public lands, and state-land foods are personal use only; whether the forest's 'edible material' exemption covers digging whole ramps is unpublished, so the page says to ask the Supervisor's Office. Some Forest Service-operated sites charge a $5 day-use fee (cash or check only), and many activities are free. Per the DNR, Verpa bohemica appears in late April and black morels, usually the first true morels, fruit in early to mid-May. Mt. Hood is given as one Pacific Northwest forest with a 1-gallon-a-day figure, and Mesick is described as on the northern edge of the Manistee National Forest. The page also now lists the bald eagle (Feb 1 – July 15), Mason County piping plover (Apr 15 – Aug 31) and former bombing range closures.
1 page corrected

Peace River: tool limits, riverbed title, permit obligations, closed riverbed sections and access-point managers corrected

What was wrong
The page said no published limit on shovel or screen size applied on the river and recommended a round-point shovel worked in knee-deep gravel, adding that 'no size limit applies on the river itself'. It cited Fla. Stat. § 253.03 as the law making the riverbed state sovereignty land. It told permit holders to carry a permit 'card' without mentioning photo ID, described the reporting and 60-day rules without the end-of-permit-year deadline or the duty to keep the fossils during that time, and said the permit is issued under § 1004.575. It did not mention that riverbed under a water management district is closed to collecting or that county-owned stretches follow county rules. The access-point table listed DeSoto Veterans Memorial Park's manager as a 'Public park', Crews Park as a 'Local park' and Gardner as a 'Public ramp' without a source, and applied 'teeth free, bone with permit' to park land. It cited an older FDEP trail guide (Guide 5) and described the trail as running 67 miles from Fort Meade without noting that FDEP's access-point list runs from Bartow (mile 0) to SR 70 (mile 70).
What it says now
The Florida Museum allows surface collecting, hand-fanning and small single-handed tools; motorized, mechanical-excavating and dredging equipment need DEP permission, up to a gallon of sediment a day may be screen-washed, and an area should not look disturbed afterward. UF Regulation 7.0541(4)(b) treats hand tools longer than two feet, more than a gallon of vertebrate fossils at one site, or more than three days (24 hours) at a site a year as systematic collection needing a permit; the page now recommends a short-handled scoop or trowel and says to ask the museum whether the limits bind teeth-only collectors. The riverbed's state ownership now rests on Fla. Const. Art. X, § 11 and Fla. Admin. Code R. 18-21.003. Permit holders must carry the permit and photo ID (7.0541(8)(d)), report vertebrate finds by the end of the permit year (8)(c), keep reported fossils other than shark teeth for 60 days (8)(b), after which unclaimed finds are released (10); the permit is issued under § 1004.576, each adult needs their own, and minors may hold one or collect with a permitted adult. Water-management-district riverbed is closed and county stretches follow county rules (Florida Museum FAQ). DeSoto Veterans Memorial Park is shown as DeSoto County (FDEP guide Access Point 13: DeSoto County Park); Crews Park, Pioneer Park and Gardner now say the owner is not confirmed, and the table notes that park land follows county or city rules. The page cites the current FDEP guide (Guide 6), and unsourced seasonal-water, put-in and find claims were removed.
1 page corrected

Petoskey State Park: penalty citations, bottomland attribution, Recreation Passport order and day-use hours corrected

What was wrong
The page cited the penalty as 'MCL 324.504' and the eviction rule as 'Rule 29', and said 'the DNR can seize material taken over the limit'. It said the DNR had stated that the 25-pound limit reaches Great Lakes bottomlands, attributing that to a 'DNR enforcement position' in the 2015 Northport case, and described the finder digging the 93-lb stone free with a trowel from shallow water and the DNR 'making the point publicly' about bottomlands; that line came from the CBS Detroit/AP reporter, not a DNR statement. It said city and township beaches were 'not covered by the state rule'. It gave no legal basis for the Recreation Passport requirement, said day-use hours applied to 'the Petoskey beach' without saying which area is the day-use area, and omitted that the day-use lot closes in winter. It listed Charlevoix stone and Favosites as separate finds, said the Traverse Group bedrock explains why the city, bay and park share the name and that the park 'sits almost on top of it', named granite, basalt and banded gneiss among the erratics, put Sleeping Bear Dunes 70 miles away, cited the NPS penalty only to 36 CFR 1.3, and described the Sleeping Bear gathering allowance as 'a gallon'.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed' (no permit; 25 lb a year under R 299.922(hh)). The penalty is a state civil infraction with a civil fine up to $500 under MCL 324.504(14), and R 299.929 allows eviction for not less than 48 hours or as set by court order. The seizure line now reads: in 2015 DNR officers collected a 93-lb stone taken over the limit (news report); the case retells only what the report says (found in September near Northport, lugged to shore, taken home to Copemish for lawn display, collected in December 2015, the finder cooperated). R 299.922 covers land owned or under the control of the DNR; the bottomland point is now attributed to EGLE, which describes the 25-lb limit as covering state-owned and public-trust lands (its 2026 fossils pages: 'state parks and shorelines'); public-trust bottomland lies below the ordinary high-water mark, 579.8 ft for Lake Michigan (MCL 324.32502). On city and township beaches the dry beach follows municipal rules, while EGLE says the limit applies on public-trust shoreline and bottomland. Land Use Order 5.16a(1)(a) requires a Recreation Passport for motor-vehicle entry to Petoskey SP (walkers and cyclists need none); rates follow the DNR passport page ($15 at plate renewal, two-year $29, $5 convenience fee otherwise, non-Michigan $42 annual or $12 daily, up $1 from Jan. 1, 2026). The beach-house swim and picnic area is a day-use area (R 299.921(c), including a 450-ft buffer), closed 10 p.m.–8 a.m. unless posted (R 299.927(a)); campgrounds are closed to non-campers over the same hours, and the day-use lot typically closes early November through early spring. Favosites is listed once as the tabulate coral colloquially called Charlevoix stone (EGLE). The stone is named for the city of Petoskey, near which the Traverse Group bedrock lies (EGLE), and is the state stone under MCL 2.16 (1965 Act 89). Erratics are described only as glacial erratics from Canada. Sleeping Bear Dunes is about 60 miles southwest; its penalty cites 36 CFR 1.3, 18 U.S.C. 1865 and 18 U.S.C. 3571(b)(6); its compendium allows up to a gallon of designated fruits, nuts and edible mushrooms (a bushel for apples and pears) and designates no rocks or fossils. Posted piping-plover closures at Fisherman's Island and other listed parks run April 15–August 31 (Land Use Order 5.7).
1 page corrected

Big Brook Preserve: Colts Neck group permit repealed in 2024; county penalty, hours and section numbers corrected

What was wrong
The page said Colts Neck requires a fossil-collecting permit for groups of 15 or more ($25 for 15–29, $50 for 30+), issued daily and valid 8 a.m. (or 6 a.m.) to dusk, carried by the group leader and applied for by email and mailed check, and cited the township's 2019 Rules and Policies and a 2021 PDF of Chapter 177. It cited the Big Brook Preserve rules as § 177-46(A)(5), (6) and (7). It gave county park violations no penalty beyond removal from the park. It said Big Brook Park closes at 8 p.m. through October 4 and 7:30 p.m. from October 5, and that the brook drains to the Navesink River. It did not mention archery deer hunting in the park.
What it says now
Colts Neck Ordinance No. 2024-21, adopted September 11, 2024, struck the group permit, its daily validity and carry rule from § 177-46A and the township's authority to issue permits from § 177-47A; the township code now has no fossil-collecting permit. The remaining rules were renumbered § 177-46A(1) (group buses only at the Hillsdale Road lot, now closed), (2) stream waterline only, (3) 6-inch trowel and 18-inch screen, (4) five fossils per person per day. No permit or fee is needed for individuals or county groups of 10 or fewer (Supplemental Rule 1); larger county groups need a Naturalist-led program. Violating county park rules is a disorderly persons offense (County Rule 53; N.J.S.A. 40:12-6), punishable by up to $1,000 (N.J.S.A. 2C:43-3) and up to 6 months in jail (N.J.S.A. 2C:43-8), and Park System employees have police authority. Big Brook Park opens at 7 a.m. daily and closes at 7:30 p.m. through October 31, 5:30 p.m. November 1–January 18 and 6 p.m. January 19–February 8. Portions of the park are open for archery deer hunting October 1, 2026 to February 20, 2027, with all areas open for other public use. Big Brook drains into the Swimming River Reservoir. The map pin moved to the public gravel lot at the end of Big Brook Road.
1 page corrected

Folly Beach: city hole and shovel rule, county pier, Hobby License scope, fees and penalty corrected

What was wrong
The page said city beach rules cap holes at '1 foot', require every hole filled before you leave and ban only metal shovels, and cited the penalty only as 'City of Folly Beach ordinances (published beach rules)'. It described the city's jurisdiction as including 'the pier area' and did not say Folly Beach Pier is a county facility. It framed the island as a city middle with county parks at 'both ends', as if the county parks were outside the city. It said Hobby License licensees may not use 'sifting' and that 'state jurisdiction' begins at mean low water, stated 'three statute miles' as the legal limit, and gave no license fees. It gave the § 54-7-810 penalty without saying each day is a separate offense or that the license may be revoked. It left out the ban on walking on groins and cited no ordinance for the dunes rule. It called Lighthouse Inlet's no-removal reading settled without noting that CCPRC promotes beachcombing there. It stated without a source that small black teeth are 'the site's signature find', that fossil ray plates, fish vertebrae and turtle shell turn up, that Folly is 'one of the Charleston area's best-known shark-tooth beaches', that the Charleston area's sediments are 'famous' for megalodon teeth, that storms and tropical systems concentrate fossils, and that renourishment keeps delivering teeth.
What it says now
City Code § 151.09 bars any hole deeper than 12 inches, requires the sand restored before leaving and no later than 30 minutes before sunset, and bans shovels other than those intended for children and metal shovels of any type; violations carry the general penalty in § 10.99 (the city says fines run up to $1,092). Folly Beach Pier and its plaza at 101 East Arctic Avenue are a Charleston County Parks facility whose rules bar removing plants, animals or artifacts, with CCPRC's agency rules applying; the city's jurisdiction covers the beach either side of the pier and the Washout. Folly Beach County Park and Lighthouse Inlet Heritage Preserve are inside city limits (Census TIGER), so CCPRC's 'any rock, stone, plant, wood, or other materials' removal rule applies on top of the city's beach rules. Lighthouse Inlet keeps the no-removal reading; CCPRC's listing promotes 'beachcombing' there but publishes no exception, so the page says to ask CCPRC at (843) 795-4386; it is a county facility, not an SC DNR Heritage Trust preserve. The Hobby License area starts at the mean low-water mark (§ 54-7-670(A)); the license allows recovery by hand of exposed objects only (§ 54-7-670(F)), and SCIAA says it does not permit tools, digging, movement of sediment or collecting above the waterline. SCIAA describes offshore jurisdiction as three statute miles; the statute uses three geographical miles. Fees are $5 resident / $10 nonresident for six months and $18 / $36 for two years (§ 54-7-670(B)). Violations are a misdemeanor with a fine up to $50, each day a separate offense, and the license may be revoked (§ 54-7-810(A)). Walking on any groin is banned (§ 151.07(A)); being on the dunes without a city permit is unlawful (§ 151.02). SCPRT lists Folly among five SC beaches favored by shark-tooth seekers, says giant finds are rare and most teeth are small, and attributes renourishment-driven deposits to dredging stirring up buried particles; the page says we found no official study of the source. Reported finds now follow SCIAA ('mineralized shark teeth, animal bones or plant remains'). The verdict stays 'allowed' on the city beach. The map pin moved to the city beach just east of the pier, where SCPRT suggests starting.
Sources
1 page corrected

Dahlonega: the Forest Plan bars digging tools for gold panning; dead Forest Service source replaced; penalty, trespass and mine prices corrected

What was wrong
The page said the Chattahoochee National Forest allows free gold panning with a pan and a small hand shovel or trowel, and presented the trowel and the ban on in-stream sluices and suction dredges as the forest's current guidance, citing a Forest Service web page that no longer exists (it now redirects). It did not cite the Forest Plan, gave the federal penalty as an unspecified fine, cited 36 CFR 261.9 without a paragraph, and did not say that mining claims can't be staked on the forest. It said written permission is needed on private creek frontage or it's trespass. It said Crisson Gold Mine's prices couldn't be confirmed, and gave Consolidated Gold Mine's prices without tax or its holiday closures. It said much of the creek frontage near town is private without a source, and said the gold here is flour-sized and flat and that black sand turns up in every pan.
What it says now
The binding Land and Resource Management Plan (2004) allows recreational gold panning on the forest with no permit, provided that neither hand nor power digging tools are used, collection does not conflict with existing mineral rights and is not prohibited elsewhere in the Plan (standard FW-169), and in riparian corridors only where it does not adversely affect stream channel stability, substrate, aquatic species or their habitats (standard 11-019). The trowel allowance and the sluice and dredge ban are now attributed to the forest's former web guidance (archived June 2024), and readers are told to ask the Blue Ridge Ranger District (706-745-6928) which applies; the trowel is no longer listed as required gear. The forest has no public-domain lands, so the mining-law claims program doesn't apply; gold is a leasable mineral on these acquired lands, with leases issued by the BLM (Plan p. 2-47). Violations of 36 CFR 261.9(a)–(b) carry up to six months in jail and/or a fine of up to $5,000 for an individual (36 CFR 261.1b; 18 U.S.C. 3571). Beds of non-navigable creeks belong to the adjoining landowners (O.C.G.A. § 44-8-2); entering after notice that entry is forbidden, or staying after being told to leave, is criminal trespass, a misdemeanor (§ 16-7-21). National forest is about a fifth (19%) of the Chestatee River–Yahoola Creek watershed around Dahlonega (Plan p. 4-17). Crisson general admission is $19.95 for adults 13 and up, $15.95 for youth 12 and under and free for 3 and under, including a sample pan of gold dirt and a two-gallon gemstone bucket. Consolidated's prices are plus tax, adult means 13 and up, it closes Easter Sunday, Thanksgiving and Christmas Day and opens 10 a.m.–1 p.m. on Christmas Eve, and its panning areas are indoors. The suction-dredging guide's Georgia row now attributes the sluice and dredge quote to the former guidance and adds standard FW-169.
2 pages corrected

Tybee Island: state ownership below the high-tide line, dog fine, Little Tybee, lost property and sandbar rule corrected (City Code not re-read)

What was wrong
The page left out state law entirely: it did not say that the beach below the high-tide line is state-owned tidewater bed, that historic artifacts, treasure and treasure-trove on state land are reserved to the State and must be reported to DNR, or that submerged cultural resources older than 50 years belong to the State and need a DNR permit to recover. It gave the dog-on-beach fine as a $200 minimum. It said smoking and vaping were banned on the pier, and that § 12-1(a)(20) bans going 'past the signs' at a south end the city had designated 'extremely hazardous'. For Little Tybee it cited only § 12-3-621. It said Fort Screven was sold 'to the city' and that detecting equipment can be seized at Fort Pulaski. It treated returning lost items as etiquette only, and listed unsourced claims about where and when jewelry is found (pier, Strand, after 5 p.m., spring break, a 'jewelry zone').
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed', no permit: the city's published beach rules and citation schedule don't mention metal detecting. Georgia holds title to the beds of all tidewaters (O.C.G.A. § 52-1-2). § 12-3-52 reserves to the State the exclusive right to explore, excavate or survey historic sites, artifacts, treasure and treasure-trove on state land, with finds reported to DNR within two days (weekends and holidays excluded); submerged cultural resources on the bottom more than 50 years within the 3-mile limit belong to the State (§ 12-3-80), must be reported within two days (§ 12-3-81(b)) and need a DNR permit to recover (§ 12-3-82), and a violation is a misdemeanor (§ 12-3-83). Modern lost items aren't covered. Little Tybee is state-owned and § 12-3-52 applies; no DNR rule on hobby detecting was found, so the page says to ask DNR first. The city citation schedule lists a $300 fine for pets on the beach (service animals excepted). Smoking and vaping are banned on the beach and beach crossovers (up to $300). § 12-1(a)(20) makes it unlawful to walk, swim or wade out to the South End Sand Bar area. O.C.G.A. § 16-8-6 makes keeping property known to be lost, without reasonable measures to restore it to the owner, theft of lost or mislaid property. Fort Screven (1897–1947) was closed and sold to the town in 1947 (NPS). The Fort Pulaski ban (compendium current as of Jan. 6, 2026) stands without the seizure line. § 12-3-621(c): possessing an artifact collected on or after July 1, 2001 without the landowner's written permission is prima facie evidence of a violation. The winter and fall notes now flag the city's renourishment (about 1.3 million cubic yards, sand placement expected to begin December 2026). The unsourced find-location claims were removed. The Tybee Island City Code itself was not re-read, so the page's last-verified date is unchanged.
Sources
1 page corrected

Mount Ida: Ouachita National Forest collecting rules updated to the Forest Service's June 2026 text; penalties, trespass and distances corrected

What was wrong
The page said national forest "limited collection" is allowed without a permit when five conditions are met, including that no digging beyond small hand tools takes place, and that selling crystals from the forest requires commercial authorization. It cited 36 CFR 261.9 without subsections and gave the penalty only as a fine and/or up to six months in jail. It said digging at a private mine without paying or outside the mine's rules is criminal trespass under Ark. Code § 5-39-203, without the offense class. It said the Encyclopedia of Arkansas counts 20 to 25 operating mines, and that Crater of Diamonds State Park is about 36 miles away. The map pin was at 34.5576, -93.6326, not on a mine site.
What it says now
The Ouachita National Forest's rocks-and-minerals page (last updated June 16, 2026) says rockhounding is available in certain areas and requires a permit, and asks visitors to contact the forest. Visitors may occasionally remove small amounts of material by hand from surface exposures of rock and quartz veins, for personal use only and never for sale; this does not include excavating or digging to expose quartz crystal-bearing veins. Crystal Vista is the forest's one designated quartz crystal collecting site, is not an active mine and has no fee to collect quartz; the page now tells readers to ask the Caddo-Womble Ranger District ((870) 867-2101) whether a permit is needed and before using any tool there. Removing material from land under a mineral contract, claim, permit or lease requires permission, and organized collecting events with access or excavation impacts need a written proposal to the District Ranger and may require a reclamation bond. The citation is 36 CFR 261.9(a)–(b), with penalties under 36 CFR 261.1b and 18 U.S.C. 3571: a Class B misdemeanor, up to six months in jail and/or a fine of up to $5,000 for an individual. Staying on a mine's property after being told to leave is criminal trespass, a Class C misdemeanor unless an aggravating factor applies (Ark. Code § 5-39-203). The 20 to 25 mines figure is Mike Howard's estimate, as cited by the Encyclopedia of Arkansas. Wegner's homepage gives Tuesday–Saturday hours while its FAQ page says trucks leave every day, so the page says to call. The pin now marks Wegner Crystal Mines (34.5141, -93.6413), and Crater of Diamonds is about 33 miles away.
1 page corrected

Herkimer Diamond Mines: state-land rule scope, trespass penalty, tool advice and geology corrected

What was wrong
The page grouped NY-28 roadcuts with state land under 6 NYCRR § 190.8(g), as if the DEC rule covered highway roadcuts, and said most other Little Falls Dolostone outcrops are private. It described the § 190.8(g) permit without noting the rule's exceptions. It gave trespass under Penal Law § 140.05 as up to 15 days and/or an unspecified fine. It recommended a 3- to 4-lb crack hammer, dated the dolostone to 495 million years ago, said the crystals grew in open cavities without attaching to a wall, and called most crystals pea- to thumbnail-sized. It omitted the mine's weekly area-rotation rule for miners staying more than a week, and gave Crystal Grove's season without noting it is the campground season or that Crystal Grove requires a signed Miner's Agreement and daily armband.
What it says now
Part 190 applies to State lands under DEC's jurisdiction administered by its Division of Lands and Forests or Division of Operations (§ 190.0(a)); the page now says roadside outcrops along NY-28 are highway right-of-way or private land, not DEC land, and to ask NYSDOT or the landowner first. § 190.8(g)'s only exceptions are personal consumption and a joint DEC/Education permit, neither of which fits recreational crystal collecting. Trespass is a violation punishable by up to 15 days (Penal Law § 70.15(4)) and/or a fine of up to $250 (§ 80.05(4)). The mine names a 2- to 3-lb crack hammer and bull point chisel as the most popular tools, dates the bedrock to approximately half a billion years ago, says the crystals grew in vugs dissolved by seeping water, and says the clearest are usually under 1 inch long. The page now lists the weekly rotation rule, and gives Crystal Grove's season as mid-April to mid-October (campground season) with its Miner's Agreement and daily armband.
1 page corrected

Monongahela National Forest ramps: state park rule and penalty, guidance status, fundraiser rule, wilderness order and New River Gorge list corrected

What was wrong
The page said West Virginia state parks and forests bar taking plants without a permit issued by the Division, cited only the WVDNR State Park Rules and Regulations and gave no penalty beyond "expect citation and ejection". It presented the two-gallon (about 180 plants), no-resale and no-collecting-for-others limits as Forest Service rules without saying they are the forest's published guidance, and omitted that collecting for a fundraiser is also excluded. It listed New River Gorge's three-gallon gathering items as apples, black walnuts, persimmons and pawpaw-season tree fruit, and placed the park roughly 60 miles from the forest. It did not mention the forest's wilderness order. It linked the forest's old forest-products URL, described ramps as having two or three leaves with a purple-tinged stem, said a ramp needs more than seven years to mature, and put the county as Pocahontas.
What it says now
58 CSR 31-2.2 bars removing any natural object, plant or plant part from a state park, state forest or state wildlife management area without written authorization of the Chief of Parks and Recreation; a violation is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of $20 to $300 and/or 10 to 100 days in jail (58 CSR 31-3.2; W. Va. Code § 20-7-9). The Monongahela permits page lists gathering a reasonable amount of edible material (mushrooms, ramps, etc.) for your own consumption as needing no permit; the two-gallon limit, the commercial and resale prohibition and the bar on collecting for someone else or for a fundraiser come from the forest's published ramp guidance as reprinted by local media in 2022–2024, enforceable as unauthorized removal of a forest product under 36 CFR 261.6(h). In the forest's wildernesses (Dolly Sods, Cranberry, Otter Creek and others) a forest supervisor's order of April 23, 2012 bars entering to gather forest products for commercial use (36 CFR 261.57(a)). New River Gorge's three-gallon list is apples, black walnuts, peaches, pears, persimmons and plums; the park is a separate National Park Service unit southwest of the forest. Ramps have one to four leaves with a white to reddish-purple lower stem and take five to seven years to begin flowering (Penn State Extension). The county is Randolph, where the map pin lies.
1 page corrected

Aurora Fossil Museum: pits keep museum hours, bulk and for-profit collecting barred, PRPA civil-penalty citation and pit geology corrected

What was wrong
The page said the fossil pits are open during daylight hours daily and that museum building hours are narrower than pit hours, and that there is no ticket, registration or staffed gate. It said everything found is yours with no limits beyond tool and screen size. It cited PRPA civil penalties as 16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-4. It said the pit material mixes the Miocene Pungo River and Pliocene Yorktown formations as one stream, dated them roughly 22–18 and 5–2.5 million years, and implied megalodon teeth come from the pits. It said public trust beaches are open to fossil collecting with no exceptions, that federal land allows casual collecting of common invertebrate and plant fossils without qualification, and listed the NC Museum of Natural Sciences' poorly represented categories as crabs, reptiles and land mammals. It said the pits have no benches. The map pin was off the museum.
What it says now
The Fossil Park and pits keep the museum's schedule — Wednesday–Sunday 9:30 am–4:00 pm from September 9, 2026 to February 28, 2027 (closed November 26 and December 24–25), Tuesday–Sunday 9:30 am–4:00 pm from March 2 to May 23, 2027 (closed March 28) — and if the museum is closed the pits are closed. Visitors are asked to park in the museum lot and check in at the museum. The museum's pit rules bar rock throwing, removal of bulk fossil material and collecting for personal or commercial profit, cap screens at 12 × 12 in with 1/4-inch mesh and digging tools at 3 feet; finds remain yours to take home. The museum, grounds and pits close the week before the NC Fossil Festival (2026: May 18–23, pits reopened at noon May 23; 2027 festival May 29–30). PRPA penalties are 16 U.S.C. §§ 470aaa-5 (criminal) and 470aaa-6 (civil), with forfeiture under § 470aaa-7; PRPA bars vertebrate collecting on federal land without a permit and allows casual invertebrate/plant collecting only where the agency allows it. The pit material is the coarse fraction the mill separates from the Pungo River Formation phosphate ore (early to middle Miocene, USGS), donated by Nutrien; the museum ties the mine's megalodon teeth to the Lower Yorktown Formation (early Pliocene). NCMNS lists Onslow Beach (Camp Lejeune, closed to the public) and the national seashores (federal land; vertebrate fossils need a permit) as public-trust exceptions, and names crabs, reptiles, dinosaurs (including birds) and mammals as poorly represented. Picnic tables are available. The map pin moved to the museum.
1 page corrected

Auburn SRA: metal detector ban added; penalties, mining-claim status, swim-area closure, closures and hours corrected

What was wrong
The page didn't mention that metal detectors are banned in Auburn SRA. It said tool and other § 4611 violations carry equipment seizure and forfeiture of material, and that removing artifacts brings citation and forfeiture. It said no mining claim can be located anywhere in the unit because the federal lands were withdrawn from mineral entry, that there are no claims to check, and that almost every other productive reach of the American River carries active claims. It treated a classifier as an unresolved grey area and said snuffer bottles and vials sit outside the tool restriction and were required kit. It said § 4611(f) closes the most popular summer stretch at the Confluence. It described the Yankee Jims closure only as the bridge 'has been closed', and gave Mammoth Bar only as posting its own closures. It said CDPR's fact sheet is the posting that opens the unit under 14 CCR § 4611(b), cited a South Yuba River State Park page (page_id=30708) as the Auburn gold-panning source, cited the General Plan page for the mineral withdrawal, and named Reclamation's region as Mid-Pacific. It said Highway 49 runs south out of Auburn to the Confluence and that canyon temperatures regularly clear 100°F.
What it says now
District Superintendent's Order 690-053-2026 (January 5, 2026) bars possessing or using a metal detector or other geophysical discovery device anywhere in Auburn SRA, except carried unused in a vehicle on a public road or under a 43 CFR 423.50 permit; 43 CFR 423.29(f) says the same on the Reclamation land. Breaking a State Parks rule or order is a misdemeanor (up to 90 days and/or $1,000) or an infraction (up to $1,000) under PRC § 5008(d); removing historic or archaeological material from public land is also a misdemeanor under PRC § 5097.5 (up to $10,000 and/or one year), and § 5097.99 makes it a felony only for Native American items taken from a grave or cairn. CDPR's fact sheet says the federal lands in the unit have been withdrawn from commercial mining claims and commercial mining is prohibited on State Parks land, so a recreational panner needn't check for claims as on open BLM land, but withdrawals are subject to prior rights and BLM records can show claims nearby; the page now says to ask the sector office about any claim markers. CDPR says tools and equipment may not be used except gold pans ('hands and goldpans only'), so classifiers are not allowed and the page says to ask the Auburn Sector Office (530) 885-4527 before bringing a snuffer bottle or vial. § 4611(f) closes any area designated for swimming or boat launching, such as the Lake Clementine boat launch; the page now says to ask whether the Confluence beach counts as a designated swim area. § 4611(g) also allows Lake Clementine beaches within the wave action zone, and 43 CFR 423.29(a) bars removing natural resources, minerals included, from Reclamation land except as other law allows, which is why the state rules apply. Order 690-055-2026 closes the North Fork between Indian Creek and Bunch Canyon, and Shirttail Creek up to the boundary, to all public access during the Yankee Jims bridge construction, with rafting through the only public exception; Mammoth Bar is closed to OHV use Sundays, Mondays and Thursdays and open to non-motorized recreation on those days (Order 690-045-2026). Order 690-052-2026 sets day use at sunrise to sunset, 8 a.m. to sunset at Mammoth Bar, China Bar and Lower Lake Clementine, with Upper Lake Clementine vehicle access closing at 6:30 p.m., and closes Upper Lake Clementine Road, Drivers Flat Road, Sliger Mine Road and the Lower Lake Clementine boat ramp to vehicles from October 15 until after April 15. Sources now point to CDPR's Auburn SRA page and fact sheet; Reclamation's region is California-Great Basin; Highway 49 runs east out of Auburn toward Cool and Placerville; CDPR gives average summer highs in the high 80s to mid 90s. The California metal-detecting overview now lists Auburn SRA among units that ban detectors.
Sources
2 pages corrected

Revere Beach: plover dates, archaeology and lost-property rules, underwater resources, HCP and history corrected

What was wrong
The page said piping plover areas are closed April 1 through August 31 under 321 CMR 10.00, that plover habitat is "delineated as priority habitat", and that fencing comes down after August 31. It described DCR's management as an "Urban Coast" habitat conservation plan using reduced symbolic fencing at Revere. It gave the second-offence Endangered Species Act fine as "not less than $5,000" with no maximum or jail term. It omitted 302 CMR 12.04(22) and (23) (archaeological investigation needs State Archaeologist and Division Director approval; historic finds must be reported to DCR immediately) and told readers to call the Massachusetts Historical Commission instead. It did not mention the lost-property reporting rule (M.G.L. c. 134) or the Commonwealth's title to underwater archaeological resources in the intertidal zone. It said the City of Revere's ordinances govern Revere Beach Boulevard and its free four-hour parking. It called M.G.L. c. 9, § 27C the "Massachusetts Antiquities Act", said the beach opened as a public beach on July 12, 1896, called the Reservation a National Register historic district, and said the Blizzard of 1978 destroyed the seawall and sidewalks and the beach has since been renourished, with an amusement district running through the 1970s.
What it says now
DCR proactively fences historic piping plover and least tern territories by April 1 and fences other sections immediately once additional pairs demonstrate territoriality or scraping; fenced areas are closed whatever the date (DCR application for inclusion in the Massachusetts Piping Plover Habitat Conservation Plan). DCR's Revere, Winthrop and Nahant beaches are covered by a certificate of inclusion in that plan; the 2025 annual report records no covered activities at Revere. Under M.G.L. c. 131A, § 6 a violation is punishable by a fine of not less than $500 and/or up to 90 days; a second or subsequent conviction by $5,000–$10,000 and/or up to 180 days; plus a civil assessment up to $10,000 per violation. "Take" includes harassing and disrupting nesting or feeding (§ 1). The piping plover is federally Threatened (Atlantic Coast) and Threatened in Massachusetts; the least tern is a Massachusetts Species of Special Concern (321 CMR 10.90). 302 CMR 12.04(22) bars archaeological investigation unless permitted by the State Archaeologist under M.G.L. c. 9, § 27C and approved by the Division Director, and 12.04(23) requires unanticipated discoveries of historic artifacts or human remains to be reported immediately to DCR; the page now gives the DCR Coastal District, (781) 485-2803, as the first contact and MHC as the second. Lost money or goods worth $3 or more with an unknown owner must be reported within two days to the police station in the town where found (M.G.L. c. 134, § 1); the owner may reclaim within a year (§ 3) and the finder keeps it after a year if § 1 was followed (§ 4); how this interacts with 302 CMR 12.04(21) is presented as unclear. Title to underwater archaeological resources (abandoned property, artifacts, treasure trove, shipwrecks unclaimed 100+ years or valued $5,000+) in coastal waters, which include waters within the rise and fall of the tide, is in the Commonwealth (M.G.L. c. 6, § 180; c. 130, § 1); removing them without a Board permit is a misdemeanor punishable by up to $1,000 and/or six months plus forfeiture (M.G.L. c. 91, § 63; 312 CMR 2.06). The City of Revere says the reservation is under DCR jurisdiction; 302 CMR 12.02 counts boulevards as DCR property, so detector use on Revere Beach Boulevard needs DCR permission. DCR lists a 4-hour parking limit, no parking 9–10 AM from Eliot Circle to #320 Revere Beach Blvd, resident permit parking on Ocean Ave and the inland side, and dawn-to-dusk hours (302 CMR 12.03(1) default: ½ hour before sunrise to ½ hour after sunset unless posted). DCR dates the public beach to 1896 (NPS: opened with temporary improvements in July 1895); NPS calls the Reservation a National Historic Landmark and records restoration efforts in the 1980s and 1990s. The map pin moved onto the sand.
1 page corrected

Virginia Beach Oceanfront: sand-removal rule is a Class 1 misdemeanor, not a $250 fine

What was wrong
The page gave Virginia Beach City Code § 6-13 (altering the sand's contours by grading, carrying away or removing sand from the beaches or dunes without a city manager's permit) as a Class 4 misdemeanor with a $250 maximum fine, and said the § 6-14 dune band and the state dune act carried the heaviest penalties on the beach.
What it says now
§ 6-13(f) makes any violation of § 6-13 a Class 1 misdemeanor (up to 12 months in jail and/or a $2,500 fine under Va. Code § 18.2-11), the same class as § 6-14. The page also now gives the beach litter rule: § 6-7(b) bars discarding litter on any beach, and § 6-7(e) makes a violation a Class 1 misdemeanor. Chapter 6 (Supp. No. 162) still has no metal-detector, digging or hole provision, and the verdict is unchanged.
1 page corrected

Alaska suction dredges: DEC registration no longer needed on most streams

What was wrong
The Crow Creek Mine page and the suction-dredging guide said every suction dredge or highbanker needs an annual $25 Alaska DEC registration under general permit AKG375000 before it discharges, and the Nome page told dredgers to register under that permit. They cited DEC's 2023 registration FAQ.
What it says now
DEC modified AKG375000 on January 30, 2026. Part 1.5.1 now requires annual registration only for listed impaired waters in the Circle and Fairbanks mining districts, marine waters (except state recreational mining areas and Norton Sound claims or leases) and federal reserves (national park units, monuments, refuges, conservation areas, wilderness and similar); "Discharge registrations are not required for any other locations." Every operation must still follow the permit and keep a copy of it, and any ADF&G Fish Habitat Permit, on site. Crow Creek needs no registration; Nome's recreation areas are state recreational mining areas. The pages now cite the modified permit and DEC's March 2026 FAQ.
3 pages corrected

Gulf Breeze: Santa Rosa Island land managers, Naval Live Oaks headquarters, and federal penalties

What was wrong
The page said the barrier island south of Gulf Breeze is federally prohibited Gulf Islands National Seashore, and that Naval Live Oaks houses the national seashore's visitor center. It gave the federal penalty as a citation of up to $5,000 and/or 6 months with possible equipment confiscation, citing 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) alone. It said every public beach access in Gulf Breeze faces Santa Rosa Sound, and applied a Santa Rosa County park ordinance although no county park near Gulf Breeze is covered by the page.
What it says now
Gulf Islands National Seashore holds the Naval Live Oaks Area and both ends of Santa Rosa Island; Pensacola Beach in between is Escambia County land managed by the Santa Rosa Island Authority, where detecting is allowed. Naval Live Oaks holds the national seashore's headquarters (staff only), picnic areas and trails; NPS sends visitors to Fort Pickens for passes and stamps. Detecting there is a federal petty offense under 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) and 36 CFR 1.3 / 18 U.S.C. § 1865: up to 6 months in jail and/or a fine of up to $5,000. Gulf Breeze's public waterfront faces Santa Rosa Sound and Pensacola Bay (Mariners Landing). The county ordinance entry was removed. The page now also states that Santa Rosa County's nesting season is May 1 – October 31 and that disturbing a nest is a third-degree felony (Fla. Stat. § 379.2431), that keeping lost or abandoned property is theft (Fla. Stat. § 705.102(3)–(4)), and that vehicles and equipment used in an unpermitted excavation on state land are subject to forfeiture (Fla. Stat. § 267.13(1)(b)).
1 page corrected

Panama City Beach: city limits, Shell Island and the Tyndall Air Force Base detector ban

What was wrong
The page applied the city's metal-shovel ban and hole limit to the whole beach and gave about 26 miles of public Gulf beach. It said St. Andrews State Park occupies the entire eastern end of the Panama City Beach shoreline and that its boundary is signed at beach level. It described Tyndall Air Force Base land, east of the park across the St. Andrews Bay pass, as closed military property rather than public beach, and didn't say the base bans metal detectors. It told readers to report only valuable or identifiable finds under Fla. Stat. § 705.102.
What it says now
The City of Panama City Beach covers about 13 miles of Gulf beach, and not all of the beach is inside the city. The city's § 7-10 metal-shovel ban and two-foot hole limit apply only inside city limits. The beaches west of the city (such as Sunnyside and Laguna Beach) and the Thomas Drive stretch between the city's eastern limit and St. Andrews State Park are unincorporated Bay County, where Bay County Code § 5-27 bars holes deeper than two feet and there is no shovel ban; the page points readers to the city's address lookup map. St. Andrews State Park includes the western part of Shell Island across the pass, and Florida State Parks policy allows detecting there only between the toe of the dune and the high-water line in areas the park manager designates, not in submerged locations, and doesn't let visitors keep objects over 50 years old (FAQ 1.6); the page gives the park's phone number. Tyndall Air Force Base adjoins the park on the east end of Shell Island; its East Unit beaches are open to the public with a Tyndall recreation permit, sunrise to sunset, but the 2026–27 base regulations prohibit using or possessing a metal detector on all of the base and searching for or removing objects of antiquity. The page now says § 705.102 requires reporting any lost or abandoned property, with no minimum value, and that a reported find the finder asks to claim becomes theirs after a 90-day hold if no owner comes forward (§ 705.104). The March beach alcohol ban is now cited to PCB Code § 3-2.1, and the tide figure to NOAA station 8729210 (great diurnal range 1.39 feet).
1 page corrected

St. George Island State Park: location, WWII range, fees, hours and nesting season

What was wrong
The page's map pin and GPS coordinates (29.6483, -84.7695) were in the Gulf of Mexico, and its distances to nearby sites were wrong. It didn't mention that the eastern island was a 1940s Army gunnery and bombing range where practice bombs and artillery shells are still found, and described finds there as low-historic-potential modern resort finds. It gave the entry fee as a flat $6 per vehicle, said dawn sessions before 8 a.m. were possible, and said Gulf Coast nesting season starts a month later than the Atlantic coast's. It called the bridge CR-300, described the western island as a private resort community, listed surf-zone fishing weights as a find although detecting in the water isn't allowed, and said a long-handled scoop was required.
What it says now
The pin is now at the park entrance, 1900 E. Gulf Beach Drive (29.6815, -84.8027); Cape San Blas is 36.0 miles away and Panama City Beach 69.2. The US Army used the eastern island in the 1940s as a gunnery and bombing range; the park's 2016 Unit Management Plan lists five sites (FR-1146 to FR-1150) with remains of practice bombs and .50 cal bullets and casings, and Florida State Parks says practice bombs and artillery shells are still found in the park. The page now says to leave anything that looks like ordnance, note the spot and tell a ranger, and that WWII debris is over 50 years old so visitors can't keep it. Entry is $6 per vehicle (2–8 people), $4 single-occupant vehicle and $2 pedestrians and cyclists; the park is open 8 a.m. until sundown. Franklin County's nesting season is May 1 – October 31 (Franklin County Code § 5-62); only Brevard to Broward counties start March 1. The Bryant Patton Bridge (SR 300) is the only road onto the island; west of the park is the developed part of the island with the county's public beach (§ 5-132). Detecting is only between the toe of the dune and the high-water line, never in the water; a scoop is needed only if the park allows digging. The page now also states that lost or abandoned property must be reported to a law enforcement officer and keeping it is theft (Fla. Stat. § 705.102), that owners may recover a specific lost item with park staff present, and that collecting plant or animal specimens is a second-degree misdemeanor (Fla. Stat. § 258.008(3)).
1 page corrected

Cape San Blas: park penalty statute, Gulf County fines, detecting zone and the Air Force lighthouse site

What was wrong
The Cape San Blas page cited Fla. Stat. § 258.009, which does not exist, for detecting outside the designated beach areas, and said repeat violations could bring a trespass charge and a permanent ban from Florida State Parks. It said Gulf County's Leave No Trace ordinance sets no specific fine. It told readers to detect at low tide in the tidal flat between the first sandbar and the dune toe, and recommended wet-sand recovery in the tidal zone. It said the lighthouse was moved in 2014 because the waterline was within feet of its foundation, in the fourth move since 1847, that its original footprint is on the active beach, and treated it as a state-land question, without saying the site is Air Force property or that Eglin AFB prohibits metal detectors on its reservation. It said anything over 50 years old belongs to the state under Ch. 267, said § 705.102 requires reporting only valuable or identifiable finds, and described the Panama City Beach row as having no ordinance.
What it says now
Breaking a state park rule is a noncriminal infraction: a fine of up to $500 and ejection from all state park property (Fla. Stat. § 258.008(1)); digging up or removing a historic object is a separate crime under § 267.13. Gulf County Ordinance 2015-07 § 20 sets fines of $100 for a first violation, $200 for a second and up to $500 for a third; it covers beaches seaward of SR 30A and CR C30B/C30E from the Indian Pass boat ramp to the park's southern boundary, St. Joseph Bay's sandy shores, and south of US 98 from the Gulf County Canal to the Bay County line (§ 2), requires holes to be attended and completely filled the same day (§ 6) and bars removing beach sand (§ 15). Florida State Parks allows detecting only between the toe of the dune and the high-water line, never in submerged areas, so the page now limits detecting to the designated dry beach. The 1885 lighthouse stood on Air Force property south of the park and was moved with two keepers' houses to George Core Park in Port St. Joe in 2014; Eglin's FY25 Outdoor Recreation handbook prohibits metal detectors on all portions of the Eglin Reservation, and the page tells readers to call Eglin Natural Resources (850) 882-4165 before detecting near the Air Force site. The 50-year rule is Florida State Parks policy; Ch. 267 vests historic objects on state land in the state with no age threshold (§ 267.061). Section 705.102 requires reporting any lost or abandoned property, with no minimum value. Panama City Beach's code bans metal shovels and holes over 2 feet (§ 7-10).
1 page corrected

Okanogan-Wenatchee: no commercial mushroom permits in 2026, 5-gallon limit, wildernesses and ranger districts

What was wrong
The Okanogan-Wenatchee page said commercial mushroom harvesting needed a free permit from a ranger district, obtained in person from late August. It gave a 1-gallon-per-species daily limit in places alongside the 5-gallon morel rule, said selling personal-use harvest violated 36 CFR 261.6(f), and listed six wildernesses including Noisy-Diobsud, which is not on this forest, with Pasayten, Goat Rocks and William O. Douglas missing. It counted seven ranger districts, named nonexistent Lake Wenatchee and Okanogan districts and gave not the numbers the forest lists Wenatchee River and Methow Valley phone numbers. It gave the forest's area as four million acres, compared it with forests whose rules it misstated (including no personal-use permit on the Deschutes), put its map pin on a private house near Cashmere, and gave distances of 41.8, 114.2 and 300 miles to Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie, Olympic and Willamette.
What it says now
The forest says commercial mushroom harvesting permits will not be sold in 2026 (nor were they in 2025). Personal harvest is free up to 5 gallons per person per day with the forest's Incidental Use Mushroom Information Sheet (written for morels) in your possession; no stockpiling, and personal-use mushrooms can't be sold or exchanged, so removal outside the sheet's terms is unauthorized removal under 36 CFR 261.6(h). Washington requires a specialized forest products permit to pick or carry more than 5 gallons of wild edible mushrooms and to sell any amount of huckleberries (RCW 76.48.021, 76.48.031). The forest's eight wildernesses are Alpine Lakes, Glacier Peak, Henry M. Jackson, Pasayten, Lake Chelan-Sawtooth, Goat Rocks, Norse Peak and William O. Douglas; commercial harvest is barred there (16 U.S.C. 1133(c)), and the page now says to ask the district about personal picking. The forest has six ranger districts (Chelan, Cle Elum, Entiat, Methow Valley, Naches, Wenatchee River) with current phone numbers, and covers 3.8 million acres. The page adds the forest's rules on not walking through streams, no rakes or digging, transplant permits (Methow Valley, Chelan and Wenatchee River only), closure areas and posted product rates. The comparison table was rebuilt from the current sibling pages, the pin is now at Tumwater Campground on national forest land, and distances are 28.0, 101.8 and 244.7 miles.
1 page corrected

Badlands National Park: penalties, Buffalo Gap rules, fees, hiking policy and formation ages

What was wrong
The page gave the 36 CFR 2.1 penalty as a federal citation with civil fines and a criminal misdemeanor only for repeat or commercial violations, and said seized fossils and equipment under PRPA. It said PRPA permits go to qualified institutions only and that PRPA covers all federal land in and around the park. It said Buffalo Gap National Grassland may permit some invertebrate collecting, without saying collecting there is surface-only with no digging, that vertebrates need a permit under 36 CFR 291.13 and 291.27, or that selling or trading is prohibited, and called it the same formation as the park. It said off-trail travel is restricted in much of the park. It gave the entrance fee as $35 per vehicle paid at automated kiosks. It put the Fossil Exhibit Trail, a paved loop with covered shelters, in a 'Scenic Unit' and put Wall, SD 8 miles north of the Northeast Entrance. It dated the formations to 33–37 million years and called them Oligocene throughout. It said the park logs every reported find in a database, that a significant new specimen is exposed every two to three hours, that the park is the richest Oligocene mammal site on Earth, and that rangers conduct bag checks, none of which NPS states.
What it says now
Possessing, disturbing or removing a fossil in the park violates 36 CFR 2.1(a)(1)(iii), a federal petty offense of up to 6 months in jail, a fine under Title 18, or both (36 CFR 1.3; 18 U.S.C. 1865); PRPA's rules also allow no casual collecting on NPS land (43 CFR 49.800). PRPA's criminal penalties apply to a knowing violation (16 U.S.C. 470aaa-5) and the fossils are subject to civil or criminal forfeiture (470aaa-7). PRPA permits go to qualified applicants for research or education (470aaa-3), and PRPA covers Interior Department land (except Indian land) and National Forest System land, including Buffalo Gap National Grassland (470aaa(2)). On Buffalo Gap, the Forest Service allows surface collection of common invertebrate and plant fossils for personal, non-commercial use without digging, up to 25 lb a day and 100 lb a year (36 CFR 291.5; 36 CFR 291.11); vertebrate fossils need a permit (36 CFR 291.13, 291.27), none is issued for hobby collecting, and selling or trading is prohibited. The park has an Open Hike Policy allowing off-trail hiking, though some trails ask you to stay on them. The entrance fee is $30 per private vehicle for 7 days, $25 per motorcycle and $15 per person, card only at the Northeast, Pinnacles and Interior entrance stations or online. The Fossil Exhibit Trail is a 0.25-mile accessible boardwalk with fossil replicas in the North Unit; Wall is about 7 miles north of the Pinnacles Entrance (I-90 Exit 110). The Chadron Formation dates to about 37–34 million years ago (late Eocene), the Brule to 34–30 and the Sharps to 30–28 million years ago, above the marine Pierre Shale (75–69 million years ago). The page now also states that the South Unit lies within the Pine Ridge Reservation, that the park's only gathering allowance is plant gathering by enrolled Lakota tribal members for religious purposes (2026 Compendium § 2.1(c)(1)), and the NPS reporting steps: photograph with scale, don't mark the site, tell a ranger at a visitor center and fill in a report.
1 page corrected

Como Bluff: mostly private land, BLM sections only, map pin, location and history

What was wrong
The Como Bluff page said the site is publicly accessible BLM land open for casual fossil collection, with only some private parcels interspersed. Its map pin was about 16 miles from the bluff, on Hanna Formation rock. It put the bluff 6 miles west of Medicine Bow and said Medicine Bow was 6 miles east, and reversed the directions to Laramie and Rawlins. It said Yale college scouts found the bones in 1877, that Quarries 1 to 13 produced the type specimens of Diplodocus longus and Camarasaurus supremus, and that the Bone Cabin was built in 1897 and had deteriorated near Bone Cabin Quarry. It said vertebrate permits go to researchers through academic institutions, that misidentifying bone is no defense, and that every vertebrate violation is a federal crime, and it cited only 'BLM land use conditions' for the hand-tool rule. Other fossil pages gave distances to Como Bluff of 165, 170, 200 and 248 miles, and the Wyoming overview and the Garden Park and Flaming Gorge comparison rows described Como Bluff as BLM land open for collecting with no site-specific restrictions.
What it says now
The National Register nomination shows most of Como Bluff in private ownership. The BLM holds section 18 at the west end (Marsh's Quarries 7 and 12), section 14 and part of section 8 (T22N R77W); section 16 (Quarry 1a) is Wyoming school trust land. BLM's surface management map still shows BLM land at Quarry 7 and private land along the crest. The verdict stays allowed but now covers only the BLM sections: common invertebrate and plant fossils up to 25 lb a day with non-powered hand tools (43 CFR 49.810(a)(5)); uncommon invertebrate and plant fossils need a permit (43 CFR 49.810(c)); private sections need the landowner's permission and section 16 an Office of State Lands and Investments permit. Whether the Rawlins resource management plan restricts collecting there is unconfirmed, and the page says to call the Rawlins Field Office. The pin is now at Quarry 7 (41.8783, -106.1042), about 5 miles east-southeast of Medicine Bow. Union Pacific workers William Reed and William Carlin found the bones in 1877 and wrote to Marsh; no primary source ties the Diplodocus longus or Camarasaurus supremus type specimens to Como Bluff, so that claim was removed. Fossil Cabin was built in 1932 by Thomas Boylan, and May 2026 local news reported it moved to the Medicine Bow Museum; Bone Cabin Quarry is a separate site on private land. BLM vertebrate permits go only to applicants with a relevant degree or demonstrated training and experience, for research or public education (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-3; 43 CFR 49.110). Criminal penalties need a knowing violation (43 CFR 49.400(a)); mistakes can still bring civil penalties and forfeiture (16 U.S.C. §§ 470aaa-6, -7). The page now also gives the Wyoming misdemeanor penalty (W.S. 36-1-116(a)) and the ban on removing deposits from the state without board consent (W.S. 36-1-115). Distances to Como Bluff are now 234.2 miles (Green River Formation), 239.7 (Fossil Butte), 191.7 (Flaming Gorge) and 247.4 (Badlands), and from it 193.7 (Dinosaur NM), 394.9 (Hell Creek) and 425.2 (Grand Staircase-Escalante).
8 pages corrected

Newport Beach: Crystal Cove location and status, Corona del Mar State Beach, beach hours and city rules

What was wrong
The page placed Crystal Cove State Park immediately south of the city beach and outside city limits, and called detecting there prohibited because a state park is legally different from a state beach. It listed hole-filling and staying out of flagged lifeguard zones as city rules, said beach patrol cites people for unfilled holes, and recommended detecting before 5–6 a.m. It did not mention Corona del Mar State Beach or the Crystal Cove State Marine Conservation Area, cited only 14 CCR § 550(g)(1) for Upper Newport Bay, gave parking as $3–4/hour and free or reduced in winter, and said Newport Pier was built in 1888.
What it says now
Crystal Cove State Park lies about 4 miles south-east of the Balboa Peninsula, past the harbor entrance, Corona del Mar State Beach and Little Corona, between Corona del Mar and Laguna Beach; most of it is inside Newport Beach city limits but it is State Parks land. No Orange Coast District posted order mentions metal detectors; 14 CCR § 4307(a) (no disturbing sand) and Order 925-23-11(B) (no disturbing geological formations) apply, so its status is now unclear — ask the park, (949) 494-3539. It is closed sunset to 6 a.m. (Historic District day-use 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., Order 925-23-03(C)). Corona del Mar State Beach, a State Parks unit operated by the city, was added as unclear (§ 4307(a); Order 925-23-31(A) bars taking shells or intertidal life). The city rules listed are now those in the Municipal Code: beaches closed 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. (§ 11.08.030(A)), no removing beach sand without the City Manager's written approval (§ 11.08.070), no disturbing City trees, plants or rocks (§ 11.04.070(J)); no provision mentions metal detectors. Hole-filling and avoiding swim areas are now advice, and pre-6 a.m. advice was removed. The page now notes the Crystal Cove State Marine Conservation Area (14 CCR § 632(b)(133), § 632(a)(1)(C)), cites § 550(g)(1) and (g)(3) for Upper Newport Bay, gives the city's parking rates, and drops the 1888 pier date. The verdict for the city strand stays allowed.
1 page corrected

Dockweiler State Beach: verdict changed from "allowed" to "unclear"; City of Los Angeles lease and LA County beach code added

What was wrong
The page said metal detecting was allowed on the sand with no ban from "either agency", naming only California State Parks (owner) and LA County Beaches and Harbors (operator, "under an agreement with the state"). It left out that the State leased the beach to the City of Los Angeles in 1946 and that the County runs it for the City, and it did not mention LA County Code chapter 17.12. It said the State's detector restrictions are typically site-specific orders for individual historic parks. The California overview listed Dockweiler as allowed and as simply State-owned and County-run.
What it says now
The State leased Dockweiler to the City of Los Angeles in 1946, and LA County Beaches and Harbors has operated it for the City since 1976; California State Parks still lists it as a state beach in its Angeles District, operated by Los Angeles County, (310) 322-4951. LA County Code chapter 17.12 covers beaches the County owns, controls or manages: § 17.12.200 "A person shall not remove any wood, turf, grass, soil, rock, sand or gravel from any beach", § 17.12.205 bars digging a hole deeper than 18 inches into the sand, and a violation is an infraction (§ 17.12.150(A)); exceptions need specific permission from the Director, Fire Chief, an ocean lifeguard or a code enforcement officer (§ 17.12.180(C)). No rule from the State, the City or the County mentions metal detectors, and no detecting permit exists. Whether 14 CCR § 4307(a) (no disturbing or removing sand in State Parks units) applies on this City-leased beach is unconfirmed, so the verdict is now "unclear" and the page says to call before digging. State Parks detector orders can cover whole recreation areas and districts (Folsom Lake SRA, every Northern Buttes District unit), not only historic parks. The California overview's Dockweiler row, warning box and checklist now match.
2 pages corrected

Pismo Beach: state beach section changed to "unclear"; beach driving, Monarch Grove and day-use fee corrected

What was wrong
The page said metal detecting was allowed with no permit on both the City of Pismo Beach frontage and Pismo State Beach, under "the same no-permit, no-deep-holes framework" and "without any real change" at the boundary. It said vehicles are not permitted on most of Pismo State Beach and that only Oceano Dunes SVRA, south of the Pier Avenue entrance, allows beach driving. It called the Monarch Butterfly Grove a fenced stand open dusk to dawn and closed to all digging and collecting year-round (detecting status "prohibited"), and gave the $5 day-use fee as charged at the Grand Avenue and Pier Avenue entrances. The California overview said the grove is closed to digging.
What it says now
Detecting stays allowed on the city frontage, where the 1-foot hole limit (Municipal Code § 12.20.090) applies; that limit is city code only. Pismo State Beach is a State Parks unit run by the Oceano Dunes District: none of the district's 2023 posted orders mentions metal detectors, but 14 CCR § 4307(a) bars disturbing or removing sand in every State Parks unit, so the state beach is now "unclear — ask the park", (805) 473-7220. Order 554-033 closes fenced restoration, habitat-protection and cultural-resource areas to all public access. Order 554-005 bars driving on Pismo State Beach north of Grand Avenue and allows street-legal vehicles from Grand Avenue south to beach marker post #2; California State Parks says vehicles enter at the end of West Grand Avenue in Grover Beach and charges $5 per vehicle entering the beach. The grove is described as California State Parks does: a site for viewing overwintering monarchs, November–February, where § 4307(a) applies; the unsourced hours and year-round digging closure were removed. The California overview's Pismo row now reads "Allowed (city beach)" with the state beach unclear.
2 pages corrected

Ocean Beach (San Diego): California State Parks does not ban detecting outright

What was wrong
The permit note and an FAQ said California state parks and state beaches "prohibit detecting outright".
What it says now
California State Parks has no statewide detecting ban; some units ban detectors by posted order, and in every unit 14 CCR § 4307(a) bars disturbing sand. The Ocean Beach verdict (allowed, city beach) is unchanged.
1 page corrected

Florida modern finds: lost-property law (Fla. Stat. ch. 705) requires reporting, with no minimum value

What was wrong
Several Florida pages and the how-to-start Tip said modern finds (recent coins, jewelry, phones) are the finder’s to keep, or that modern losses aren’t covered by any rule. Other Florida pages correctly cited Fla. Stat. § 705.102 but told readers to report only valuable or identifiable finds. The Florida Chapter 267 guide, the Florida state overview and many Florida beach pages didn’t mention chapter 705 at all, and the metal-detecting hobby FAQ said modern finds are yours.
What it says now
Florida’s lost-property law covers modern finds on public property, which expressly includes sovereignty submerged lands, and in parks, public recreation areas and other places open to the public (Fla. Stat. § 705.101). Anyone who finds lost or abandoned property must report its description and location to a law enforcement officer (§ 705.102(1)); the statute sets no minimum value, and keeping it for your own use is theft under § 812.014 (§ 705.102(3)–(4)). A finder who reports a find and asks to claim it pays the agency’s costs (§ 705.102(2)); the agency holds it for 90 days and gives notice (§ 705.103(2)(b)), and title passes to the finder if no owner claims it (§ 705.104(1)). The pages now say this, and Florida state park pages also note that Florida State Parks lets a detector be used with park staff to recover a specific lost item, keeping only that item (FAQ 1.7). No court decision, Attorney General opinion or agency guidance applying chapter 705 to detecting finds was found.
36 pages corrected

Glass Beach (Fort Bragg): wrong citation, and the glass beaches south of the park are city land where removing glass is banned

What was wrong
The page said taking sea glass is prohibited under California's state park rockhounding rule, 14 CCR § 4611, with § 4306 separately barring removal of "driftwood or other natural beach material", and that some units allow rockhounding up to 15 lb/day. It said the two glass beaches south of the park ('Glass Beach 2' and '3') might lie outside the park where collecting "may not be restricted" and called their status "legally ambiguous". It said a permit path doesn't exist because removal is banned under the rockhounding rule, and gave the penalty as a possible citation under § 4611. The beachcombing hobby page and the Oregon Beach Bill guide also cited § 4611 for Glass Beach.
What it says now
14 CCR § 4611 is the rockhounding allowance and covers naturally occurring stones and minerals (§ 4301(v)); sea glass is manufactured. § 4306 covers trees, plants and dead wood only, and the mineral-collecting allowance in PRC § 5001.65(b) applies only to state beaches and recreation areas, not state parks. California State Parks says all MacKerricher State Park features are protected and may not be collected, including glass found at Glass Beach; in every unit, 14 CCR § 4307(a) bars removing sand, gravel or rocks and § 4308 bars removing objects of historical interest, and State Parks hasn't said which one it applies to the glass. Violations are a misdemeanor (up to 90 days in jail and/or a $1,000 fine) or an infraction (PRC § 5008(d)). The beaches south of the park are the City of Fort Bragg's Noyo Headlands Park, where Fort Bragg Municipal Code § 9.68.030(Q) says "Removal of beach glass is prohibited" (a misdemeanor, § 9.68.070). There is no permit for recreational collecting. The verdict (prohibited) is unchanged.
3 pages corrected

Fossil Butte: research-quarry closure, no Junior Ranger dig, permit type, current fee quarries and history

What was wrong
The Fossil Butte National Monument page placed the Superintendent's Compendium's 300-foot closure around the historic quarry and left out the night closure. It said the Junior Ranger program includes a ranger-supervised shale-splitting dig, and that fossils can be seen in place on the trails. It described the research permit as a 36 CFR 2.5 scientific permit issued only to institution-affiliated researchers. It listed Warfield Fossil Quarries, which is no longer on the Fossil Basin Promotion Board's operator list, described American Fossil as notable for three-toed horse fossils and put the nearest pay-to-dig quarry about 3 minutes from the visitor center. Its history said Union Pacific workers found the fossils in the 1870s, that Lee Craig sold fossils from 1897 to 1937, and that Congress created the monument specifically to stop commercial digging, making the ban absolute. It called Gallinuloides a complete skeleton with soft-tissue impressions related to chachalacas, gave the elevation as 7,500+ ft and the visitor center as having 80+ displays and a 13-minute film. The Green River Formation (BLM) page said the fee quarries operate under their own leases on BLM parcels, quoted a $65–$89 day fee and put Fossil Butte about 12 miles away.
What it says now
The compendium (approved January 8, 2026) closes the area within 300 feet of the center point of the research quarry, except the trail leading to it, and closes the whole monument from 30 minutes after sunset to 30 minutes before sunrise except the paved areas around the visitor center and the Chicken Creek Road and Scenic Drive. The Junior Ranger program is a booklet; the hands-on program is the summer Fossil Quarry Program at the research quarry (Fridays and Saturdays, June 26–August 15, 2026, 11 am–3 pm, no reservations), and all fossils found stay in the park's museum collection. NPS says fossils are not visible from any of the trails; fossil-bearing layers can be seen at the historic quarry, and more than 2,000 fossils are displayed in the visitor center. Research collecting needs a paleontological resource permit under 43 CFR Part 49, for research or public education by qualified applicants (43 CFR 49.110), with specimens kept as federal property in an approved repository. The penalty citation is now 36 CFR 2.1(a)(1)(iii) with 36 CFR 1.3(a) and 18 U.S.C. 1865(a), including the costs of the proceedings, and PRPA forfeiture is cited to 16 U.S.C. 470aaa-7. Per NPS, some commercial quarries on state and private land outside the monument allow digging for a fee; the current operators are American Fossil (a private quarry, closed for 2026; $89–$169), Blue Moon Quarry, Fossil Lake Safari ($79–$159), In Stone Fossils, Tynsky's Fossil Fish and Ulrich's Fossil Gallery ($135 per adult, transport to the quarry provided; the gallery, not the quarry, is about 3 minutes from the visitor center). Wyoming state trust land has no public digging permit. The history now follows NPS: interest since the fossils' discovery in the 1850s, Lee Craig and David C. Haddenham as full-time quarriers from the 1890s to the 1950s, and the monument's stated purpose; the ban is the NPS-wide 36 CFR 2.1 rule. Gallinuloides wyomingensis is described as an early Galliformes species, the first bird found in the Fossil Butte Member, shown as a cast (original at Harvard's MCZ). Elevation is 6,600–8,000 ft. The Green River Formation page now says the quarries are on state and private land, gives the current rates and puts Fossil Butte's visitor center about 7 miles away.
Sources
2 pages corrected

Cape Hatteras National Seashore: the beach in front of the villages is seashore land, the detector ban is servicewide, and the penalty citation was incomplete

What was wrong
The page said the beach in front of Rodanthe, Waves, Salvo, Avon, Buxton, Frisco, Hatteras and Ocracoke village sits outside NPS jurisdiction and called detecting there "unclear", telling readers to call Dare County. It presented 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) as a layer Cape Hatteras adds, "a dedicated regulatory subsection", rather than a rule in every National Park Service unit, and said the only exceptions were a stored detector or boat/aircraft navigation equipment. It listed a required permit for recreational metal detecting, gave the penalty under 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) alone, and said ORV routes run roughly 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. from May 1 to September 15 with a night-driving permit required from September 16 to November 15. It said there are more than 2,000 shipwrecks off the coast since 1526, that the Navy named the area Torpedo Junction, that U-85's hatch is displayed at the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse, and that the USS Monitor lies about 16 nautical miles offshore in about 240 feet of water. It gave lighthouse climb fees as $4–$10 including Ocracoke. The NC state overview said the village beaches are outside NPS land, the 36 CFR 2.1 guide said a citation includes confiscation of anything collected, and the Nags Head page put Cape Hatteras 5 miles away.
What it says now
The villages are private and county land, but the ocean beach in front of them is part of the seashore: the NPS reports 32 privately owned houses have collapsed on seashore beaches since 2020, 36 CFR 7.58(c)(9) designates village-beach ORV routes, and the NPS closes beach areas fronting the villages; so 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) applies there too. (a)(7) applies in every NPS unit; it does not apply to a detector broken down and stored or packed to prevent its use, to boat/aircraft navigation electronics, or to detectors used for authorized scientific, mining or administrative work, and there is no permit for recreational detecting. A violation is a federal petty offense under 36 CFR 1.3 and 18 U.S.C. § 1865: up to 6 months in jail and/or a fine of up to $5,000 for an individual ($10,000 for an organization) under 18 U.S.C. § 3571; neither provides for confiscation. From May 1 to November 15, ORV routes in turtle-nesting habitat close at 9 p.m. and open no earlier than 6 a.m.; from November 16 to April 30 they are open 24 hours (36 CFR 7.58(c)(12)); there is no night-driving permit. The NPS estimates more than 1,000 vessels lost near Cape Hatteras; captains referred to the area as "Torpedo Junction", and the campaign's final toll was more than eighty sunken ships. NOAA places the Monitor about 16 miles south-southeast of the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse in about 230 feet of water. Bodie Island Lighthouse climbs are $10 adult / $5 reduced, and Cape Hatteras Lighthouse is closed for climbing through 2026. The page now also covers the 2026 Compendium's shell allowance (one 5-gallon bucket per person per day), Pea Island National Wildlife Refuge (50 CFR 27.61 and 27.63(a)), G.S. 121-22 title to wrecks and temporary beach closures after house collapses. The Nags Head page now gives about 49 miles pin to pin. The verdict (prohibited) is unchanged.
4 pages corrected

Port Aransas Beach: beach boundaries, Mustang Island permit and penalties corrected

What was wrong
The page said Mustang Island State Park begins immediately south of the Port Aransas city beach (around Marker 102), and the Texas overview said the city beach 'runs straight into' the park. It described a free Mustang Island 'lost-item search permit' issued by the superintendent, which no TPWD source describes. It gave the state-park penalty as a fine 'up to $500', the Antiquities Code penalty only as 'fines and potential imprisonment', and said historic finds 'must be reported'. It listed equipment forfeiture as a Padre Island National Seashore penalty, put the 1554 Spanish Plate Fleet wrecks about 50 miles south, and said the $12 beach permit 'covers Marker 0 to Marker 62'. The map pin was on an RV park.
What it says now
The Port Aransas city beach runs from Horace Caldwell Pier (Marker 0) to the city limit immediately south of Access Road 1, around Marker 62 (Port Aransas Code § 27-401(a)). Markers 62 to about 103 are City of Corpus Christi beach, and Mustang Island State Park begins around Marker 103 (Corpus Christi beach permit map). North of the pier is Nueces County's I.B. Magee Beach Park. Inside the state park, operating a metal detector is an offense except as authorized by permit (31 TAC § 59.134(i)); the lost-item permit was removed. That offense is a Class C Parks and Wildlife Code misdemeanor (§ 13.112) with a fine of $25 to $500 (§ 12.406). An Antiquities Code violation is a misdemeanor with a $50–$1,000 fine and/or up to 30 days in jail, each day a separate offense (Nat. Res. Code § 191.171). Historic wreck material on state tidelands and artifacts on public land belong to Texas and need a Texas Historical Commission permit to remove (§§ 191.091–191.093). The national seashore penalty is up to $5,000 and/or 6 months (36 CFR 1.3; 18 U.S.C. 1865), with no forfeiture claim. The 1554 fleet wrecked roughly 85–90 miles south, near Mansfield Cut. The $12 calendar-year permit is for parking on the city beach (§ 27-450) and isn't needed in the county park or between Markers 52 and 58. The 'allowed' verdict stands: Ch. 27 (Public Beach) has no metal-detecting, digging or sand-removal rule. The pin was moved onto the beach.
2 pages corrected

Royal Peacock Opal Mine: map pin, land history, opal care, safety and age rules corrected

What was wrong
The map pin was about 17 miles from the mine, on BLM land, and the page called its coordinates approximate. It said the mine's mineral rights predate the refuge's 1931 establishment and were 'grandfathered'; the opal material page said 'grandfathered mineral rights' on 'patented claims' next to 'adjacent free BLM ground'. It said Virgin Valley opal is hydrophane and every fresh piece must go straight into water. It said eye protection was required for everyone, that bank digging was for ages 12 and up, that mechanical tools meant removal without refund and a possible ban, and that entering without paying was 'criminal trespass' under NRS 207.200. It said the claims were staked in 1912 and kept as a working claim until 1981, called the access road a county road, gave the nearby Virgin Valley refuge page as 1 mile away, and described neighboring Bonanza and Rainbow Ridge claims and their rates in ways the operators' pages don't support.
What it says now
The pin is now on the mine (41.7862, -119.0999), which the BLM land-status map shows as private land inside the Sheldon National Wildlife Refuge boundary; the Virgin Valley refuge page is about 6.8 miles away. Virgin Valley's opal mines were worked from 1905 (Royal Peacock developed in 1912) and remained when the land became part of the refuge; the refuge has been closed to new mining claims since 1991 (PLO 6849, extended to 2031 by PLO 7761). Opal care follows the operator: depending on the type, fresh bank opal goes into water or into a sealed bag for a year; opal that is 35% or more fossilized wood can be damaged by soaking; tailings material stays dry. Everyone in the mining area needs closed-toe or hard-toed shoes; hard hats and safety glasses are for bank diggers. Children 12 and under (the terms; the digging page says under 12) may not dig the bank. The mechanical-tools rule has no stated penalty beyond the operator refusing or ending access. NRS 207.200 makes trespass a misdemeanor (up to 6 months and/or $1,000, NRS 193.150) only when you enter to commit an unlawful act or stay after a warning or where the land is posted. The mine has been open for fee digging since 1981; the access is about 10 miles of gravel through the refuge. Neighboring mines' rates and seasons now match their published pages, and the 2026 season (May 1 to October 18) is stated as ended. Bonanza Opal Mines now charges $75 per person per day and opens weekends (Friday–Sunday) from Memorial Day weekend through Labor Day weekend; the Virgin Valley page no longer calls the opal hydrophane.
3 pages corrected

Rockhound State Park, New Mexico: no weight limit in the rule, collecting only in posted areas of the Rockhound unit, and the real penalties

What was wrong
The Rockhound State Park page presented 15 lb per visitor as the park's collecting limit throughout (quick answer, meta description, stat block, restrictions, FAQ, comparison table), said the day-use fee covered collecting up to 15 lb, and said exceeding it led to confiscation and citation, and commercial collecting to confiscation and removal, with no source for either penalty. It placed collecting along the Jasper and Thunder Egg Trails and pointed collectors to the Spring Canyon unit and its Lovers Leap Trail as part of the collecting area. It said the park covered 1,100 acres, was about 7 miles southeast of Deming, was named for thundereggs, and stood on ground mined for precious metals, copper, lead and manganese from 1880 to 1956. It dated the volcanic rocks to 24–33 million years and capped BLM petrified wood at 25 lb a day plus one piece without the 250 lb yearly maximum. The materials pages for agate and thunder eggs repeated the daily-limit and "named for" claims.
What it says now
The rule that allows collecting, 19.5.2.25(A) NMAC, permits it only in areas designated and posted at the Rockhound unit, for souvenirs, with small hand tools, and sets no weight. Under NMSA 16-2-32(A) park personnel strictly regulate the quantity removed; the park's 2011 management plan describes 15 lb per person as a long-standing unofficial guideline. The page now tells readers to ask at the visitor center or call (575) 546-6182 for the current limit. Removing material outside designated areas, for commercial use or beyond what staff authorize is a petty misdemeanor (NMSA 16-2-32(A)), punishable by up to 6 months in the county jail and/or a $500 fine (NMSA 31-19-1(B)); breaking a park rule such as the tool limits is a penalty assessment misdemeanor ($30 first, $50 second, $150 third or later, plus court costs; NMSA 16-2-33), and officers may eject violators (19.5.2.27(E) NMAC). Spring Canyon, about 3.5 miles away by road, is a day-use hiking and picnicking area; its Lovers Leap Trail (2.36 mi round trip) ends at BLM's Florida Mountains Wilderness Study Area. The park is about 905 acres in two units (Rockhound about 329 acres), about 10 miles east-southeast of downtown Deming in a straight line (13 by road); the land was donated in 1964 and the park dedicated in 1966; it is known for thundereggs; the volcanic rocks are about 24–28.5 million years old; and manganese and fluorite were mined elsewhere in the Little Florida Mountains until 1959. Day-use fees are per vehicle under 19.5.6.8 NMAC, walk-ins are free, and America the Beautiful passes are not accepted. Land around the park is a mix of BLM, state trust and private land: reasonable amounts on BLM land (43 CFR 8365.1-5(b)(2)), no collecting on state trust land (19.2.19.18(A)(15) NMAC), and petrified wood on BLM land capped at 25 lb plus one piece a day and 250 lb a year (43 CFR 3622.4(a)(1)).
3 pages corrected

Agate Beach, Oregon: Yaquina Head is north of the beach, sand may be collected within limits, and no plover closure applies

What was wrong
The Agate Beach page put Yaquina Head Outstanding Natural Area immediately south of Agate Beach, said Moolack Beach ran from Otter Rock down to Yaquina Head with Agate Beach at its southern end, and its map pin was on a house inland. It said sand could not be dug up or removed at all, applied western snowy plover closures (March 15–September 15) to Agate Beach, cited unspecified "BLM Yaquina Head ONA management rules" with a "possible fine" as the federal penalty, and listed Glass Beach (California) as prohibited under 14 CCR § 4611. The Bandon Beach page also placed Yaquina Head immediately south of Agate Beach and gave the distance between the two pages as 190 miles.
What it says now
Yaquina Head is at the north end of Agate Beach: Agate Beach runs south from the headland toward Newport's Nye Beach, and Moolack Beach is the separate stretch north of the headland toward Otter Rock. The pin is now at Agate Beach State Recreation Site, and the Bandon distance is 109 miles. OAR 736-021-0090(4)(a) allows, per person, one gallon a day and three gallons a year of agates and other non-living items loose on the ground, five gallons a day of sand (20 a year) and of cobble (10 a year), each in an individual container that can't be combined with another person's; outside those allowances (2)(b) bars digging up or removing sand, soil, rock, historical or fossil material, and OPRD may restrict removal by area, quantity and time of year. Agate Beach isn't one of OPRD's snowy plover management areas. At Yaquina Head, 43 CFR 8365.1-5(a) applies, the personal-collecting allowance in 8365.1-5(b) doesn't apply on developed recreation sites or where posted, and the penalty is up to $1,000 and/or 12 months (43 CFR 8360.0-7); its tide pools are a Marine Garden closed to taking invertebrates. Glass Beach is prohibited under 14 CCR §§ 4307(a) and 4308 and Fort Bragg Municipal Code § 9.68.030(Q). The Oregon Beach Bill guide and an earlier register entry dated the rule "effective May 26, 2025"; the current version is PRD 2-2024, effective February 28, 2024.
3 pages corrected

Coyote Buttes: fossil and rock collecting is prohibited under the Vermilion Cliffs monument plan; the buttes are in Arizona

What was wrong
The page rated fossil collecting at Coyote Buttes "unclear", saying BLM had published no casual-collection policy for the Vermilion Cliffs National Monument / Paria Canyon-Vermilion Cliffs Wilderness area. It presented the buttes as a Utah site, said vertebrate fossils could not be collected "under any circumstances", said hand tools were permitted under the Wilderness Act, and gave a $9 lottery application fee. It described Coyote Buttes South as a less competitive lottery without its quota, vehicle requirement or fees, called House Rock Valley Road "graded dirt", said rangers check permits in person at the trailhead kiosk, and cited 43 CFR 2932.57(a)(3) for entering without a permit and 16 U.S.C. 1133(c) for wilderness tool violations. It also stated documented dinosaur trackways and arthropod burrows at North Coyote Buttes without a source, and gave distances of 110 miles to Grand Staircase-Escalante and 195 miles to San Rafael Swell.
What it says now
The verdict is now prohibited. BLM's Vermilion Cliffs National Monument Approved Resource Management Plan (January 2008) says the collection of any objects in the monument, including fossils, track ways or rock specimens, is not authorized except by permit for scientific research or use (MA-GL-03), and prohibits recreational collecting of rocks, mineral specimens, petrified wood, fossils or plants (MA-RR-18); 43 CFR 49.805(a) excludes land closed by a land use plan from casual collecting. Coyote Buttes North and South (and White Pocket) are in Arizona, inside the monument (Proclamation 7374); the page's Utah pin is the Wire Pass trailhead on BLM Kanab Field Office land. Coyote Buttes North lottery fees are a $6 non-refundable application fee plus $7 per person or dog if selected; Coyote Buttes South allows 20 people a day (half by advance calendar, half by Daily Lottery), costs $6 plus $5 per person or dog, and BLM says a four-wheel-drive, high-clearance vehicle is required. BLM says House Rock Valley Road in Utah is not periodically maintained and is impassable when wet, and that staff may ask to see your permit and ID. Penalties now cite 43 CFR 2932.57(a)(1) and (b)(1) (Class A misdemeanor), 43 CFR 6302.20(d) and 6302.30(a), 16 U.S.C. 470aaa-5, and 43 CFR 8365.1-5(a)(2) with 8360.0-7. The trackway and burrow claims were removed, and distances corrected to 35.5 and 142.3 miles. The Utah fossil-hunting and Arizona rockhounding state overviews were updated to match.
3 pages corrected

Cape May: state park permit, beach-tag hours and fees, penalties, shoreline geography and lost-property law

What was wrong
The Cape May page said Cape May Point State Park requires a "Special Use Permit" for metal detecting, that the permit fee "varies" and is "often not granted regardless of fee", and that the city's beach tag is needed all day from Memorial Day to Labor Day, at a flat $40 per season with free tags for veterans only. It gave the penalty for tag violations only as a "municipal citation; fine" and didn't mention the 10 p.m.–6 a.m. beach closure. It said the Borough of Cape May Point surrounds the state park, that a detectorist near the lighthouse could be on City of Cape May land, that Cape May Point is "a few miles south", that Battery 223 sits near Sunset Beach where the state park and borough meet, that the whole city is a National Historic Landmark, and that the Borough of Cape May Point's rules had to be confirmed locally. It called Sunset Beach a Lower Township beach without saying it is privately owned, called the SS Atlantus a WWII ship, said no New Jersey law governs keeping beach finds, and listed 19th-century and WWII-era finds without a source. The New Jersey overview said Cape May's city beaches sit between the state park and the Borough of Cape May Point, and neither it nor the Asbury Park and Island Beach pages mentioned New Jersey's lost-property law; the Asbury Park page implied ordinary finds are yours to keep.
What it says now
Detecting in a state park needs a permit from the park Superintendent or designee, which may limit location, hours and days; none is issued for areas of significant historical or other value or where detecting would harm the resource or interfere with public use (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.16). Most of Cape May Point State Park is the Cape May Point Natural Area, so the page says we'd expect a refusal, as our reading of those criteria, and to ask the park office about cost. Digging up or removing soil, rock, historic or fossil material in the park needs the written permission of the Director of Parks and Forestry (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.10(c)). On city beaches, tags are required 10 a.m.–5 p.m. (City Code § 158-6), in 2026 from Saturday, May 23 to Labor Day, September 7; a season tag is $30 if bought December 1–April 30 and $40 after, with $25 weekly, $20 three-day and $10 daily tags, free under 12 and for active military and their families, active New Jersey National Guard and veterans with documentation (§ 158-3). Nobody may be on the beach or in the adjacent water from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., year-round (§ 158-9B(17)), or in the dunes or sand fencing (§ 158-12C); violations carry up to a $1,250 fine, 90 days in jail or 90 days' community service, each day a separate violation (§ 158-15; Ch. 1, Art. III). The city's beach and digging rules don't restrict detecting: Chapter 158 has no detector rule and Chapter 368's park digging ban excludes beaches (§ 368-2). West of the city lie The Nature Conservancy's South Cape May Meadows (beach use limited to nature viewing March 15–August 31), then the state park, then the Borough of Cape May Point; near the lighthouse there is no city land. The borough's code (Ch. 58) has no detecting rule; it requires its own beach tag for anyone 12+ in season ($40 season before May 31, $50 after, $25 weekly, $10 daily), gives city tag holders transit-only access, fines dune violations $2,000 each and doubles fines from 11 p.m. to 6 a.m. Battery 223 stands on the state park's beach (NJDEP). Sunset Beach is privately owned (Hume family / Sunset Beach Gift Shops), so detecting there needs the owner's permission; Higbee Beach WMA bans detecting. The SS Atlantus was a World War I-era concrete ship launched November 21, 1918, that went aground June 8, 1926. The National Historic Landmark is Cape May's historic district (1976). New Jersey's lost-property law requires a finder to make reasonable efforts to return lost property, lets the finder claim it only if the owner doesn't reclaim it within 120 days, and for buried or hidden lost property lets the landowner, not the finder, claim title (N.J.S.A. 46:30C-3, -4); keeping an item when you know whose it is can be theft (N.J.S.A. 2C:20-6). The unsourced find claims were removed. The New Jersey overview, Asbury Park and Island Beach pages now carry the lost-property rule, and the overview gives the shoreline order correctly.
4 pages corrected

Padre Island NS and South Padre Island: distances, forfeiture claim and the 1554 wreck sites

What was wrong
The Padre Island National Seashore page put South Padre Island about 60 miles south and Port Aransas about 40 miles north, and listed equipment forfeiture as a penalty for detecting in the seashore. The South Padre Island page said Port Aransas is closer to the 1554 Spanish Plate Fleet wreck corridor and that the wreck corridor is 60+ miles north of South Padre.
What it says now
Pin to pin, South Padre Island is about 94 miles south of the seashore page and Port Aransas about 31 miles north. 36 CFR 1.3 and 18 U.S.C. 1865 set fines and up to 6 months in jail; neither provides for forfeiting a detector, so that claim was removed. The Texas Historical Commission ties the 1554 wrecks to Mansfield Cut, about 34 miles north of South Padre Island and 85–90 miles south of Port Aransas.
2 pages corrected

Wrightsville Beach: source of the detecting rule, hole-filling penalty, Lumina location and Masonboro Island digging ban

What was wrong
The page said the town's own visitor guidelines confirm detecting is legal unless posted otherwise; that source (wrightsvillebeach.com) is a commercial tourism site, not the town. It gave the penalty for an unfilled hole as a default Class 3 misdemeanor under G.S. 14-4. It placed the Lumina Pavilion at the north end of the beach near Station One and said its footprint yields older finds. It called Masonboro Island Reserve's detecting status unclear, saying its rules only cover scientific collecting. It gave (910) 341-4630 for Parks & Recreation, allowed dogs October 1–March 30, and put Cape Hatteras National Seashore about 180 miles north.
What it says now
No Town of Wrightsville Beach ordinance restricts metal detecting: the beach chapter of the Town Code (Ch. 92) and the town's posted beach rules don't mention it, and NC DEQ says local ordinances govern detecting on beaches that aren't state parks. The rule that applies is § 92.17: fill every hole. Under § 92.99(G) a violation is a misdemeanor under G.S. 14-4 with a fine of up to $500, plus a $100 civil penalty if the citation isn't paid within 10 days. Lumina stood at the south end (state marker D-97, Waynick Blvd. between Nathan and Iula Streets, '100 yds. E.'); the finds claim was removed. Masonboro Island Reserve's rules prohibit disturbances of the soil and disturbing or removing cultural resources without Division of Coastal Management authorization (15A NCAC 07O .0202(6), (9)), which rules out digging targets there. Parks & Recreation is (910) 256-7925; leashed dogs are allowed October 1–March 31 only (§ 91.21). Cape Hatteras is about 148 miles north-east.
1 page corrected

South Padre Island: Padre Island NS distance, wildlife refuge, beach driving, county fees, Boca Chica and penalties

What was wrong
The page put Padre Island National Seashore about 60 miles north on the same 113-mile barrier island, reachable by a long drive up the open beach or via US-77/TX-186. It said the undeveloped beach north of Beach Access 5 toward the Port Mansfield East Cut is open to recreational 4WD driving and is how detectorists reach quieter stretches, without mentioning that much of it is Laguna Atascosa National Wildlife Refuge. It gave the county park fee as 'varies seasonally', said removing an antiquity is a misdemeanor only if not reported, said a PINS violation can lead to equipment confiscation, described the city dune-permit review as by the Shoreline Task Force, GLO and City Council with fines that 'vary', and said Cameron County periodically closes Boca Chica Beach, about 20 miles south, on a few days' notice. It called the Open Beaches Act the legal basis for detecting, and it did not mention the City Code's rule against digging holes in a park without a use permit.
What it says now
The National Park Service says the seashore does not extend onto South Padre Island, a separate island to the south; the seashore begins at the Mansfield Channel, about 34 miles north, and no direct road connects them (the route is US-77 (I-69E) to Corpus Christi, then TX-358 and Park Road 22). North of the county beach accesses, more than eight miles of beachfront are Laguna Atascosa NWR, where searching for treasure or removing objects without a permit is prohibited (50 CFR 27.61–27.63); the page now says to call the refuge before detecting north of Beach Access 6. Vehicles are forbidden on city beaches except police, emergency, refuse and permitted vehicles (SPI Code §§ 18-4, 22-8.3); county beach driving is from Beach Access 5 (E.K. Atwood Park) and Beach Access 6 (seasonal). County day use is $15 per vehicle (30-day pass $35, annual $100). Removing an antiquity from state, county or city land, including tidelands, without a Texas Historical Commission permit (§ 191.093) is a misdemeanor (§ 191.171), each day a separate offense. 36 CFR 1.3 and 18 U.S.C. 1865 set fines and jail but no equipment forfeiture. City dune violations carry a fine up to $500 per day (§ 22-18), removing sand from the beach system is unlawful (§ 22-17(D)), and dune permits are reviewed by the Beach and Dune Task Force, the GLO or the Attorney General's Office (§ 22-8). Boca Chica, about 5 miles away across Brazos Santiago Pass, is in the City of Starbase, which gives 48 hours' notice of SpaceX closures (31 TAC § 15.38). The Open Beaches Act guarantees public access to and use of the beach (§ 61.011). The verdict stays allowed — no city or county rule mentions detecting — with a new condition: City Code § 25-8(A)(2) bars digging holes in a park without a use permit, and whether the City treats the Gulf beach as a park is unconfirmed.
Sources
1 page corrected

Wiley Well: Chuckwalla National Monument, county, field offices, camping and penalties

What was wrong
The Wiley Well page did not say the geode beds are inside Chuckwalla National Monument. It put the site in Riverside County, said it is managed by BLM's El Centro Field Office and not the Palm Springs–South Coast Field Office, and called it a formally designated collecting area, one of a small number nationwide. It said Wiley's Well Campground is open only from September 15 to April 15, that a high-clearance 4WD vehicle is required, and that summer heat regularly tops 115°F. It listed confiscation of excess material and vehicle impoundment as penalties, and said that over 250 lb a year could be bought through the local office.
What it says now
The geode beds have been inside Chuckwalla National Monument since January 14, 2025 (Proclamation 10881). The proclamation lists rockhounding among the area's recreation uses, tells the management plan to consider the permissible casual collection of rocks and names no rocks or minerals as monument objects, so personal-use collecting under BLM California's 25 lb/day plus one piece, 250 lb/year limit continues; it also withdraws the land from new mining claims and sale and limits vehicles to inventoried routes. The beds are in Imperial County under the El Centro Field Office; the campgrounds and the monument as a whole are handled by the Palm Springs–South Coast Field Office. BLM lists Wiley Well Geode Beds among nine named rockhounding areas on its national page. Wiley's Well and Coon Hollow (Mule Mountain LTVA) are open year-round: an LTVA permit ($40 for 14 days, $180 for the season) is needed from September 15 to April 15, and camping is free with a 14-day limit the rest of the year. BLM says the graded road is normally passable to all vehicles when dry, but as of October 15, 2026 it is 4x4-only after Post-Tropical Cyclone Rachel. Average highs at Blythe are 105–109°F in June–August (NOAA 1991–2020 normals). 43 CFR 8360.0-7 and 8340.0-7 set a fine of up to $1,000 and/or up to 12 months; neither provides for confiscation or impoundment, and selling requires a BLM contract or permit (43 CFR 8365.1-5(c)).
4 pages corrected

Bandon Beach: plover rules, fire ban, driftwood limit, Coquille Point Marine Garden and refuge penalties

What was wrong
The Bandon Beach page said a snowy plover closure was "active right now" south of China Creek, limiting the beach to foot and horse traffic on wet sand, and that an open-flame ban had been in effect at Bandon State Natural Area since July 20, 2026, with a matching penalty. Its rules box and permit note put driftwood inside the one-gallon limit. It gave no Coquille Point Marine Garden rule, no refuge penalty statute (only a generic "federal citation"), said the refuge has 1,854 rocks, said Message in a Bottle bottles are hidden daily with no season, and put Lincoln City 90 miles north with nearly 3,000 floats and no yearly limit. The Oregon Beach Bill guide said marine gardens allow no collecting of any kind.
What it says now
From March 15 to September 15 (OPRD may end it July 15), the plover management area from the posted boundary in Bandon State Natural Area south to Floras Lake is closed above the wet sand; dogs, bikes, vehicles, kites and drones are banned on the wet sand, and camping and fires are prohibited (OAR 736-021-0090(15)). The July 20 open-flame ban could not be found in any OPRD or city source and was removed; the page now says fire rules change with the season and to check with OPRD and the City of Bandon. Driftwood has its own limit: one cubic yard a day and three cords a year, loaded by hand (OAR 736-021-0090(4)(a)(D)). The Coquille Point Marine Garden (OAR 141-142-0155) is closed to taking shellfish and other invertebrates (ODFW) and plants or seaweed (OAR 736-021-0090(4)(b)(H)); loose agates and empty shells there fall under the gallon limits, and the guide now says the same. Entering the refuge rocks is trespass under 50 CFR 26.21(a), punishable under 16 U.S.C. 668dd(f) by a fine and up to 1 year (knowing) or 180 days (other). The refuge has more than 1,800 rocks, reefs and islands. Message in a Bottle is a Chamber program that ran on weekends February 13–March 15 in 2026; Lincoln City is about 130 miles north, places over 3,000 floats a year and allows one per household per year. The map pin moved from private land inland to Face Rock State Scenic Viewpoint.
2 pages corrected

Flaming Gorge NRA: wrong fossil regulation, penalties, fees, limits, geology and Kemmerer distance

What was wrong
The page cited 36 CFR 261.9(i) as the rule banning removal of vertebrate fossils and gave a Class B misdemeanor penalty (up to $5,000 and 6 months) under 16 U.S.C. 551. It said collecting was allowed up to an unspecified "reasonable personal-use quantity", that research permits go to paleontologists affiliated with a museum or university, and that a Recreation Use Pass ($5/day, $15/16 days, $35/year) is needed only at boat launches and the Little Hole trail, so most outcrops could be reached without one. It said canyon erosion around the reservoir exposes the Green River Formation, that the formation was named for outcrops along this stretch of river, and that Kemmerer is about 100 miles northeast. It treated the private fee quarries as being on private lease land only.
What it says now
36 CFR 261.9(i) protects cave resources, not fossils; the fossil rule is 36 CFR 291.27(a)(1). A knowing violation carries a fine under Title 18 and up to 5 years in prison (2 years if value plus restoration cost is $500 or less) under 36 CFR 291.34, with civil penalties (291.28) and forfeiture (291.41). Casual collecting is limited to 25 pounds a day and 100 pounds a calendar year, by surface collection or non-powered hand tools (291.5), and casually collected fossils cannot be sold (291.11). Permits go only to applicants with a graduate degree in paleontology or equivalent training, for work that furthers paleontological knowledge, with an approved repository (291.13–291.15). The Flaming Gorge pass is $5 a day, $15 a week or $35 a year per vehicle and is required at developed fee sites: boat launches, day-use areas and swim beaches, including Little Hole and the Spillway. The canyon country around the Red Canyon Visitor Center (the map pin) is Precambrian Uinta Mountain Group quartzite; the Green River Formation is exposed mainly around the Wyoming half of the reservoir, and USGS Geolex says Hayden's 1869 name probably refers to exposures in Sweetwater County, Wyoming. Kemmerer is about 80 miles northwest, and its fee quarries are commercial operations on state and private land.
1 page corrected

Asbury Park Beach: 12-inch hole limit, tent ban, badge penalty and map pin

What was wrong
The Asbury Park page said the city's beach rules don't touch on detecting and called the beach 'unrestricted', without mentioning the code's limit on hole depth or its ban on removing sand. It said tents and canopies were fined only if they broke posted size rules, gave the penalty for using the beach without a badge as an unspecified 'municipal citation and fine', listed badge booths at Asbury, 2nd, 3rd, 5th, 6th and 7th Avenues, and placed the map pin on a house west of the beach.
What it says now
The City Code still has no rule on metal detectors, so the verdict stays allowed, but no hole may leave a depression more than 12 inches deep (§ 5-4.14) and no one may take or haul beach sand or soil from the beachfront (§ 5-4.12). Tents, camping tents and canopies are prohibited outright ($250 fine, § 5-4.23); only umbrellas up to 6 feet across and small infant shades are allowed. Using the beach in season without a pass (§§ 5-1(b), 5-2.1), and digging too deep or removing sand, fall under the general penalty of § 1-5: up to $2,000, up to 90 days in jail or up to 90 days' community service, each day a separate violation. Season badges are sold online from April 1 and in person from May 1 at the Beach Office (Boardwalk at First Avenue) and the 7th Avenue beach booth. The pin now sits on the sand between First and Second Avenues.
1 page corrected

Nags Head: hole rule, penalty, USS Huron wreck, beach driving and Jockey's Ridge permit

What was wrong
The page gave the penalty for unattended holes or equipment only as a "municipal citation and fine" under an unnamed beach ordinance, tied the hole rule to blocking "beach-driving lanes", and said the region's shipwreck material is concentrated in Cape Hatteras National Seashore rather than off Nags Head's beach. It said no vehicles at all may use the beach in summer, described the Jockey's Ridge permit as covering only a specific item "in the specific area it was lost", did not mention the seashore's broken-down-and-packed exception, called Nags Head North Carolina's first or oldest beach resort, and put Wrightsville Beach 260 miles away.
What it says now
Unattended holes and equipment violate Town Code §§ 8-8 and 8-9, a Class 3 misdemeanor under G.S. 14-4(a) (Town Code § 1-6(b)); the fine is capped at $50 because the ordinance sets no higher maximum, and the town may remove unattended items (§ 8-8(e)). Under § 8-9 a hole can't be left unattended at night at all or for more than an hour by day without refilling it, and mustn't block emergency, ocean-rescue or public-works vehicles or the public, or endanger people or nesting sea turtles. The wreck of the USS Huron (1877) lies about 250 yards off the Nags Head beach, a state Heritage Dive Site where collecting is prohibited, and wreck material unclaimed for more than 10 years on the bottom out to one marine league belongs to North Carolina (G.S. 121-22). Recreational beach driving is barred May 1–September 30; municipal, emergency and beach-restoration vehicles and licensed commercial fishermen are exempt (§ 8-87). At Jockey's Ridge, 07 NCAC 13B .0203 allows a detector only to locate lost personal property under a Special Use Permit, including at the Soundside Access. In the seashore, 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) allows a detector that is broken down and packed. NCpedia dates Nags Head as a summer resort to the 1830s, with no first-or-oldest claim. Wrightsville Beach is about 172 miles away, pin to pin.
1 page corrected

Padre Island National Seashore: 1554 wrecks are in state tidelands; penalties, exemptions, turtle patrols and park rules

What was wrong
The Padre Island National Seashore page said the 1554 Spanish Plate Fleet wrecks and the salvors' shore camp sit inside the seashore under "double federal protection", with the Mansfield Cut Underwater Archeological District adding its own federal protection. It said roughly half of about 300 people drowned, salvors recovered less than half the cargo, divers rediscovered the sites in the late 1960s, and NPS and the THC had run joint investigations since 2020. It listed a recreational detecting permit as required while saying none exists, and said the only exception to the detector ban is a unit broken down and stored. It gave ESA civil penalties as up to $25,000 and the ARPA penalty as only the $20,000/2-year felony tier. It described morning ATV nest patrols and nest-triggered beach closures, called the seashore 70 miles long, said more than 60 gas wells had been drilled with EOG Resources among the operators, put South Padre Island 60 miles away in the alternatives, said both South Padre and Port Aransas need a mainland drive, gave the Compendium as revised December 2025, the visitor center as closed only on Christmas, South Beach Mile 0–5 as passable by 2WD only in dry conditions with high clearance required beyond, and the entrance fee as $15–$25.
What it says now
The NPS administrative history says "all three shipwrecks rested in the tidelands on the edge of the National Seashore": Espíritu Santo about 3 miles north of the Mansfield Channel, San Esteban about 2.5 miles further north; Santa María de Yciar was destroyed by channel dredging in the late 1950s. The sites were listed on the National Register on January 21, 1974 as the Mansfield Cut Underwater Archeological District, a listing that adds no visitor rule. As pre-20th-century wrecks in state tidelands they are state archeological landmarks under the Texas Antiquities Code (Nat. Res. Code § 191.091; misdemeanor, $50–$1,000 and/or up to 30 days, § 191.171). On seashore land, 36 CFR 2.1 and ARPA apply (up to $10,000/1 year; $20,000/2 years over $500; $100,000/5 years for a repeat conviction). About 300 were aboard and nearly 250 died in the wrecking and march toward Veracruz; salvors worked the wrecks July–September 1554; Vida Lee Connor located the first wreck in 1964, Platoro's 1967 salvage led to the 1969 Antiquities Code, and NPS and the THC surveyed the area in 2020–2021. The page now lists all (a)(7) exemptions (broken down and packed, navigation electronics, authorized scientific, mining or administrative work), the 36 CFR 1.3 / 18 U.S.C. 1865 / 3571 penalty, and the ESA civil penalty of up to $65,653 (50 CFR 11.33). Turtle patrollers on UTVs cover the whole beach throughout the day from April to mid-July and nests are moved to protected areas. The seashore has about 66 miles of beach; mineral rights were reserved under the 1962 act and the NPS and Texas Railroad Commission plugged 11 orphaned wells in 2021. South Padre Island is 93.6 miles away and only reachable by a 3–4 hour mainland drive; Port Aransas is about 31 miles north by island road, past City of Corpus Christi beaches and Mustang Island State Park. Fees are $25 per vehicle for 7 days ($10 for 1 day), $20 motorcycle, $15 per person, $45 annual; the visitor center is open 9 a.m.–5 p.m., closed Thanksgiving and Christmas; 2WD is allowed to Mile 5 and 4WD is required beyond. The page now cites the Compendium revised July 2026, including the shell/sea bean, driftwood, found-property and beach-obstruction rules.
2 pages corrected

Opal Butte: private land, not patented claims surrounded by BLM land

What was wrong
The Opal Butte page, the opal material page and the Oregon rockhounding overview said the opal deposit sits on patented mining claims surrounded by BLM Prineville District land open under the BLM Oregon/Washington car-trunk/250 lb rule. The Site page named the BLM Prineville District as the land manager, cited ORS 105.810 (timber and produce damages) for trespass, listed BLM stockpile theft and over-limit penalties, and said West Coast Gemstones had sold a 315-carat opal.
What it says now
GIA's 1988 Gems & Gemology note puts the mine on privately owned land, and BLM land-status mapping shows the land around the butte is private too; no open mining claims were found within about 12 miles. The nearest public land is Umatilla National Forest (Heppner Ranger District), about 2 miles east and south, where Forest Service rules allow personal, non-commercial hand collection with no barter or sale (FS-1091); the nearest BLM land is a parcel about 6 miles southeast. Neither has a documented opal occurrence. Entering private land without permission is criminal trespass in the second degree under ORS 164.245, a Class C misdemeanor (up to 30 days and a $1,250 fine). GIA reports a 315-carat crystal opal found, not sold.
3 pages corrected

Badlands: Buffalo Gap vertebrate-fossil permit citation

What was wrong
The Badlands National Park page (and the 2026-10-20 register entry for it) cited 36 CFR 261.9(i) as the rule requiring a permit for vertebrate fossils on Buffalo Gap National Grassland. 36 CFR 261.9(i) covers cave resources, not fossils.
What it says now
Collecting paleontological resources on National Forest System lands, including national grasslands, without a permit is prohibited by 36 CFR 291.27(a)(1); research permits are issued under 36 CFR 291.13. The page now cites those sections.
1 page corrected

Green River Formation: fossil insects, quarry locations and fees, land pattern, research permits and penalties

What was wrong
The Green River Formation (BLM) page said insect fossils ("beetles, damselflies") are casually collectable on BLM land as invertebrate material. It said American Fossil Quarry is about 6 miles west of Kemmerer on US-30, gave fee-dig prices of about $79–$169, and said rare species are typically excluded from the standard take-home fee and kept by the operator or given to research institutions. It said BLM research permits go only to paleontologists affiliated with a museum, university or recognized institution. It described the area as alternating one-square-mile BLM and private sections from 19th-century railroad grants, without mentioning Wyoming state trust land. It called removing a fish fossil an "accidental federal felony" and gave the federal criminal penalties without saying they apply to knowing violations. It gave Wyoming criminal trespass as a misdemeanor without the elements or penalty, and listed no penalty for the Wyoming paleontological-deposit permit law it cited. It said Green River fish were preserved because a cold snap made carcasses sink and the lake bottom was anoxic, and that the lake lasted about five million years. The map pin was on the Wasatch Formation rather than the Green River Formation.
What it says now
Casual collecting on BLM land covers common invertebrate and plant fossils: up to 25 lb per person per day, and a slab or cobble over 25 lb may be removed with non-motorized hand tools to keep a specimen intact (43 CFR 49.810(a)); the Kemmerer RMP Record of Decision (2010, Decision 5014) continues to allow it. Fossil insects may count as uncommon, which the land manager can exclude from casual collecting (43 CFR 49.810(c)), so the page now says to ask the Kemmerer Field Office before keeping one. BLM says it is illegal to dig, remove or collect vertebrate fossils, including fish, without a research permit; those permits go only to applicants with a relevant degree or demonstrated training and experience, for research or public education, with finds going to an approved repository (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-3; 43 CFR 49.110). Blue Moon Quarry is about 6 miles west of Kemmerer on US-30; American Fossil (closed for 2026) is north of Kemmerer off Hwy 233 and Dempsey Road, and the operator says to use its directions, not GPS. A standard adult dig costs about $55–$169 depending on operator and length (private excursions from $750), and take-home rules vary by operator: some exclude rare species, others let you keep anything valued under $100,000. BLM land here is intermixed with private ranch land and Wyoming state trust parcels, with no fence or marker between them; on state trust land the only fossil permits are Exclusive Commercial and Non-Exclusive Scientific. Federal criminal penalties apply to knowing violations (43 CFR 49.400); civil penalties and forfeiture can apply even to an honest mistake (16 U.S.C. §§ 470aaa-6, -7). Wyoming criminal trespass is knowingly entering without authorization or after notice, including posted signs: up to 6 months and/or $750 (W.S. 6-3-303). Excavating paleontological deposits on state or federal land without a State Board of Land Commissioners permit (W.S. 36-1-114) is a misdemeanor with a $25–$100 fine and/or up to 6 months plus forfeiture, or a felony with up to $10,000 and/or 10 years when the material is worth more than $500 (W.S. 36-1-116). The National Park Service attributes the preservation to three conditions: a saltwater bottom layer that kept scavengers away, very little oxygen at the bottom, and a microbial mat that grew over carcasses; the five-million-year figure was removed. The pin now sits on BLM land on the Green River Formation's Angelo Member.
3 pages corrected

Ruby Beach: campfire wood, the Hoh Reservation boundary, Abbey Island, sea glass, penalties and fees

What was wrong
The Ruby Beach page said beach campfires are allowed only below the high-tide line and may burn driftwood found on site, that the ban is on removal, not on-site use, and that leaving partially burned wood is litter the park calls out; the Washington beachcombing overview repeated the driftwood-fire claim. It said the beach runs about 3 miles north within the park to the Hoh River mouth, where the Hoh Indian Reservation begins north of the river, and that the walk is a day hike within the park. It said Abbey Island becomes accessible on foot at low tide, without saying it is a closed wildlife refuge. It treated sea glass as a natural object banned by 36 CFR 2.1(a)(1). It said Washington DNR-managed ocean beaches generally allow personal-use collecting of driftwood and rocks, and compared Ruby Beach with "Olympic National Forest beaches". It gave the penalty as a federal petty offense of up to $5,000 and 6 months under 36 CFR 1.3 alone, and the campfire penalty as a compendium citation and possible fine. It didn't mention the Olympic Coast National Marine Sanctuary. It put Kalaloch 10 miles away and implied dogs are allowed there but not at Ruby Beach, listed only vehicle, per-person and annual fees, said there is no surcharge for non-Washington residents and told visitors to pay at the gate. It said Destruction Island held a 94-foot lighthouse from 1888 to 1968, accessible only by boat and named for 18th-century shipwreck-era massacres.
What it says now
Beach fires are allowed on the Kalaloch-area beaches, including Ruby Beach, at least 10 feet from beach logs or grass, no more than 3 feet across and not during a burn ban (Superintendent's Compendium, 36 CFR 2.13). Using wood gathered in the park is prohibited except where the superintendent designates it (36 CFR 2.1(a)(4)); the compendium's beach driftwood designation covers only South Beach and Kalaloch campgrounds, for use there and not to be removed from the park, so the page now says to bring firewood or ask a ranger. About 1.5 miles north of the Ruby Beach parking area the park ends at the Hoh Indian Reservation, which runs north to the Hoh River mouth; the page says to ask the Hoh Tribe before walking or collecting there. Abbey Island and the sea stacks above high tide are part of Quillayute Needles National Wildlife Refuge; the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says all the islands are closed to human disturbance and the refuges are closed to all public access. Sea glass isn't named in 36 CFR 2.1; old glass and shipwreck material can be a protected cultural or historical resource (36 CFR 2.1(a)(6); below mean higher high water, the sanctuary's historical-resource rule), and the park has published no rule allowing it to be taken, so the page says to leave it or ask a ranger. Washington's ocean beaches outside the park are the Seashore Conservation Area under State Parks, where WAC 352-28-010 allows removal only under an approved resource conservation plan; private tidelands need the owner's permission and tribal land follows tribal law; the national forest has no ocean beaches. Violations of 36 CFR 2.1 and 2.13 carry up to 6 months in jail and/or a fine of up to $5,000 (36 CFR 1.3; 18 U.S.C. 1865 and 3571). The Olympic Coast National Marine Sanctuary's coastal boundary next to federally managed land is mean higher high water (15 CFR 922.150(b)), and its rules ban moving or removing sanctuary historical resources and taking marine mammals or seabirds (15 CFR 922.152(a)). Ruby Beach is 7.5 miles north of Kalaloch (NPS) and leashed pets are allowed at both. Fees are $30 per vehicle, $25 per motorcycle and $15 per person (7 days), $55 for the annual pass; Olympic is not one of the 11 parks with the 2026 $100 non-US-resident fee, and passes can be bought on Recreation.gov or at visitor centers. Destruction Island's lighthouse was first lit in 1891 and automated in 1968 (U.S. Coast Guard); the unsourced height, dates and naming story were removed.
2 pages corrected

Six Rivers National Forest: mushroom limit, closed areas and citations

What was wrong
The Six Rivers foraging page said the forest publishes no daily or gallon limit for personal use (contrasting it with Oregon's 1-gallon rule) and that collecting beyond incidental amounts needs a free-use permit capped at $20 in product value per person per year, a figure taken from Rogue River-Siskiyou, not Six Rivers. It said personal-use foraging is generally allowed in wilderness, with only commercial collecting barred under the Wilderness Act, listed four wildernesses, and cited 36 CFR 261.6(f) for selling, 261.6(a) for over-limit collecting and 16 U.S.C. 1133(c) as a penalty provision. It said Port-Orford-cedar closures cover central and northern forest roads until late spring, cited a dead closure page, gave the forest's size as about 957,590 acres, and its map pin was on a private house. The Mendocino National Forest page repeated the 'undefined incidental amount, no wilderness ban' description of Six Rivers and put it 180 miles away.
What it says now
Six Rivers' Mushroom Harvesting Policy (effective 10/10/2012) allows incidental collecting without a permit of up to 1 gallon a day and 5 gallons a year per person; above that you need a permit from a district office, and the forest's permits page says some years, for example after a large fire season, need permits even for personal-use mushroom gathering. The $20 free-use cap is removed. The forest's special forest products rules close wilderness areas, research natural areas, botanical, geologic and special interest areas and administrative sites to all harvest, along with ground within 200 feet of any building, campground, state highway or water body; the forest has six wildernesses (Siskiyou, Trinity Alps, Yolla Bolly–Middle Eel, Marble Mountain, North Fork, Mount Lassic). Removing forest products without authorization violates 36 CFR 261.6(h), punishable under 36 CFR 261.1b by up to six months and/or a fine under 18 U.S.C. 3571 (up to $5,000 for an individual); driving a closed road falls under 36 CFR 261.54 as specified in the closure order. Port-Orford-cedar road closures are set each wet season (in 2024 the Gasquet district closed eight roads from October 29). The forest covers nearly a million acres, the pin is now on Forest Service land northwest of Orleans, and the Mendocino page's Six Rivers link now gives the correct rules and a distance of about 137 miles.
2 pages corrected

Kalaloch Beach: Quinault boundary, beach fires and firewood, razor clam status, dogs at Ruby Beach

What was wrong
The page put the start of Quinault Indian Nation land near Beach Trail 3 and told visitors to treat Beach Trail 3 as the southern limit. It said beach campfires were allowed only below the high-tide line using on-site driftwood and that nothing burned or unburned could be carried off the beach, and called collecting a blanket ban under which nothing natural leaves the beach. It said the Kalaloch razor clam beach was closed for the 2025–26 season because of depressed clam populations, cited a 2019 WDFW news release, described the fishery as WDFW co-managed with coastal treaty tribes, cited only state rules for out-of-season digging, and said Kalaloch is one of the only Olympic beaches with a legal harvest activity. It said dogs are not permitted at Ruby Beach, that Ruby Beach is 10 miles north, listed sea glass as a natural object under 36 CFR 2.1(a)(1), and gave camping as $24–$48 a night. The 36 CFR 2.1 guide's table also listed sea glass under 2.1(a)(1).
What it says now
The Quinault Indian Reservation begins just south of South Beach Campground, about 3 miles south of Kalaloch Lodge (WDFW describes the Kalaloch clam beach as running from South Beach Campground to Brown's Point, just south of Beach Trail 3; the compendium's pet rule runs from the Hoh Indian Reservation south to the Quinault Indian Reservation). Beach fires are allowed on the Kalaloch-area beaches at least 10 feet from beach logs or grass and no more than 3 feet across (compendium, 36 CFR 2.13); driftwood up to 12 inches in diameter may be gathered for firewood at Kalaloch and South Beach campgrounds, burned there and never taken out of the park (36 CFR 2.1(a)(4)). WDFW has scheduled no Kalaloch digs for 2026–27, and the beach has had no recreational razor clam digs since 2018–19; razor clams are managed by WDFW and Olympic National Park with the Quinault, Hoh and Quileute tribes, with the park leading enforcement, and the compendium adopts the park's fish and shellfish regulations (36 CFR 2.3), which open several shellfish species on the coast. Leashed pets are allowed on the Kalaloch-area beaches and at Ruby Beach, about 7.5 miles north. Sea glass isn't a natural object; older glass or shipwreck debris can be a protected cultural resource (36 CFR 2.1(a)(1)(iii)). Kalaloch Campground is $24 a night and South Beach $20. The penalty is up to 6 months and/or $5,000 (36 CFR 1.3; 18 U.S.C. 1865, 3571(b)(6)). The verdict (prohibited) is unchanged.
2 pages corrected

Lady Bird Lake: verdict now unclear; city code sections, penalties and ownership corrected

What was wrong
The Lady Bird Lake page said magnet fishing was allowed with no permit question, "same as bank fishing" (bank fishing needs a TPWD fishing licence). It recommended a spot below Longhorn Dam, which is on the Colorado River outside the lake, where the city code also bans swimming and wading downstream to US 183. It called the swimming ban "citywide" with rescue as the "sole exception", limited the bridge rule to fishing from a "deck", gave penalties only as "fine under the municipal fine schedule", and described the Antiquities Code penalty as "escalating". It said the lake bed is state-owned submerged land as the reason the Antiquities Code applies, cited Tex. Parks & Wild. Code § 66.006 (illegal fishing devices), which supports nothing on the page, and told readers to check LCRA floodgate status rather than the City's waterway bans. The Guide 'Is Magnet Fishing Legal?' repeated the "bridge decks" wording.
What it says now
The verdict is now unclear. No Austin or Texas rule names magnet fishing, but the shoreline and trail are city parkland, and Austin City Code § 8-1-11(E) bars removing artifacts from a public recreation area (parks, trails, docks; § 8-1-1(15)) without an approval; PARD issues metal-detecting permits only for searches for specific lost items. The page now quotes § 8-5-48 ("A person may not swim in Lady Bird Lake"; swimming includes wading, § 8-5-1(9); exceptions include rescue and some official activities) and § 8-5-43 ("A person may not fish from a bridge that crosses the Colorado River"), adds the § 8-5-42 Shoal Creek no-fishing zone, park hours (§§ 8-1-11(C), 8-1-12(B)) and motor rules (§ 8-5-82), and gives the penalties: Class C misdemeanor up to $500 for swimming/wading (§§ 8-5-104(A), 1-1-99) and for removing artifacts from parkland (§ 8-1-4(B)); $1–$50 for bridge fishing (§ 8-5-104(D)); not less than $100 for entering a waterway under a flood ban (§§ 8-5-22, 8-5-104(B)); $50–$1,000 and/or up to 30 days, each day a separate offense, for removing a state archeological landmark without a THC permit (Tex. Nat. Res. Code §§ 191.093, 191.171). Historic finds from the state-owned river bed or city-owned land are state archeological landmarks (§§ 191.091–.092). Flood bans are issued by the fire chief and take effect when posted on the city website (§ 8-5-21). The Longhorn Dam spot and the § 66.006 source were removed. The Guide's Texas row now says the Lady Bird Lake verdict is unclear and uses "from a bridge".
2 pages corrected

Mineral Mountains (Rock Corral): mining claims, state trust land, a nonexistent geothermal permit, penalties and finds

What was wrong
The Mineral Mountains page listed a required permit for "collecting within active geothermal lease boundaries" and said Ormat had leased the federal parcels around Roosevelt Hot Springs since at least 2016. It said the lease and claim restrictions applied only to ground within a few miles of Roosevelt Hot Springs and the Blundell plant, "not to Rock Corral itself on the range's opposite west-slope canyon", and didn't mention the active mining claims near Rock Corral or the state trust land nearby. It cited 43 CFR 3602.10 as the penalty for commercial collecting, with a "potential criminal referral", added "potential forfeiture of collected material" to the 43 CFR 8360.0-7 penalty, and gave a civil-trespass penalty for collecting on a geothermal lease. It called Rock Corral the BLM's own named rockhounding site and one of the few Utah sites BLM names directly. It listed Milford obsidian from a "Roosevelt Hot Springs Mining District" and pyrite and malachite from tailings near Minersville as finds in the range, and the obsidian and copper-mineral material pages repeated them. It called the Blundell plant Utah's first commercial geothermal plant, put Topaz Mountain about 110 miles away, and said the Rock Corral turnoff is about half a mile before Milford with a fork about 2 miles in.
What it says now
There is no permit for collecting on a lease or claim. BLM says collecting is "generally not allowed … where there are active mining claims or other authorized mineral uses, or on lands where the mineral estate is owned privately." BLM's MLRS shows active quartz placer claims (Ebreuil Quartz, Pirates Dell, Malawi's Keep Mine, Nova) starting about half a mile west and north of the Rock Corral day-use area, and authorized federal geothermal leases from about 2 miles north-northwest up to the Blundell plant, about 8 miles north on the same west slope; the leases date from 1974 to 2025 (the newest, UTU 095454, effective May 1, 2025). The page now says to avoid claimed ground, check MLRS and ask the Cedar City Field Office. Scattered state trust sections lie within 2 miles and look like BLM land; collecting there needs a Utah Trust Lands rockhounding permit ($25 individual or family; 25 lb plus one piece per person per day, 250 lb a year, by hand), and removing minerals without one is a class B misdemeanor (Utah Code 53C-2-301). Penalties are now 43 CFR 8365.1-5 with 8360.0-7 (fine up to $1,000 and/or up to 12 months), civil liability to the claimant for taking the claimed mineral (30 U.S.C. 26), and the trust-land penalty; 43 CFR 3602.10 concerns applying for a mineral materials sales contract. 43 CFR 8365.1-5(b) excludes "developed recreation sites and areas", so the page says to ask the field office where collecting is OK around the day-use area. BLM's Rock Corral page says the area "is popular with rock hounders, and is known for its smoky quartz"; BLM's national rockhounding list names Dugway and Topaz Mountain for Utah, not Rock Corral. The obsidian and pyrite/malachite finds had no source and were removed from the page and the obsidian and copper-minerals pages; the Utah Geological Survey lists smoky quartz up to three inches, microcline averaging about 0.75 inch across and occasional limonite pseudomorphs after pyrite. The 34-megawatt Blundell plant, owned by PacifiCorp, began operating in 1984 (UGS). Topaz Mountain is about 93 miles north in a straight line. Directions now follow UGS: turn east 0.7 miles south of the railroad tracks on State Route 21 from Milford, then 5.4, 1.2 and 2.7 miles on a road that turns to sand.
3 pages corrected

Lance Creek: land status, rock type and dinosaur history

What was wrong
The Lance Creek page said the BLM site was "this exact drainage", the type locality of Triceratops and Torosaurus, with vertebrate material "documented from this exact ground" and fossils "still coming out of the same badlands exposures today"; it named Lance Formation freshwater mollusks, ostracods and leaf impressions as the collectable target. It did not say that the land around the BLM parcels is private or state trust land. It said Hatcher found a horn core in 1887 and collected more than 50 ceratopsian skeletons for O.C. Marsh in 1889-1892, that Triceratops made up more than 40% of North America's large dinosaurs, and that Wyoming named it state dinosaur in 1994. Directions said "I-85" and unpaved approach roads with no signage. The off-road penalty was given as a generic citation. The Wyoming state overview called Lance Creek the type area of the Lance Formation and of the first known Triceratops.
What it says now
Only the BLM parcels are open: a block of about 4 square miles around WY-270 at Lance Creek plus scattered small parcels; nearly all the surrounding land, and most of the Lance Formation outcrop, is private ranch land or Wyoming state trust land, where fossils need an Exclusive Commercial or Non-Exclusive Scientific state permit and off-road vehicles, camping and fires are prohibited (W.S. 36-2-107). The BLM parcel at BLM's published coordinates is on Pierre Shale, described by the Wyoming State Geological Survey as fossiliferous with limestone concretions; the Lance Formation outcrop begins about 8 miles north, and its type locality (mouth of Lance Creek, sec. 11 T39N R62W) is about 30 miles northeast. Hatcher's crews worked the Lance Formation of Niobrara County for four seasons from 1889 for the USGS and recovered more than 30 ceratopsian skulls, later used to name Torosaurus latus and a dozen Triceratops species (Farke 2011). The 40% figure and the 1994 date were removed. Directions now say US-85, as the route is, and BLM says its land is on either side of WY-270. The off-road penalty is 43 CFR 8340.0-7: up to $1,000 and/or 12 months. The page now notes the 49.810(a)(2) slab exception and that rare or unique invertebrate and plant fossils need a permit (49.810(c)), and that whether BLM's proposed northeast Wyoming resource management plan changes collecting here is unconfirmed. The verdict (allowed on BLM land) is unchanged.
2 pages corrected

Rogue River gold sites: motorized dredges banned at all four; Hellgate dredge ban explained

What was wrong
The Rogue River (BLM Medford District) page said suction dredges of 4 inches or less were allowed seasonally at Gold Nugget, Little Applegate and Tunnel Ridge with two state permits, because those sites were outside the essential salmon habitat designation, and that 2017's SB 3 had permanently classified only the Hellgate mainstem (about 20,688 miles statewide) as habitat. It gave the dredge seasons as BLM site seasons, said SB 838 only capped permits at 850, attributed the Hellgate dredge ban to SB 3 alone, listed equipment seizure as a penalty, gave the DEQ number as 1-800-452-5011, an old DEQ address and DSL phone, and the Star Ranger Station as 541-899-1812. Its history said Galice Creek mining began in 1854 a few miles upstream of Hellgate. The Applegate River page placed the Little Applegate and Tunnel Ridge sites about 18 miles downstream.
What it says now
All four sites, including Gold Nugget on the Rogue mainstem, are essential salmon habitat on the Department of State Lands map, so motorized in-stream placer mining is banned at every one (ORS 468B.114), and DEQ's 700-PM does not cover motorized dredges in that habitat. A non-motorized gravity or siphon dredge with a hose of 4 inches or less may be possible at Gold Nugget, Little Applegate and Tunnel Ridge only with 700-PM registration ($25 a year) and a DSL general authorization (OAR 141-089-0820/-0830, under 25 cubic yards a year), within ODFW's in-water work period (Rogue, Marial to William Jess Dam: June 15–Aug 31; Applegate basin: July 1–Sept 15), in daylight, and only if BLM still allows dredges there. Hellgate bans every dredge for three reasons: BLM's site rule (2007 brochure), the Rogue State Scenic Waterway (no dredge permits since 2001; the 700-PM excludes scenic waterways) and ORS 468B.114. SB 838 (2013) imposed a temporary moratorium on motorized mining in salmon habitat (2016–2021) and capped permits elsewhere at 850; SB 3 (2017) replaced it with a standing ban. Hand panning stays allowed with no permit, within ORS 196.810's limits (under 1 cubic yard per site, 5 a year in a habitat segment, bed or wet perimeter only, not where fish eggs are present). Penalties are now cited: motorized dredging in salmon habitat or without DEQ coverage is a Class A violation, fine up to $2,000 (ORS 468.948; ORS 153.018); removal-fill beyond the exemption without DSL authorization is a misdemeanor (ORS 196.990). Contacts updated: DEQ 800-452-4011 (toll-free in Oregon), 700 NE Multnomah St., Suite 600, Portland, 503-229-5696; DSL 503-986-5200; Star Ranger Station (541) 899-3800. History now follows the Oregon History Project. The Little Applegate and Tunnel Ridge sites are up the Little Applegate River, a tributary, about 13–14 miles northeast of the Applegate page's location in a straight line. The map pin moved to BLM's Smullin Visitor Center at Rand, inside the Hellgate stretch.
3 pages corrected

Pismo Beach: the sand by the pier is Pismo State Beach; verdict now unclear

What was wrong
The Pismo Beach page said metal detecting was allowed without a permit on a "City of Pismo Beach frontage" around the pier and downtown, with Pismo State Beach starting south of it at the North Beach Campground, and that the 1-foot hole limit applied "only on the city beach". It put the penalty for breaking that limit at fines "typically in the low hundreds of dollars" and said most first encounters end in a verbal warning. It also said a CDFW guidance fine range of $100–$1,000 applied to clamming violations, that CDFW had stepped up patrols, that 2,835 metric tons of clams were harvested "here" from 1916 to 1947, and that a 2020 clam recruitment was documented by a Cal Poly lab; it gave an unsourced pier history. The California overview listed the verdict as "Allowed (city beach)".
What it says now
California State Parks' park-boundary map places the sand by the pier inside Pismo State Beach, which runs from north of the pier south through Grover Beach to the Oceano Dunes area; the City's own page for the area is titled "Pismo State Beach, Pier, Promenade & Creek", and State Parks' operating-agreement list shows the City operating Pismo Pier from 1951 to 2005. 14 CCR § 4307(a) bars disturbing sand in State Parks units, no rule names detectors and no permit exists, so the verdict is now unclear: ask the park at (805) 473-7220 before digging. City code applies on top across all public beach within city limits (§ 12.20.010): § 12.20.090 bars holes deeper than one foot without a city permit and requires refilling. A violation is a misdemeanor (up to $1,000 and/or 6 months) unless the City Attorney charges it as an infraction ($100/$200/$500 within 12 months), under §§ 12.20.250 and 1.20.010. The page now adds the pier zone's 11 p.m.–4 a.m. closure (§ 12.20.210), gives CDFW's clam rules (10/day, 4.5 in. minimum, hand-operated gear, no clamming at night) without a fine range, says CDFW and State Parks have increased outreach and signage, states the 6.25 million lb (2,834 tons) commercial harvest as statewide, and drops the Cal Poly claim and the pier history. The map pin moved onto the sand north of the pier.
2 pages corrected

Birch Bay State Park: penalty for taking rocks and shells, metal detecting, park facts

What was wrong
The Birch Bay State Park page rested the rock-and-shell rule on WAC 352-28-010 alone and said removing them was an infraction under chapter 7.84 RCW; WAC 352-28-010 has no infraction clause. It described seaweed harvest as an exception available on state park land, though seaweed harvest is closed in every state park except Fort Ebey, Fort Flagler and Fort Worden. It treated metal detecting as unconfirmed. It gave day-use hours as 8 a.m. to dusk year-round, said the park's shoreline was the bay's 'entire' shoreline, placed the park about 8 miles south of the Peace Arch crossing, attributed biotoxin closures to WDFW, did not mention the Puget Sound crab endorsement and catch record card, and said Oregon's beach limit was a daily gallon covering driftwood, with no annual cap, 'just across the border to the south'.
What it says now
Taking a natural object from a state park is a misdemeanor under RCW 79A.05.165(1)(a) unless State Parks commission rules allow it, punishable by up to 90 days in jail and a $1,000 fine (RCW 9.92.030); WAC 352-28-010(2) allows removal of natural resources other than trees only under an approved resource conservation plan or the seaweed, edible-plant and research-permit rules, and natural resources include 'dead or organic matter' and 'geologic materials' (WAC 352-28-005). Wood-debris and metal-detector violations remain infractions (WAC 352-32-290(8), 352-32-235(7)). Birch Bay is not among the parks Washington State Parks lists for metal detecting, so the page now says detecting is not allowed. Hours are 6:30 a.m. to dusk in summer and 8 a.m. to dusk in winter; the park has 8,255 feet of saltwater shoreline, part of the bay's shore, about 10 miles south of Blaine; shellfish safety status comes from the Department of Health; crabbing in Puget Sound needs a crab endorsement and catch record card; and Oregon's limit is one gallon a day and three gallons a year of agates, shells and similar items, with separate driftwood limits. The Washington beachcombing overview had the same penalty error in its state-parks row; it now gives the RCW 79A.05.165(1)(a) misdemeanor for rocks and shells and the WAC 352-32-290(8) infraction for wood debris.
2 pages corrected

Boise River: panning prohibited from Lucky Peak Dam to Star Road

What was wrong
The Boise River page gave the verdict as "allowed", saying hand panning was free and unpermitted on the river and that the Idaho Department of Lands had designated the bed from Lucky Peak Dam to Star Road "for recreational mining" and "open to the general public as a recreational mining site" (wording IDL uses for the South Fork Payette, not the Boise), so panners there had no claims to worry about. It named Barber Park as a place to start panning, described the land as BLM-managed in part, said motorized equipment needed both an IDWR permit and an "IDEQ discharge permit" (including for power sluices), and gave penalties as an unspecified "state citation", a DEQ fine and a rejected claim application. It explained the lack of an extra permit layer by Lucky Peak Dam blocking anadromous fish passage, and discussed an IDFG spring fishing closure on the South Fork Boise.
What it says now
The State Board of Land Commissioners withdrew the bed of the Boise River from Lucky Peak Dam downstream to Star Road from mineral entry and exploration on October 11, 1988 (Idaho Code § 47-702(2)); IDL lists it among the waters closed to mining, and IDWR's 2026 Small Scale Mining Instructions list "Boise River, Star Bridge to Lucky Peak Res. (Withdrawn – Navigable)" as "Closed Entire Year" and state that pans, rockers, hand tools and hand-operated sluices are prohibited on withdrawn segments. The verdict is now "prohibited" for that reach, which includes Barber Park and the Greenbelt. Below the Star Highway Bridge the river is open year-round: non-powered work needs no permit within ¼ cubic yard an hour, ⅓ of the stream width and five people in one area; powered equipment needs IDWR's Small Scale Mining Authorization (Letter Permit), $10 resident / $30 non-resident, valid January 1–December 31; and a suction dredge (only) also needs DEQ IPDES suction dredge general permit coverage. Land there is mostly private. The riverbed is IDL-managed; the banks are mostly private, City of Boise or Ada County land. Violations are a misdemeanor (Idaho Code § 42-3811; IDWR states a $150–$500 fine, each day a separate offense), with notices of violation and injunctions under § 42-3809 and restoration under § 42-3810. The page notes that IDWR's web FAQ says the state doesn't regulate panning on public lands and refers readers to IDL. The anadromous-fish rationale, the IDFG closure, the claim-application penalty, unsourced finds and seasonal claims were removed, and the map pin moved to the river at Barber Park. The suction-dredging Guide now notes that Idaho bars even pans on withdrawn navigable riverbeds, and that DEQ's suction-dredge general permit excludes tribal reservations, critical habitat, wild and scenic rivers and withdrawn segments (which rules out dredging on the Clearwater near Orofino).
2 pages corrected

Carolina Beach: town digging limits, beach fires and Freeman Park

What was wrong
The Carolina Beach page said no town ordinance addressed digging, so filling holes was only etiquette, and recommended a long-handled sand scoop. It said bonfires and campfires were illegal within town limits with no exceptions, and that Freeman Park allowed fires November 1–March 31 north of mile marker 6. It gave the Freeman Park Parking Office address as 1708 Canal Drive and said daily passes were sold online. It cited a private tourism site as a Town of Carolina Beach source, described Freeman Park as within the town, called off-island dune rules island-wide, and gave unsourced boardwalk history (Captain John W. Harper, an 1891 bowling alley and grocery, 1920s rides). The map pin sat on a house.
What it says now
Town Code § 28-61 (Ord. No. 23-1213, 2023) applies to the whole beach strand, Freeman Park included: no hole deeper than 12 inches or wider than 5 feet, no shovels other than children's toy shovels, and every hole attended (within 20 feet) and filled before leaving and by 5:00 p.m.; a violation is a $50 civil penalty. No ordinance mentions metal detectors, so detecting stays allowed with no permit. Open fires on the town beach are prohibited unless by special permit from the Town Manager (§ 8-30(a)), enforceable by civil penalty or misdemeanor warrant (§ 8-23(c)); Freeman Park allows small contained campfires October 1–March 31 from Marker F north (§ 28-150(a)). Freeman Park is run by the town under an interlocal agreement with the county and lies mostly in the town's extraterritorial jurisdiction (§ 28-139(a)). Annual Freeman Park permits are sold in person in December and online from January 1 and picked up at the Parking Office, 1121 N. Lake Park Blvd.; daily passes are sold only at the park-entrance pay station ($50 April–September, $30 October–March). The page now cites the town code and the town's own web pages, dune rules are scoped to the town (§ 28-64) and Freeman Park (§ 28-151), the history is limited to the town's own timeline (1887 resort opening, 1925 incorporation), and the pin is on the beach east of the boardwalk.
1 page corrected

Clearwater River (Orofino): land status, suction-dredge exclusions, season and penalties

What was wrong
The Clearwater River page said BLM manages public land along a long stretch of the river near Orofino and that hand panning needs no permit anywhere on "open BLM river frontage" under "Idaho's casual-use policy". It said a suction dredge or power sluice on this stretch needs only an IDWR letter permit plus an IDEQ discharge permit, and that the South Fork Clearwater, "about 50 miles south", has an extra permitting layer because it is ESA critical habitat, unlike the mainstem near Orofino. It listed Idaho Fish and Game as a jurisdiction and gave unsourced penalties (an IDEQ citation and fine, and permit denial or revocation for repeat South Fork violations). It omitted IDWR's limits on non-mechanized work, the main Clearwater mining season, the 200-foot boat-ramp buffer and the closure of the Middle Fork Clearwater to all mining. It said Elias D. Pierce found gold at Canal Gulch in October 1860, that roughly 10,000 miners arrived within a year and that Idaho Territory was created "specifically to administer the rush", without sources.
What it says now
BLM's Cottonwood Field Office manages Pink House Recreation Site and a few small riverside parcels; most of the bank is private. The riverbed below the ordinary high-water mark is State of Idaho land (the Clearwater is on IDL's navigable-rivers list), open to casual exploration and small-scale mining under IDAPA 20.03.05.015.01, so hand panning works at Pink House and on that riverbed. "Casual use" is BLM's term (43 CFR 3809.5). IDWR says the federal and state governments don't regulate panning, but non-mechanized work needs an IDWR permit above ¼ cubic yard an hour, a third of the stream width or five people in one area. IDWR lists the main Clearwater open June 30–Sept. 15 in 2026 (unlisted tributaries closed all year), bars mining equipment within 200 feet of a maintained boat ramp (Pink House has one) and allows one mining site per 100 linear feet. DEQ's IPDES small suction dredge mining general permit excludes tribal reservations and endangered species habitat whatever IDWR's status; this stretch is inside the Nez Perce Reservation (Census TIGERweb) and is bull trout critical habitat (EPA Appendix G), so the page now says dredging isn't practically available here and to call DEQ at 208-373-0168. The South Fork joins at Kooskia, about 30 miles southeast; it needs IDWR's Special Supplement (2026 deadline March 1), a Plan of Operations to USFS or BLM and one of DEQ's first 15 complete notices of intent, with a July 15–Aug. 15 season from the mouth to the Red/American River confluence only. Mining in any form is prohibited on the Middle Fork Clearwater (Kooskia to Lowell), and Idaho Code 47-1323 also bans dredge mining on the Lochsa and Selway. Penalties are now Idaho Code 42-3811 (misdemeanor; IDWR states $150–$500 a day), 42-3809 and 42-1701B(6)(a) (notice of violation, injunction, civil penalty up to $10,000 per violation or $150 a day continuing, whichever is greater) and 42-3810 (restoration). IDFG was replaced by IDWR, NMFS and USFWS (ESA) and DEQ/EPA (discharge). The history now follows the National Park Service; the unsourced date, miner count and territory claim were removed.
1 page corrected

Congaree River: legal basis, scope, penalty and cleanup history

What was wrong
The Congaree River page presented S.C. Code § 54-7-670 alone as a statewide magnet-fishing ban applying to "every waterway in the state" and listed screens among the barred tools. It described the penalty as a $50 fine while implying the $10,000 / one-year tier might apply depending on enforcement. It dated the riverbed cleanup 2011–2023, said it recovered "thousands of Civil War-era artifacts" by "licensed contractors" coordinating with the Relic Room, and said Union troops rolled ordnance off the bank and that live ammunition "still capable of detonating" was found. It said H.4398 was stuck in committee "as of mid-2026", compared South Carolina with North Carolina and Georgia without sources (the North Carolina row contradicted the site's magnet-fishing guide), and listed boat launching at the bridge.
What it says now
The prohibition rests on SCIAA, which administers the Underwater Antiquities Act and states that magnet fishing is prohibited in South Carolina waterways and that it issues no hobby licenses for it; the Act requires a SCIAA license to recover or disturb submerged historic or fossil material on state-controlled submerged lands (§ 54-7-650(G)) and allows hobby recovery only of material that "can be obtained by hand" (§ 54-7-670(F)(2)). Scope is South Carolina's public waterways (navigable rivers, creeks, canals and coastal waters); privately owned land is exempt (§ 54-7-830). SCIAA lists tethered rakes, scoops and magnets, not screens. The penalty is a misdemeanor fine of not more than $50, each day a separate offense, with hobby-license revocation and seizure of artifacts (§§ 54-7-810(A), 54-7-800(D)); the $10,000 tier applies only to commercial salvage licensees. The coal-tar cleanup between the Gervais Street and Blossom Street bridges (pollution found in 2010, excavation June 2022 to fall 2023) recovered thousands of historical artifacts, including hundreds of Civil War relics and at least one unexploded shell destroyed by the military, by Dominion Energy's contractors and archaeologists. H.4398 has had no action since its April 2025 committee referral. The Georgia row was removed and the North Carolina row now matches G.S. 121-22 and 121-25.
1 page corrected

Judith River: what the monument plan bans, private and state inholdings, penalties and access corrected

What was wrong
The Judith River page said the monument plan bans "plant material" in the sense of plant fossils and that the ban covers everything within a 377,346-acre boundary, without mentioning the private and state land inside it. It said the BLM Director added the ban in response to 45 protest letters filed "during the public comment period", that the ban came "two years" after the proclamation, and that the proclamation closes the area to mineral entry and off-road use. It said PRPA requires prompt reporting of vertebrate finds. The penalty for collecting invertebrates was given as a citation and confiscation under 43 CFR 8365.1-5(b), the PRPA penalty didn't say criminal penalties need a knowing violation, and the off-road penalty included vehicle impoundment. It said Leonardo was found about 100 miles northwest, on BLM Malta Field Office land outside the monument, and that Edward Drinker Cope worked the lower Judith in 1876. It listed the site in Fergus County, put the pin off the campground, described a BLM contact station, shuttle parking and a self-registration box at Judith Landing, put Lewistown about 60 miles away, and gave a formation age it didn't source.
What it says now
The 2008 Record of Decision bans personal collection of common invertebrate fossils and petrified wood, and of plant material (vegetation, seeds and berries), with an exception for plant material only under the American Indian Religious Freedom Act; plant fossils aren't named separately, so the page says to treat them as closed and ask the Lewistown Field Office. The ban applies to the monument's roughly 375,000 acres of BLM land (Federal Register, January 9, 2009); the ROD says about 80,000 acres of private land and 39,000 acres of state land inside the boundary aren't part of the monument. Private land needs the surface owner's permission (Mont. Code Ann. § 1-4-112), and state trust land is closed to fossil collecting (ARM 36.25.145(11)(a)). BLM received 46 protest letters during the 30-day protest period; the protest review found that allowing collection did not follow the 2001 proclamation, which doesn't name fossils but withdraws the federal land from entry and disposition, so the ban was added in the December 2008 ROD, seven years later. Reporting a find isn't legally required. Collecting invertebrates here is a PRPA prohibited act (43 CFR 49.805(a), 49.810(d)): a knowing violation carries fines and up to 5 years (2 years at $500 or less), doubled for a repeat; any violation can bring civil penalties (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-6) and forfeiture (§ 470aaa-7). Off-road vehicle use carries up to $1,000 and/or 12 months (43 CFR 8340.0-7). Leonardo came from near Malta, about 90 miles east-northeast, where land is a mix of private, BLM and state; the Cope claim and the formation age were removed. The page now notes metal detectors are allowed by permit only and research permits require relevant training or experience (43 CFR 49.110). County is Chouteau; the pin is BLM's Judith Landing campground location (47.74135, -109.62665); access details now follow BLM's Judith Landing page (May 15–October 15, eight sites, $20/night, 14-day limit, no water); Lewistown is about 48 miles straight-line.
1 page corrected

Mendocino National Forest: mushroom permits, wilderness areas, citations and fire history

What was wrong
The Mendocino National Forest foraging page said personal use above 1 gallon a month could be covered by a paid permit ($20 for up to 8 gallons over 4 days, $50 for up to 20 gallons over 30 days) and applied the 1-gallon limit to most special forest products, not just mushrooms. It named only two wilderness areas closed to collecting, described the ban as a closure order and as unusual among national forests, and said Mendocino was the only California forest covered with a numeric limit, comparing it with an outdated Six Rivers rule. It cited 36 CFR § 261.6(f) for selling mushrooms and said material and equipment would be confiscated. It cited the Sudden Oak Death quarantine as "7 CCR" with civil penalties and seizure, and listed soil and duff as restricted material. It said nearly 90% of the forest had burned since 2020, called the August Complex the majority of the forest's footprint across six counties, said 2026 fire restrictions ran July 28 to December 1, and named road closures on M21 and M4. Its map pin was not on National Forest land.
What it says now
The forest's permits page allows incidental personal-use mushroom collecting up to 1 gallon per person per month with no permit; no permit is sold for more, and commercial mushroom permits are not available at this time. The 1-gallon rule covers mushrooms only: for other forest products the forest issues permits, sometimes for a minimal fee, through its district offices, and all commercial removal requires a permit. Mushroom collecting is not allowed in wilderness areas (forest policy stated on the permits page); the forest manages all or part of four: Snow Mountain, Yolla Bolly-Middle Eel, Yuki and Sanhedrin. Unauthorized removal, including collecting to sell, is prohibited under 36 CFR § 261.6(h), punishable under 36 CFR § 261.1b by up to six months and/or a fine under 18 U.S.C. § 3571 (up to $5,000 for an individual). The Sudden Oak Death rules are 3 CCR § 3700 and 7 CFR 301.92; the state regulated area includes Lake and Mendocino counties, regulated articles are host plant parts and unprocessed host wood or bark, and mushrooms are not regulated articles. Nearly 90% of the forest burned in the 2018 Ranch Fire and 2020 August Complex. The 2026 fire restrictions lifted on September 30. Road closures now name only those on the forest's alerts page (M10 weekday construction closure, M6 Eel River crossing traffic control, 16N21). The pin was moved onto National Forest land and district contacts were added.
1 page corrected

Ocean Beach (San Diego): current park-code rules and penalties, no Dog Beach nesting closure, pier timeline and 75-foot rule

What was wrong
The Ocean Beach page relied on a superseded 2006 version of SDMC Chapter 6, Article 3, saying the code bars digging caves or depressions "in cliff areas adjacent to the ocean shoreline" and bans "unauthorized holes". It gave the penalty as a municipal code infraction and listed an "SDMC park closure authority" trespass citation for entering the pier that no section supports. It said a California Department of Fish and Wildlife buffer closure shut nesting areas at the San Diego River mouth near Dog Beach from April 15 to September 15, and placed Dog Beach at the south end of Ocean Beach. It said pier demolition could start in 2027, called the 75-foot pier rule moot while the pier is closed, and described Sunset Cliffs Natural Park as a separate jurisdiction. It said some inland San Diego regional parks use a detecting permit system.
What it says now
The current SDMC § 63.0102(b) counts all public beaches as parks. § 63.0102(c)(4) bars removing natural vegetation, soil, or rock in any park without the City Manager's written permission, and (c)(5) bars digging caves or otherwise reconfiguring the landscape in a manner that damages it without written permission; no section names small refilled detecting holes, so refilling is now given as advice. Under SDMC § 12.0201 violations are misdemeanors (up to $1,000 and/or 6 months), which the City Attorney may charge as infractions ($250; $500 for a second conviction within a year). The Dog Beach seasonal closure and CDFW were removed: the river mouth beside Dog Beach, at the north end of the beach, is fenced City-managed sensitive habitat (MHPA) where snowy plovers overwinter and least terns forage, so the page says to stay outside the post-and-rope fencing year-round. The pier opened in 1966 and has been closed since October 2023; the City's timeline puts replacement construction starting around 2030 and lasting 48–56 months, subject to funding and permits. SDMC § 63.20.16(b)(4) (no swimming, wading, surfing or skin diving within 75 feet of the pier) applies now, and the City has posted signs. Sunset Cliffs Natural Park is a City park under the same code. The County permit claim was replaced with County Code § 41.113 (digging in a County park needs written authorization). Civil Code § 2080.1(a) (finds worth $100 or more go to the city police) was added. Unsourced history, find-concentration and parking claims were removed. The California metal-detecting overview row no longer mentions seasonal closures at the river mouth.
2 pages corrected

Saddle Butte: rock collecting allowed in the WSA; current WSA policy, ACEC extent and penalties

What was wrong
The Saddle Butte page gave the verdict as "unclear", saying no ACEC rule on rock collecting had been published. It said the WSA was governed by BLM's Interim Management Policy, allowed "non-motorized access only", and that the Saddle Butte ACEC overlays the 81,380-acre WSA. It cited "43 CFR Subpart 3610" with a retroactive permit or plan of operations as the penalty for over-collecting, the ACEC designation itself as the rule against disturbing the caves, and "stricter future management" as the penalty for off-route driving. It compared the caves with Forest Service caves that use white-nose syndrome permits, and listed Harney Basin oolitic agate as a nearby verified site, without sources.
What it says now
Collecting reasonable noncommercial amounts of rocks and mineral specimens is allowed on BLM land (43 CFR 8365.1-5(b)), and BLM Manual 6330 (2012), which replaced the Interim Management Policy, allows hobby rock collecting for personal use in WSAs where the method meets the non-impairment criteria. The verdict is now "allowed": hand tools only (8365.1-5(a)(3)), no digging that needs reclamation, nothing from the caves (8365.1-5(a)(2)), and motor vehicles only on primitive routes open to the public (Manual 6330). The 2002 Southeastern Oregon RMP Record of Decision sets the Saddle Butte ACEC at 7,056 acres, about 87% inside the WSA, protecting sensitive wildlife and habitat (a State-sensitive big-eared bat population), rare geologic features and the lava tube cave system; it requires a permit for plant collecting, limits OHV use to designated roads and has no rock-collecting ban. Violations of 8365.1-5 carry up to $1,000 and/or 12 months (43 CFR 8360.0-7); off-road vehicle violations of 43 CFR 8341.1 carry the same (43 CFR 8340.0-7). DOGAMI's 1969 study found none of the caves safe to enter. The unsourced cave-permit comparison and Harney Basin row were removed. The Oregon rockhounding overview row now shows the allowed verdict and its conditions.
2 pages corrected

Arkansas River: Cache Creek permit was only proposed; equipment, penalties and history corrected

What was wrong
The Arkansas River page said the Cache Creek Placer Area near Granite has required a BLM "mineral-collection permit" under a supplemental rule adopted in 2016, cited that rule for a citation-and-seizure penalty, and said small recirculating systems and dry washers were allowed in the designated digging area. It said the rule was adopted to stop sub-ground burrows and root-cutting, and described the leash rule as in force. It gave the Point Bar Placer Area's 4-inch/8 hp dredge cap as a current site rule without noting it came from a 2017 notification, said stream beds count as land under C.R.S. 34-32-103(12), and said EPA Region 8 has issued a general permit for portable suction dredges and that a CDPHE discharge permit may apply. It cited "DRMS Mineral Rules" for state fines and a stop-work order, and an unnamed "site rule" for the motorized season. It described an "EPA-run" treatment plant near Leadville removing about 200 tons of metal a year since 1992, said Cache Creek was worked in the late 1860s, "decades before" Leadville, and drew more visitors than any other stretch, and said small nuggets were historically documented there.
What it says now
BLM's 2016 Cache Creek Placer Area Management Plan calls for a Special Recreation Permit for placer activity on the 2,160-acre parcel, and BLM's October 2016 notice of proposed supplementary rules (81 FR 71035) would charge $5/day or $25/year for ages 16 and over; no final rule was found in the Federal Register and BLM's current Cache Creek map doesn't mention a permit, so the page now says to call the Royal Gorge Field Office (719-269-8500). The parcel is acquired land not open to the General Mining Law, so collecting falls under 43 CFR 8365.1-5, which bars motorized or mechanical devices other than metal detectors unless authorized: pans and non-mechanical hand sluices only. BLM's reasons are now those in the Federal Register notice (sediment impacting a recovering fishery, user conflicts, unstable holes and large trees, dogs), digging is limited to the designated area on BLM's 2022 map, and the leash rule is labeled as proposed. Penalties now cite 43 CFR 8365.1-5/8360.0-7 (up to $1,000 and/or 12 months), the 2000 motorized closure order under 43 CFR 8364.1 (65 FR 15647; up to $100,000 and/or one year under 18 U.S.C. 3571), and C.R.S. 34-32-103(12) and 34-32-113 for prospecting notices. The Point Bar caps are attributed to BLM's 2017 notification (expired September 30, 2018) at CPW's Point Barr site in Fremont County, with its 3-inch/8 hp highbanker limit and October 1–March 31 brown trout closure; the stream-bed, EPA general-permit and CDPHE discharge-permit claims were removed (the page says to ask CDPHE). The Leadville section now names the two treatment plants: the Yak Tunnel plant (since 1992, operated by Newmont under an EPA/State consent decree) and the Bureau of Reclamation's Leadville Mine Drainage Tunnel plant. History now says placer mining began about 1860, 1863–1865 were the most productive years, and hydraulic mining ran until 1911, when Cañon City and Pueblo sued. The page adds CPW's rule allowing recreational gold mining in the AHRA except where posted, private land along the river, CPW passes at fee sites, and the year-round AHRA versus Cache Creek's seasonal vehicle gate.
2 pages corrected

Dockweiler State Beach: smoking statute, snowy plover enclosure, ESA penalties and County beach rules corrected

What was wrong
The page cited the state beach smoking ban as Public Resources Code § 5008.20, said it covered the entire beach and the RV park, and claimed court fees bring the $25 fine to $100–$200. It placed the western snowy plover enclosure 'near Lifeguard Tower 47', called it a nesting enclosure 'closed year-round under the Endangered Species Act', and gave ESA penalties of up to $25,000 civil and $50,000 criminal, which apply to endangered species, not the threatened plover. It said § 5097.99 makes removing a Native American artifact from a grave a felony regardless of intent. It described Dockweiler as one of the few LA County beaches allowing fires, with 'metal' fire rings; said amplified music was banned only between midnight and 6 a.m.; listed 'vehicle removal' as a penalty; gave the address as 12000 Vista del Mar and the RV park as 117 hookup sites; and described LAX 'approaches' over the beach.
What it says now
The smoking ban is PRC § 5008.10 (SB 8, 2019): an infraction with a fine of up to $25 (§ 5008.10(d)); it covers the sand, exempts paved roads and parking areas (§ 5008.10(b)), and is enforced only after signs are posted (§ 5008.10(g)). LA County Beaches and Harbors installed the fenced plover enclosure in 2010 (about 100 by 300 feet, open toward the ocean) to protect a federally threatened shorebird that roosts here; the page now says to stay outside the fencing and posted nesting areas and drops the Tower 47 location. For a threatened species, 16 U.S.C. § 1540 sets a civil penalty of up to $12,000 (inflation-adjusted) for a knowing violation, or $500 otherwise, and a criminal penalty of up to $25,000 and/or 6 months for a knowing violation. Under § 5097.99, removing items from a grave or cairn is a felony with intent to sell or dissect or with malice or wantonness ((c)), as is knowingly obtaining or possessing them ((b)). Fires are allowed only in Dockweiler's roughly 40 Beaches and Harbors fire pits, with grills that fit inside the 2-foot pit (County Code § 17.12.370(A)); amplified music is banned at all times, and loitering between midnight and 6 a.m. (§ 17.12.350); driving on the beach is barred by § 17.12.230 and is an infraction under § 17.12.150(A). The address is 12001 Vista del Mar, the RV park has more than 100 full hook-up spaces and dry camper sites, and State Parks places the beach beneath the LAX takeoff path. The page adds the dog and cat ban (§ 17.12.290), the winter sand berms and § 17.12.205's bar on digging into vertical sand embankments, and a note on the fenced California least tern nesting area in the Venice part of the unit. The verdict stays unclear. Unsourced lines (Douglas Aircraft finds, find-concentration and crowding claims, restroom hours) were removed, and the map pin moved to the main entrance.
1 page corrected

Hells Canyon (Pittsburg Landing): HCNRA rules replace a wrong Wilderness Act ban; fossils prohibited

What was wrong
The Hells Canyon page based its answer on the Wilderness Act and 36 CFR Part 293, saying they prohibit collecting any natural object, rocks included, in the Hells Canyon Wilderness, and cited them as the penalty basis. It said no rule was confirmed for the rest of the NRA and that general national forest personal-use norms "likely apply", with hand tools only; it limited the NRA-wide fossil ban to vertebrate fossils and listed agate, jasper and petrified wood as reported finds. It said the Nez Perce-Clearwater National Forests co-manage about 117,000 acres on the Idaho side, gave the access road as 16.5 miles, placed the landing near the mouth of Kurry Creek, and called the canyon deeper than the Grand Canyon at over 7,900 feet. The map pin was about 1.8 km south-east of the launch.
What it says now
Part 293 only bars permits for common-variety mineral materials in Wilderness (§ 293.14(c)); the NRA has its own rules, 36 CFR Part 292 Subpart F. Under § 292.43(a)(4) all paleontological resources, which § 292.41 defines to include plant and invertebrate fossils and so petrified wood, may be removed only for scientific research with prior written authorization. Pittsburg Landing is in the Wild and Scenic Snake River corridor (16 U.S.C. 1274(a)(12): wild from Hells Canyon Dam to Pittsburg Landing, scenic below), where § 292.47(b)(2) prohibits extraction of mineral materials; the Forest Service's rockhounding guide (FS-1091) classes agates, jaspers and common rocks as mineral materials, and on the NRA's other lands § 292.47(a)(3)–(4) limits them to HCNRA facility construction. No route to a free-use permit for hobby collecting was found, so the verdict stays unclear pending the Riggins office, (208) 628-3916. Mining, including pans and sluices, is prohibited except under valid rights existing on December 31, 1975 (§§ 292.41, 292.47; 16 U.S.C. 460gg-8). Violations are enforced under 36 CFR 261 (§ 292.42(c); § 261.9(b)) with up to 6 months and a fine up to $5,000 ($10,000 for an organization) (§ 261.1b; 18 U.S.C. 3571). The page now says the NRA includes Wallowa-Whitman, Nez Perce and Payette lands and is administered by the Wallowa-Whitman National Forest, gives Deer Creek Road (FR 493) as 17.5 miles, uses the Forest Service's "deepest river gorge in North America", and drops the 117,000-acre, Kurry Creek and Grand Canyon claims. The map pin moved to the Forest Service's launch coordinates.
1 page corrected

Island Beach State Park: digging permission, lost articles, fees, natural areas, penalties, hours and contacts

What was wrong
The Island Beach page and the New Jersey overview said the detecting permit is free; no source says so. The Island Beach page did not mention that digging in a state park needs separate written permission, or that found articles must be turned over to the park. It gave the natural areas as 659 and 1,237 acres (1,896 of 3,003, "63%") and stated as fact that no permit is issued there and that permits are confined to the developed day-use section; none of those figures or statements is in a DEP source. It said the Sedge Islands Marine Conservation Zone is closed to detecting, that holes must be filled as a standard permit condition, that there is no detector size limit, that detecting without the permit in hand counts as detecting without one, and that piping plover closures at Gillikins and south of A23 make permits unlikely in spring and summer, all without a source. It added "the Superintendent can refuse future permits" as a penalty and cited unspecified "coastal dune protection rules" with a "citation; removal" penalty for the dunes. The off-season fee omitted motorcycles and oversized vehicles, the address was a PO box, and winter gate hours were said to be reduced. The history said Phipps wanted to build "the next Atlantic City", that the state bought the land "rather than let development resume", and that the park had 1848 and 1898 life-saving stations, and cited islandbeachnj.org as the official park history. It said the 1890 McKenzie wreck was left in place under the park's archaeological rules. The comparison table described Seaside Park and Seaside Heights as having no restrictions and skipped Berkeley Township's South Seaside Park section.
What it says now
A permit from the Superintendent or designee is still required (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.16); the page now says to ask the park office (732-793-0506, IslandBeach@dep.nj.gov) what it costs. Digging up soil, rock, historic or fossil materials or artifacts needs the written permission of the Director of the Division of Parks and Forestry or the Assistant Director for the State Park Service (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.10(c)), and the page says to ask whether the detector permit covers digging. All found articles must be turned over to the Superintendent or designee, with a receipt, and are returned to the finder after 90 days if unclaimed (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.23); N.J.S.A. 46:30C and 2C:20-6 also apply. This rule was also added to the Cape May page (for Cape May Point State Park) and the New Jersey overview. The Northern and Southern Natural Areas cover about 1,900 acres of a park of over 3,000 acres; public access to the Northern Natural Area is limited to the ocean beach for fishing and walking, and picnicking, sunbathing and fishing are allowed on the Southern Natural Area's ocean beaches. That a permit would likely be refused there is now given as our reading of 7:2-2.16's refusal clause, not a park statement. The Sedge Islands Marine Conservation Zone (about 1,600 acres) is limited to recreational boats, with jet skis and commercial activities prohibited. Nesting closures now read: posted closures change each year and you may not enter them (N.J.A.C. 7:2-5.1(c), 7:2-2.13(b)); pets are not permitted on the Northern Natural Area beach from April 1 to September 15. The dune rule is N.J.A.C. 7:2-5.1(a). Penalties: $50 to $1,500 per offense plus restitution, each day of a continuing violation a separate offense, and three times the gain or damage where a violation brings pecuniary gain or willful damage (N.J.S.A. 13:1L-23(d)); the page notes the de minimis exception in N.J.S.A. 13:1L-10(c). Parking fees (N.J.A.C. 7:2-17.1): Memorial Day weekend to Labor Day, $6/$12 weekdays and $10/$20 weekends and holidays for NJ residents/non-residents; otherwise $5/$10 per automobile; motorcycles $5/$7; oversized vehicles double. The State Park Pass is $50/$75, and walk-ins and drop-offs are not permitted while the park is at capacity. The park is closed 8 p.m.–8 a.m. from April 1 to October 31 and 8 p.m.–5 a.m. from November 1 to March 31, except for MSFV permit holders, surf fishermen and Barnegat Bay waterfowl hunters (N.J.A.C. 7:2-16.5(a)). The address is 2401 Central Ave., Seaside Park, NJ 08752. History now follows DEP: Phipps bought the land in 1926, three homes were built before the 1929 crash ended construction, the state bought the 2,694-acre estate in 1953 and the park opened in 1959; the former Coast Guard Station #110 is the remaining one of three lifesaving stations on this stretch. The McKenzie wreck (lost March 21, 1890) resurfaced in January 2026. North of the gate come Berkeley Township's South Seaside Park section, the Borough of Seaside Park and Seaside Heights, each with its own code.
3 pages corrected

Kure Beach: town hole-size rule, detector ban at Fort Fisher State Historic Site, Condor location

What was wrong
The Kure Beach page said no town ordinance addressed digging, treating hole-filling as etiquette only, and gave the penalty for beach-rule violations as an unspecified citation. It said Fort Fisher State Recreation Area began immediately south of town and left out Fort Fisher State Historic Site, which lies between them and bans metal detectors. It banned fires and fireworks "within town limits". It placed the blockade runner Condor about 700 yards off Kure Beach in about 25 feet of water, called it North Carolina's first Heritage Dive Site, and said it could be reached only by divers with authorization. It described the WWII range's weapons as 40mm Bofors guns and quad .50-caliber machine guns and dated training from 1941. It said Army-surplus buildings from the range were moved into town, that the summer population swells past 10,000, and gave Carolina Beach as 5 miles and Wrightsville Beach as 12 miles away.
What it says now
Kure Beach Code 13.14.020.S limits holes on the beach to 5 feet wide and 16 inches deep, requires them to be attended by a responsible adult until filled, and requires the sand restored before leaving and no later than 30 minutes before sunset; a violation is a $100 civil penalty (FY 26-27 Town Fee Schedule). The town's limits run to the entrance of Fort Fisher State Historic Site, where 07 NCAC 04N .0102(b)(3) bars using or carrying a metal detector "under any circumstances" and .0102(a)(2) requires a written permit to dig; Fort Fisher SRA lies further south (lost-item Special Use Permit only, 07 NCAC 13B .0203). Whether the historic site's property reaches the ocean beach is unconfirmed, and the page gives the site's number. Fires are prohibited on the beach (KBC 13.14.020.N) and the town brochure prohibits fireworks on the beach. Ocean Front Park bars digging without the Recreation Director's written authorization (KBC 13.15.150). The page adds the fee-schedule penalties for glass/alcohol/litter, fires, dunes and dogs, the 15-foot nest buffer (KBC 13.14.020.P.3) and turtle penalties. The Condor lies about 700 yards off the beach in front of the NC Aquarium at Fort Fisher under 24 feet of water, was designated an NC Heritage Dive Site in 2018 and is open to recreational divers; removing or disturbing wreck material needs a permit, the state holds title to wrecks unclaimed more than 10 years (G.S. 121-22, 121-25) and a violation is a Class 1 misdemeanor (G.S. 121-28). NC Historic Sites describes batteries of 40-millimeter automatic cannons and 50-caliber machine guns, with training from October 1941 to 1944. The surplus-buildings and population claims are removed; distances are now 2.7 and 16.2 miles.
1 page corrected

Lake Texoma: found-item rule, Eisenhower State Park, Oklahoma state park and Hagerman refuge corrected

What was wrong
The page applied the Corps' under-$25 exception for non-identifiable items to finds generally and never said that 36 CFR 327.16 requires all found articles to be turned in. It said Eisenhower State Park issues a detector or recovery-tool permit only to search for a specific lost personal item, 'the same rule' as at Galveston Island State Park, and called it a separate jurisdiction from the Corps. It said Corps rules apply equally on the Oklahoma side, without noting that Oklahoma State Parks bans magnet fishing, and it left out Hagerman National Wildlife Refuge. It said federal ownership moves the question 'entirely out of Texas state law' and that the lake has 580 miles of shoreline under 'a single federal management structure'. It dated the dam's construction 1938 to 1944, said prisoners of war cleared more than 7,000 acres, described construction-era tools found near the dam, and said there was no documented pre-dam history. It gave the featured access point as Island View Park, 'the most-used swim beach', with hours and a TX-289 route.
What it says now
36 CFR 327.16: all found articles must be deposited at the Manager's office or with a ranger. The exception for 'non-identifiable items such as coins of value less than $25' is in the metal-detector paragraph (§ 327.14(d)), and no rule extends it to magnet fishing. Detectors are allowed on designated beaches or other previously disturbed areas listed by the Project Office, unless the District Commander prohibits them to protect archaeological, historical or paleontological resources (§ 327.14(d)). Eisenhower State Park is Corps land leased to TPWD in 1954 (opened 1958), so TPWD rules apply on top of 36 CFR 327 (§ 327.1(e)): 31 TAC § 59.134(i) makes operating a metal detector an offense except as authorized by permit, and § 59.134(l)(2)–(3) bars disturbing geological deposits or historic artifacts without a permit or written order. The rule doesn't name magnets, so the page says to ask the park; the lost-item permit and the Galveston comparison were removed. The penalty is a Class C Parks and Wildlife Code misdemeanor, $25–$500 (§§ 13.112, 12.406). Oklahoma State Parks prohibits magnet fishing and metal detecting at all state parks, including Lake Texoma State Park. Hagerman National Wildlife Refuge, a 1946 overlay on Corps land on the Big Mineral Arm, prohibits metal detectors and collecting artifacts, and 50 CFR 27.61 and 27.63(a) ban removing public property including natural objects and searching for treasure or valuable rocks without a permit. State and local laws still apply on Corps land (36 CFR 327.0, 327.26); the Texas Antiquities Code doesn't cover federally owned land. The Tulsa District has banned magnetic fishing by memo at Pat Mayse Lake (Commander's Policy Memorandum No. 7, 2023); none was found for Texoma, so the verdict stays 'unclear'. Denison Dam was built from August 1939 to February 1944; the shoreline figure, the 7,000-acre figure, the construction-tools claim and the 'no pre-dam history' claim were removed. Island View Park is closed to public access; the access list now leads with the Corps' Dam Site Park.
1 page corrected

South Platte (Eleven Mile Canyon): verdict now unclear — canyon withdrawn from mining-law entry; citation, fees, closure and penalties corrected

What was wrong
The Eleven Mile Canyon page said hand-panning was allowed with no permit under "36 CFR 228.4a(1)(iv)", without mentioning that the canyon is withdrawn from mining-law entry. That citation is wrong: 228.4(a)(1)(iv) covers underground operations; the panning text is in (a)(1)(ii). The Applegate River page carried the same wrong citation. The page gave the fee as $11/day or $80/year, "cash or card accepted"; said Eleven Mile Reservoir is at the canyon's downstream end; called the river Gold Medal water; said flows follow spring snowmelt; listed penalties ("citation; possible removal"; equipment confiscation) with no source; put the map pin at an unsourced "entrance station" point; described Fairplay's panning as a "Prospecting Park" with $10/day or $100/year fees; and omitted the seasonal closure near the canyon entrance.
What it says now
The verdict is now unclear. BLM land records show a 1962 Forest Service withdrawal named "Eleven Mile" closing the canyon corridor, including its campgrounds and the dam area, to locatable minerals. The Pike-San Isabel prospecting guidelines (no permit for gold panning, hand sluicing or metal detecting; District Ranger approval and a reclamation plan for mechanized equipment) are written for land open to the mining laws and don't address withdrawn areas, and 36 CFR 261.9(b) prohibits removing any natural feature or property of the United States; the page tells readers to call the South Park Ranger District (719-836-2031) first. The citation is now 36 CFR 228.4(a)(1)(ii) on both pages. The fee is $11 per vehicle per day ($25 bus/van with 10+ passengers) or $100 for an annual pass for this site, paid at a seasonally staffed entrance station or a self-service station. The reservoir is at the canyon's upstream end; CPW manages the river from the dam to the Wagon Tongue Gulch Road bridge at Springer Gulch as Quality Waters (catch-and-release, artificial flies and lures only); flows depend on dam releases. The page adds Forest Order 2-12-10-26-03 (January 1–July 31 each year, no entry to the area north of the river near the canyon entrance ending at Riverside Campground, through April 12, 2031; Class B misdemeanor), the PSICC limits on metal detecting in historic archaeological sites and the special use permit for treasure hunting, and penalties under 36 CFR 261.9(a)/(b), 261.10(a) and 261.1b (up to 6 months and/or a fine under 18 U.S.C. 3571) and 16 U.S.C. 6811(d) for fee nonpayment ($100 maximum fine for a first offense). Fairplay is described only as selling its own town panning permit. Directions follow the Forest Service (County Road 96 south from Lake George), and the pin moved to Springer Gulch Campground on the river.
2 pages corrected

Two Medicine Formation: dig participants keep nothing; BLM office is Lewistown, not Havre; Egg Mountain details corrected

What was wrong
The page said what participants in the Montana Dinosaur Center's paid digs may keep 'was not confirmed', and the Montana fossil overview told readers to ask before booking. It presented the paid dig as a required permit, priced it at $110 (half-day) and $225 (8-hour day-dig) with a 50% Montana-resident discount, and gave the season as June–September. It named the BLM Havre Field Office as the federal manager, said no BLM parcel had been identified, and cited an expired BLM instruction memorandum (IM 2012-140, expired September 30, 2013). It said Egg Mountain was 553 acres, bought by The Nature Conservancy in 1985 and sold to the Museum of the Rockies in 2004, and closed 'at any price, guided or otherwise'. It gave PRPA and trespass penalties only in general terms ('federal citation', 'criminal trespass citation'), and did not mention state trust land or the Blackfeet Reservation.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed', scoped to taking part in the Montana Dinosaur Center's paid research digs on private ranch land, under agreements with the landowners. Participants keep nothing: the Center says 'we do not allow anyone to take fossils home from our dig sites, even if you are the one that found it.' The dig is described as a paid program, not a permit (permit_required false). Half-day site tours start at $125; the season is June 1–August 31 and the dig sites close August 31; educational non-profit groups get 35% off and state-recognized schools 50%. The federal manager is the BLM Lewistown Field Office (North Central District), 920 Northeast Main, Lewistown, 406-538-1900. BLM's surface-management map shows one small BLM block about 5½ miles west-southwest of Bynum, surrounded by private and state land, with public access unconfirmed; there, common invertebrate and plant fossils may be casually collected unless the area is closed, up to 25 lb per person per day (43 CFR 49.805(a), 49.810), and vertebrates need a research permit. Egg Mountain is a Museum of the Rockies (Montana State University) research site bought from The Nature Conservancy, with no general public access; MOR has run occasional members-only guided trips (2023: one adults-only trip, $200). The 'Egg Mountain' highway sign stands on private land, not the site. Penalties now read: PRPA up to 5 years (2 if $500 or less) plus fines, civil penalties and forfeiture (16 U.S.C. §§ 470aaa-5, -6); criminal trespass up to $500 and/or 6 months (Mont. Code Ann. § 45-6-203). The page adds that state trust sections are closed to fossil collecting (ARM 36.25.145(11)(a)) and that PRPA does not cover the Blackfeet Reservation north of Birch Creek (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa(2)), where collecting needs tribal permission. The expired memorandum was replaced with the eCFR regulations and the statute. The overview's Two Medicine row and its sentence on what paid-dig participants keep were updated to match.
2 pages corrected

Applegate River: lake land withdrawn from mining, river below the dam largely private; verdict now unclear

What was wrong
The page said hand panning around Applegate Lake was "allowed", free and unpermitted on National Forest land under 36 CFR 228.4(a)(1)(ii). It said a notice of intent was required for any suction dredge, high-banker or motorized equipment, that digging had to stay below the ordinary high-water mark, and that "seasonal spawning closures" applied. It gave no Oregon rules: nothing on the ban on motorized dredges in essential salmon habitat, the DEQ 700-PM and DSL authorizations, or the removal-fill limits on hand prospecting. It said Corps of Engineers day-use fees applied at the lake's developed sites. It placed Joe Creek near the border as an Applegate tributary, said it was "fishless for miles", gave a $15 million reclamation, 150,000 tons of waste rock and a 36 CFR 261.53 closure-order penalty. It gave the ranger station's phone as 541-899-1812, said scattered claims were only on tributaries, dated a mining district to 1852, and gave the BLM sites' distance as 18 miles.
What it says now
Verdict changed to "unclear". Applegate Lake, the dam and the Corps land below it are covered by Corps of Engineers withdrawal OROR106109664 ("Applegate Reservoir"), which withdraws them from location of locatable minerals, so 36 CFR 228's no-notice rule for panning doesn't apply there, and 36 CFR 261.9(b) bars removing natural features of the United States on National Forest land. The Forest Service says that from the dam downstream to the Forest boundary much of the river passes through private land, and BLM's MLRS shows active placer claims on the mainstem below the dam. Above the lake the river is in California. The page now says to call the Siskiyou Mountains Ranger District, (541) 899-3800, before panning. A notice of intent is needed only for operations that might cause significant surface disturbance (36 CFR 228.4(a)), not by equipment type. Below the dam the river is essential salmon habitat (DSL's map ends it at Applegate Dam): motorized dredges are banned (ORS 468B.114; Class A violation, up to $2,000), a gravity or siphon dredge of 4 inches or less needs DEQ 700-PM registration and a DSL general authorization, within ODFW's July 1 – September 15 in-water work period, and hand prospecting is limited to under 1 cubic yard per site and 5 a year, in the bed or wet perimeter, never where fish eggs are present (ORS 196.810). The Rogue River-Siskiyou National Forest charges no day-use fees. Joe Creek is in California, about 3 miles south of the border, and drains the Blue Ledge Mine Superfund site into Elliott Creek; EPA has posted signs not to drink from or wade in it near the mine. The unsourced figures, penalty and 1852 district date were removed, and the distance to the Rogue page's pin is now 44.5 miles. The Rogue River page no longer calls the land around Applegate Lake Forest Service land.
2 pages corrected

Calvert Cliffs State Park: metal detector ban, penalties, closed shoreline, fees and access

What was wrong
The page didn't say that metal detectors and artifact collecting are barred without Maryland Historical Trust and DNR permits. Its penalties were vague or invented: a citation with fines 'set by the District Court fine schedule', 'ejection from the park', forfeiture of collected material, and adjoining owners who 'post and prosecute'. It cited no closure authority. It said the tall cliff sections are 'not park land' and that walking past the park beach puts you on private land, without saying that the shoreline beneath the park's own cliffs is closed. It allowed fallen blocks without limiting them to the open beach. It said there was no lifeguard (not in DNR's material), put Washington, D.C. about 65 miles away, said nothing about disabled access, and listed Flag Ponds' April–October non-resident fee as $15. It presented COMAR 08.07.06.13(C) as the mechanism behind the beach allowance and listed a scientific or commercial collecting permit as required for the site. Its geology box said the Calvert Formation is the source of most Ecphora and the Choptank holds Chesapecten beds, neither of which the cited sources say. The map pin sat out near the trails rather than at the park entrance.
What it says now
Artifacts can't be taken, and metal detectors can't be used, without Maryland Historical Trust and DNR permits (COMAR 08.07.06.18(B)); the exception for detecting on designated swimming beaches excludes Point Lookout and Calvert Cliffs by name (08.07.06.18(D)(1)). Violating the park regulations is a misdemeanor: a fine up to $500, and for a second violation within two years up to $1,000 and/or one year (Md. Code, Nat. Res. § 5-1301(a)–(c)). The area beneath the cliffs is closed under COMAR 08.07.06.06(B) ('The Superintendent may, by notice, close areas of State parks to public entry and travel'); DNR says it is illegal to collect fossils beneath the cliffs, and the Maryland Geological Survey records that DNR closed the beach along the cliffs in the 1980s. Beyond the open quarter-mile beach, the shoreline beneath the park's cliffs is closed, and further along almost all of the Calvert County shoreline is privately owned (MGS). Fallen blocks may be taken only on the open beach. Trespass on posted land is a misdemeanor: first offense up to 90 days or $500 or both (Md. Code, Crim. Law § 6-402). Day use is $5 per vehicle for Maryland residents and $7 for out-of-state, cash only, sunrise to sunset, daily, year-round. There is no public vehicle access; disabled beach access can be arranged by calling 443-975-4360 or 443-510-9920 at least two weeks ahead. Wading and swimming are allowed unless posted (COMAR 08.07.06.07), and dogs must be leashed at the beach. The park is about 50 miles (straight line) southeast of Washington, D.C. Flag Ponds is $5 per vehicle November–March and, April–October, $5 for Calvert County residents and $20 for non-residents. The page now says COMAR 08.07.06.13 doesn't mention fossils and DNR doesn't say which provision its beach allowance rests on, and that removal beyond the allowance needs Park Service permission (not required for beach collecting). The unsupported formation claims were removed. The pin now marks the parking lot at 10540 H. G. Trueman Road.
1 page corrected

Crater of Diamonds: penalty law added, 'ejection' removed, souvenir-soil and park-wide search rules, rental fees and holiday closures corrected

What was wrong
The page gave no criminal penalty for breaking the search-area rules and listed 'ejection' as a penalty for excavation violations, which no rule provides. It said unprocessed soil could not leave the search area 'at all', with no mention of the gift shop's souvenir soil bags. It did not say that searching is confined to the marked plowed field or that collecting anywhere else in the park needs written permission. It said admission is paid at the visitor center and 'not booked in advance', priced rentals at $5–$12 a day with a $5–$40 deposit, and said the park closes on 'major holidays'. It described the no-claims rule as barring anyone from reserving, holding or 'selling' ground, without mentioning guarding or the park's sluices and sorting tables. It said plowing runs 'roughly monthly through spring, summer and fall', said the search area has no shade, and left out the disability transport exception, the shade-device rule, the 2-foot spoil setback and the ban on entering water-filled holes. Its account of the 6.03-carat find said the stone was spotted 'at home' at a 'kitchen table' and that the dirt was screened before it left the park 'within the five-gallon concentrate allowance' — details the park's release does not give — and presented the 48-face observation unattributed. It dated the Prairie Creek pipe only to 'the Early Cretaceous'.
What it says now
Violating a State Parks rule is an unclassified misdemeanor punishable by a fine of $100–$500, up to 30 days in jail, or both (A.C.A. § 22-4-104(b), as quoted on Arkansas State Parks' rules page); repeated violation of the search-area rules may also lead to suspension of searching privileges, a written citation, arrest, or all three (22 CAR § 50-104(h)). 'Ejection' was removed; staff may fill any hole they consider unsafe (50-104(d)(7)). Unprocessed lamproite soil may not leave the search area, but souvenir bags of it may be bought in the gift shop in limited quantities (50-104(e)(2)(B)). Searching is confined to the plowed field inside the yellow boundary markers (50-104(c)(1)); searching for or removing minerals anywhere else in the park, including the Little Missouri River, needs written permission from the Director of the State Parks Division (22 CAR § 50-111(a)). Tickets may be bought online or at the park, with age counted on the day of the visit; rentals cost $5–$20 per item or kit per day plus a $5–$70 refundable deposit, and enclosed storage pens $8 a day or $75 for 30 days. The park closes on New Year's Day, Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. No area, hole, sluice or sorting table may be guarded, claimed or in any way reserved (50-104(c)(3)). The park plows about once a month as weather allows, six to eight times a year, with no set schedule. The field has little shade; tents and umbrellas may be put up but must be removed daily (50-104(b)(5)). The page now adds the case-by-case disability transport exception (50-104(b)(3)), the 2-foot spoil setback (50-104(d)(2)) and the ban on entering an excavation holding water (50-104(d)(4)). The 6.03-carat find now gives only what the park's release, as reported by KAIT and KARK, says: the finders dug on the south end of the search area in late December; Pearadin found the stone on January 25 while processing gravel concentrate from that dirt on TikTok Live; staff confirmed it on February 6. The hexoctahedron observation is attributed to Assistant Superintendent Waymon Cox. The Arkansas Geological Survey dates the pipe to about 100 million years ago.
1 page corrected

Garden Park Fossil Area: verdict now unclear after the 1996 plan was replaced; designations, rules, penalties and history

What was wrong
The Garden Park page said fossil and rock collecting is prohibited across the whole area because a triple designation (BLM ACEC since 1996, Colorado Research Natural Area since 1991, National Natural Landmark) closes it to consumptive use altogether, and it cited the Royal Gorge Resource Management Plan as the governing rule. It said visitors are limited to a wheelchair-accessible Marsh-Felch overlook and a half-mile gravel path to a Cope-Lucas Quarry overlook, and that a site-specific closure order bans climbing on the quarry scarps, drones are prohibited and pets must be leashed, with matching penalties. It gave the penalty as a civil citation with enhanced PRPA penalties only if vertebrate material is involved, and said research permits go only to paleontologists affiliated with an academic institution or museum. It said admission is free, the stops are open during daylight hours, there are no restrooms, water or reliable cell coverage, and the Royal Gorge Field Office displays Garden Park material. It named Cope's excavator 'Ormel Lucas', said a rancher's tip led Marsh's collector to the first bone 'eight miles north of Cañon City', and gave Amphicoelias fragillimus an estimated length near 190 feet. The Picket Wire Canyonlands page called Garden Park a Colorado site where some fossil collecting is possible.
What it says now
The verdict is now unclear. BLM's Royal Gorge Field Office said in 2011 that 'Casual collecting of fossils is not permitted in the area' and in 2012 that Garden Park was the only public land in the field office closed to it. The January 2024 Eastern Colorado Approved RMP supersedes the 1996 Royal Gorge RMP; its Garden Park ACEC (3,100 acres, Table II-37) has no collecting closure, and Paleontology Management Action 5 encourages educational, research and public use with emphasis on Garden Park. On BLM land, common invertebrate and plant fossils may be casually collected unless the land is closed (43 CFR 49.805(a)). The page now says vertebrate fossils need a permit everywhere, Colorado Parks and Wildlife asks visitors to refrain from fossil collection, and visitors should call the Royal Gorge Field Office (719-269-8500) before collecting any invertebrate or plant fossil. Designations are now the BLM ACEC (designated 1996), the 2,668-acre Garden Park Fossil Locality State Natural Area, and the National Natural Landmark (3,208 acres since 2013), whose designation does not dictate activity. The invented scarp, drone and leash rules and the closure order were removed; the page adds the 1995 target shooting closure (boundary adjusted 2002), the ACEC rule restricting vehicles and bicycles to designated roads and trails, and closure-order penalties (43 CFR 8364.1(e), 8360.0-7). PRPA penalties now cover every fossil (43 CFR 49.300(a)(1), 49.810(d)): up to 5 years for a knowing violation (2 if $500 or less), doubled for a repeat, plus civil penalties (43 CFR 49.500; 16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-6). Research permits require a relevant degree or demonstrated training and experience (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-3; 43 CFR 49.110). The stops are the Cleveland Quarry rest stop and the Marsh-Felch pullout with a ¼-mile trail; the Cope quarries are seen only from the road. No entry fee is listed, and the unsourced hours, facilities and cell claims were removed. History now reads: Oramel Lucas found bones in 1876, he and his brother Ira began quarrying for Cope in summer 1877, and Marsh's collectors came later that summer and worked with rancher Marshall P. Felch; the 190-foot Amphicoelias estimate was removed. The site is about 6 miles north of Cañon City, and the map pin moved to the Marsh-Felch Quarry trail (38.5376, -105.2241). The Picket Wire page now says Garden Park's collecting rules are also unsettled.
2 pages corrected

Huntington Beach State Park: the state-park rule doesn't name fossils; no tourism 'top shark-tooth beach' listing; Hobby License, dogs and other beaches corrected

What was wrong
The page said SC State Parks' FAQ 'applies that rule to fossils and minerals' and called removal 'not a gray area'; the shark-teeth material page said SC state parks 'forbid removing fossils' and the Folly Beach page said § 51-3-145 'bars removing rocks, minerals and fossils'. It said South Carolina's tourism materials list Huntington Beach State Park as a top shark-tooth beach. It said Folly Beach and 'any other municipal or county SC beach' allow surface collecting under a 'general SC coastal norm', and that a Hobby License is needed below low water 'or with SCUBA'. It said removal is 'rarely enforced'. It called the 3-mile beach 'undeveloped', running from the 'Atalaya causeway' to the north jetty, and said dogs were prohibited only between the north parking lot and the jetty. It cited a Georgetown County beachfront-lighting ordinance and a May 1–October 31 nesting season, said shells may not leave the park under the same removal rule, and described the beach's shark fauna without a source.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'prohibited', stated as our reading. S.C. Code § 51-3-145(D) bars 'taking or gathering any tree, shrub, other plant or plant part, rock, mineral, or geological feature except by permit issued by the department', and SC State Parks' FAQ says 'the collection, injury, manipulation or removal of any forest items including minerals, plants, plant parts, or mushrooms for personal consumption or use is NOT allowed'. Neither names fossils; SCIAA describes fossil shark teeth as mineralized remains, so we read the rule as covering them, and the page says to ask the park (843-237-4440). The only permit the FAQ describes is a special permit for scientific research through Resource Management. SCPRT's 'Five Beaches for Shark Tooth Sleuthing' does not list the park, so the tourism claim was removed. The City of Folly Beach and Town of Edisto Beach beaches allow collecting; county parks, heritage preserves and other state parks have their own removal rules. The SCIAA Hobby License (Underwater Antiquities Act) is required for collecting below the mean low watermark (§ 54-7-670(A)); scuba certification is not required; fees are $5/$10 for six months and $18/$36 for two years (resident/non-resident, § 54-7-670(B)); it allows hand collection only, no articulated fossils and nothing above the waterline; violations are a misdemeanor with a fine up to $50, each day a separate offense (§ 54-7-810(A)). The § 51-3-146 penalty ($25–$200 or up to 30 days) stays, without 'rarely enforced'. Dogs are allowed on the south end of the beach on a leash of six feet or less and prohibited in buildings, including Atalaya, and on the north end (north parking lot beach access to the jetty). The turtle note now says to follow posted nest closures and keep lights off the beach at night; the shells answer says SC State Parks hasn't published a rule on empty shells and to ask the park office. The shark-teeth material page and Folly Beach page now describe the state-park rule the same way.
3 pages corrected

Jones Beach: detecting zones are mapped online; artifact rule comes from the permit guide and Education Law § 233; lost-property law and penalties corrected

What was wrong
The page said the Jones Beach zone map was 'not fully reproduced in any source available online' and that the printed guide held detail the web did not. It listed the off-limits areas as golf courses, driving ranges and 'residential-use areas', leaving out beach dune areas, landscaped areas and wildlife and piping plover nesting areas. It attributed the rule that archaeological objects must be surrendered to Park Police to 9 NYCRR § 372.7(n), and said the rule applied with 'coins and modern relics aside'. It did not say what happens to lost property under state law. It gave penalties as a Park Police citation with on-the-spot confiscation of equipment and finds (9 NYCRR § 372.7(o)), a 'citation' and seizure for keeping finds (9 NYCRR § 372.7(n)–(o)), and permit suspension or revocation for tool violations. It gave visitors as about 9.5 million, called Jones Beach New York's second-most-visited state park, said the National Register listing was the 'Jones Beach State Park Historic District' covering the Central Mall, said the park was 'completed in 1929', and cited the Saratoga-Capital District region's metal detector permit form as a source. It also carried unsourced claims about WWII military finds tied to U-boat activity, a 'towel line' tip, sand mineralization and fall being the strongest season.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'permit-required' (9 NYCRR § 372.7(o): permits 'in designated areas only'). The Long Island Region Metal Detecting Permit Guide does include a Jones Beach map: the ocean beach from the West End to around the Central Mall and part of the Zach's Bay shore are open year-round, and a few smaller areas only Memorial Day–Labor Day; the page tells readers to call the park (516-785-1600) if unsure. Off-limits areas now match the guide: beach dune areas, landscaped areas, golf courses, driving ranges and residences, and detecting must not interfere with wildlife or piping plover nesting areas. The turn-in rules are attributed to the permit guide: items worth more than $20 go to Park Police, and archaeological artifacts must not be removed from the park but turned over to Park Police. The legal ban is Education Law § 233(4): no investigating, excavating or removing objects of archaeological, historical, cultural, scientific or paleontological interest on state land without the commissioner of education's written permission, a class A misdemeanor with seizure and forfeiture of the items and of the instrumentalities. 9 NYCRR § 372.7(n) is cited only for the separate excavation permit, subject to State Education Department approval. The page adds Personal Property Law § 252(1): found property worth $20 or more must be returned to the owner or deposited with police within ten days (§ 252(3): misdemeanor, fine up to $100 and/or up to six months); unclaimed property goes to the finder after three months (under $100) up to three years ($5,000 or more) (§§ 253(7), 254(2), 257). Penalties now read: a permit or park-rule breach is a 'violation' (Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation Law § 27.11), fine up to $250 (Penal Law § 80.05(4)), and the 2026 Permits Guide says non-compliance may bring revocation for one year; the confiscation claim was removed; digging beyond the permit also breaks 9 NYCRR § 375.1(e). Visitors are 'about 8 million' (park page); the NRHP listing is the Jones Beach State Park, Causeway and Parkway System (April 28, 2005); the park opened August 4, 1929, with the East Bathhouse completed in spring 1930. The Saratoga-Capital form was replaced with the Long Island Permits Guide 2026 ($40 annually, sold year-round, expires December 31, valid at 13 listed parks), with purchase details (ReserveAmerica or 1-800-456-2267, mailed in 10–14 business days; in-person sales September 8–December 31, 2026, including at Jones Beach and the Regional Permit Office). The unsourced WWII, towel-line, mineralization and best-season claims were removed.
1 page corrected

Marshall Gold Discovery SHP: panning authority, metal-detector order and penalties

What was wrong
The page said Public Resources Code § 5001.65 is the statutory authority for panning in the park; § 5001.65(b) covers only state beaches, state recreation areas and state vehicular recreation areas. It said metal detecting should be treated as prohibited because of 14 CCR §§ 4307 and 4611 and that a written CDPR authorization was the only route, without citing the park's posted order. It said CDPR restricts panning to the east bank to protect historic resources; CDPR attaches that reason to the hands-and-pans rule and gives none for the west-bank closure. It gave equipment seizure and forfeiture of material as penalties, which no cited source supports, and called removing archaeological material a felony under PRC § 5097.99 without saying that section covers only Native American items from a grave or cairn. The dredge row cited only Fish & Game Code § 5653 and gave no penalty range. It listed a snuffer bottle and vial as allowed equipment. The map pin was about a third of a mile southwest of the Mount Murphy Road bridge rather than on the east bank where panning is allowed.
What it says now
Panning is permitted under 14 CCR § 4307(b), which allows rockhounding as defined in § 4301(v), including "panning for gold in the natural water-washed gravel of streams"; CDPR has opened the east bank across the Mount Murphy Road bridge, hands and pans only. District Superintendent's Order 690-039-2023 bars possessing or using a metal detector anywhere in the park, except carrying one unused in a vehicle on a public road or under a 43 CFR 423.50 permit; other exceptions need the Gold Fields District Superintendent's written approval. Violating department rules and orders is a misdemeanor (up to 90 days in jail and/or a $1,000 fine) or an infraction (up to $1,000) under PRC § 5008(d). Removing archaeological or historical material breaches 14 CCR §§ 4308 and 4611(h) and is a misdemeanor under PRC § 5097.5 (up to $10,000 and/or one year); it is a felony under § 5097.99 only for Native American items from a grave or cairn. Suction dredging is prohibited statewide by Fish & Game Code § 5653.1(b); using a dredge without a permit is a misdemeanor (§ 5653(c)) punishable by up to $1,000 and/or six months (§ 12002(a)). The page now says CDPR allows hands and pans only, so visitors should ask the museum before bringing a snuffer bottle. The pin was moved to the east bank. The verdict (allowed) is unchanged. The Auburn SRA page gave the distance to Marshall Gold as 22 miles (it is about 11.3) and now notes Marshall's detector ban.
2 pages corrected

Myrtle Beach: digging-rule citation, sand-scoop exception, penalty, neighbouring jurisdictions and turtle season corrected

What was wrong
The Myrtle Beach page cited City Code "§ 5-20" for the 2-foot hole limit, the fill-in rule and the metal-shovel ban; § 5-20 prohibits diving or jumping from piers. It said a 2021 ordinance exempted metal sand scoops from the shovel ban "specifically while metal detecting" and that the ban was adopted because of unfilled holes; the code has no such exception. It called Chapter 5 "Beach and Boat Ramp Regulations", described the penalty as a misdemeanor class "and/or" without the continuing-violation rule, said "at least six separately incorporated towns" line the Grand Strand, naming Garden City and Murrells Inlet among them (both are unincorporated) and omitting Atlantic Beach and Briarcliffe Acres, and said loggerhead nesting runs "mid-May through mid-August" with nests sitting "in the dune line". It said the Underwater Antiquities Act does not reach surf-zone detecting and compared Myrtle Beach to the Congaree River page's "hobby license requirement". It also carried an unsourced 18.2 million visitor figure and "60-mile" Grand Strand length, and its map pin sat inland on North Kings Highway.
What it says now
The digging rules are City Code § 5-14(d) ("Except for city issued special permitted events, metal shovels shall not be used for recreational digging on the beach") and § 5-14(e) (holes must be filled before leaving and may be no deeper than two feet), in Chapter 5, Beach and Boating Regulations. The code has no exception for metal detecting and doesn't define "shovel"; the page tells readers to ask the city (843-918-1014) whether a metal sand scoop counts, or use a non-metal scoop. Where detecting is allowed (the public beach, not the dunes, the street ends or any other public property) is labelled as city policy. Violations are punishable under § 1-9(a) by a fine up to $500 or up to 30 days, or both, each day a separate offense. North Myrtle Beach, Atlantic Beach, Briarcliffe Acres, Surfside Beach and Pawleys Island are separate towns; Garden City, Murrells Inlet and other stretches are unincorporated, under Horry or Georgetown County rules. The page adds their digging rules: North Myrtle Beach § 5-25 (holes over 12 inches filled before leaving; $100 civil penalty), Surfside Beach § 12-67(j) (2-foot max, fill, no shovels with blades over 6 inches; misdemeanor under § 1-16(a)), Horry County § 5-22(h) and Georgetown County § 5.5-17(e) (2-foot max, fill; Georgetown $20 civil penalty). SCDNR gives the nesting season as May through October: loggerheads lay from May to mid-August and nests hatch July through October. The Underwater Antiquities Act's hobby license covers historic or fossil material recovered below mean low water; dry-sand detecting is outside it, and modern losses aren't "artifacts" under § 54-7-620(1) (unclaimed more than 50 years). The state-park policy's authority, S.C. Code § 51-3-70, is now named. The unsourced visitor and length figures are removed, and the pin moved to the beach at 33.6895, -78.8805.
1 page corrected

Spencer Opal Mines: the dig is at the store in town; the land around the mine is national forest, not BLM

What was wrong
The page said the tailings-pile dig 'sits entirely on privately claimed, patented ground' and placed the map pin north of town. It named the BLM Upper Snake Field Office as the manager of the surrounding land under 43 CFR 8365.1-5(b), and said sources conflicted on whether the Opal Mountain area was BLM land or Caribou-Targhee National Forest. It cited the 'General Mining Law of 1872 claim-rights framework' as the trespass rule for claims, and BLM penalties under 43 CFR 8360.0-7 (up to $1,000 and/or 12 months). It said closed-toe shoes were required, gave the season as roughly Memorial Day weekend through mid-September, dated the opal to about 4 million years ago, said hydrophane opal can hold up to 20% water, called Spencer the only opal mine in Idaho still producing, told an unsourced discovery story (hunters sheltering from a storm, late 1940s or early 1960s), listed obsidian as a find, and put Spencer about 70 miles from Yellowstone.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed' (private fee dig, no government permit). The tailings-pile dig is at the company's store, 27 Opal Ave in Spencer: $75 per person, $50 for kids under 16, including a 2.5-gallon bucket, no reservations; the store is open Thursday–Monday 9 a.m.–6 p.m. and digging 9 a.m.–5 p.m. on shop days. Ore is brought down weekly from the company's mine about 5 miles east of town, which USGS MRDS lists as patented. The land around the mine is Caribou-Targhee National Forest (USGS MRDS land status; BLM surface management map), with active unpatented lode claims on Opal Mountain (BLM MLRS); the Forest Service handles personal-use rock and mineral collecting through a free use permit, collecting must not conflict with claims, and the page points readers to the Dubois Ranger District, (208) 374-5422. Penalties now read: removing a natural feature from national forest land, 36 CFR 261.9(b), up to 6 months and/or a fine under 18 U.S.C. 3571 (36 CFR 261.1b); trespass on private land, including a patented claim, Idaho Code § 18-7008 (misdemeanor; first offense up to 6 months and $500–$1,000, or a $300 infraction if there was no damage and the person leaves when told). The closed-toe shoe rule was removed; eye protection is given as the operator's 2025 rule (sunglasses accepted). The season is 'summer only, dates not published, call ahead'. The 4-million-year age, the 20% water figure, the 'only producing mine in Idaho' claim, the storm story and obsidian were removed; the page now cites a 2025 Minerals study (Pliocene to Quaternary volcanism; discovered by chance in 1948; 'the only operating in the region'). Spencer is about 57 miles in a straight line from West Yellowstone and about 15 miles south of Monida Pass. The map pin moved to the store.
1 page corrected

Bisti/De-Na-Zin: rock collecting is allowed; only petrified wood is banned

What was wrong
The page said rockhounding at Bisti/De-Na-Zin Wilderness was prohibited: that no published BLM guidance allows ordinary rock and mineral collecting inside the wilderness and that nothing could legally be taken home. It applied the Archaeological Resources Protection Act to vertebrate fossils, named the 1984 law the "New Mexico Wilderness Act", listed an 8-person group limit and a campfire ban that BLM does not publish, and gave wrong distances (Rockhound State Park ~180 miles; Ah-Shi-Sle-Pah ~20 miles northeast).
What it says now
BLM's visitor page says "BLM regulations for rock collecting apply, with the exception of petrified wood, collection of which is prohibited by the site's Wilderness Management Plan." Ordinary rocks and minerals may be collected in reasonable amounts for personal use, and in wilderness BLM limits collecting to non-motorized hand tools with minimal surface disturbance. Vertebrate fossils fall under the Paleontological Resources Preservation Act (ARPA excludes fossils outside an archaeological context, 16 U.S.C. § 470bb(1)). The 1984 law is the San Juan Basin Wilderness Protection Act (Pub. L. 98-603). The group-size and campfire rows were removed. Rockhound State Park is about 285 miles away and Ah-Shi-Sle-Pah about 19 miles east-southeast. The verdict changed from prohibited to allowed, which also changes the BLM rockhounding comparison table.
2 pages corrected

Florida Fossil Permit: issued by the Florida Museum for $5 a year, and open to hobbyists

What was wrong
The Florida Fossil Permit page said the permit is issued by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission under Fla. Stat. § 379.2461, is free, covers only freshwater bodies, takes 4–6 weeks, requires a scientific or educational purpose and a project description, and is rarely issued to recreational collectors. § 379.2461 does not exist.
What it says now
The permit is issued by the Florida Museum of Natural History's Program of Vertebrate Paleontology under Fla. Stat. §§ 1004.57–1004.576, costs $5 a year, and is required for anyone collecting vertebrate fossils (other than shark and ray teeth) on state-owned or leased land, including riverbeds, public beaches and the sea floor out to three nautical miles (nine in the Gulf). About 3,000 hobbyists hold one. Finds are reported to the museum and become the collector's property if not claimed within 60 days. Collecting without a permit is a misdemeanor (up to $500 and/or 6 months, plus forfeiture, § 1004.576(2)). Processing takes up to four weeks. The page now lists its sources.
1 page corrected

Bathtub Reef Beach: what the reef is, the rules that protect it, and the county park code

What was wrong
The page called the reef a coquina rock formation and tied its protection to "Florida coastal resource protection rules" and the coastal construction law (§ 161.053), which it also cited for dune vegetation. It said no Martin County ordinance applied and left out the county park code, said angling was permitted from the beach, did not mention that designated swimming areas are swimming-only while lifeguards are on duty, gave an unverified county phone number (772-288-5637), and said Jensen Beach Park was 4.5 miles away. Its Chapter 267 penalty said restitution could be ordered for any violation.
What it says now
Martin County describes the reef as "created by tiny tube-building Sabellariid sea worms". Inside the park, Martin County Code § 17.9.A.2.p bars disturbing or removing "any cultural or natural resource including vegetation" without the county's written permission (misdemeanor, up to 60 days and/or $500, § 17.4.A). In state waters, FWC's live-rock rule defines live rock to include "any formations created by tube worms of the family Sabellariidae" (Fla. Admin. Code R. 68B-42.002(12)) and provides that "No person shall harvest or possess for sale any live rock in or from state waters" (R. 68B-42.008(1)). Sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242. Fishing is barred within 50 feet of a full-service beach park (§ 17.9.A.2.x); designated swimming areas are swimming-only while lifeguards are on duty (§ 17.9.D.2), and the county can designate Bathtub a swimming-only beach (§ 17.9.D.4). Parks and Recreation is (772) 221-1418. Jensen Beach Park is about 5.3 miles north. Restitution under § 267.13 applies to the felony tier. The "allowed, no permit" verdict stands.
1 page corrected

Caladesi Island State Park: fees, ferry stay limit, access and dune citation

What was wrong
The Caladesi Island page said the park entry fee is included in the ferry ticket, that tickets can be booked online and sell out, that the binding limit for visitors is the last ferry of the day, that private boaters need a "day-use permit", and that missing the last ferry leaves visitors stranded with no legal way to leave. It said the bay shoreline is categorically off-limits and the ocean beach "fully open", cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 as the dune-vegetation rule with the line at the dune crest, and described Chapter 267 as covering "all items over 50 years old statewide". Its alternatives gave road-style distances (Clearwater Beach 8 mi, Fort De Soto 22 mi, St. Pete Beach 25 mi). The Honeymoon Island page's comparison table said Caladesi's $8/vehicle fee "includes ferry cost".
What it says now
Ferry passengers pay the Honeymoon Island entrance fee ($8 per vehicle, $4 single-occupant vehicle, $2 pedestrian) plus a separate ferry fare ($20 adult, $10 ages 6–12, under 6 free); boaters pay $6 per boat (up to eight people), $2 each additional person, $2 per kayaker. Ferry tickets are sold only at the ticket office in Honeymoon Island State Park, not online; boats leave hourly from 10 a.m. (half-hourly mid-February to Labor Day and on weekends) and a ticket gives a stay of up to four hours. The park is open 8 a.m. to sundown; since Sept. 29, 2026 its docks are day-use only. Florida State Parks describes the island as accessible only by boat; the page now says there is no road or bridge and asks readers to call the park (727-241-6126) before planning to walk in from North Clearwater Beach. Detecting is allowed only in beach areas the park manager designates, seaward of the toe of the dune, with bay-side beaches excluded unless designated. Dunes are off-limits under State Parks policy and FAC 62D-2.013(2); sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242. Chapter 267 covers historic objects abandoned on state land, with no age threshold. Distances are now straight-line (4.2, 29.4 and 22.1 mi).
2 pages corrected

Clearwater Beach: city code allows refilled digs, bars removing historic artifacts; Sand Key Park location; dune penalty

What was wrong
The Clearwater Beach page said only that no city ordinance banning detecting was found, called filling holes a courtesy, implied historic finds on the city's dry sand were unrestricted, and gave no city penalty. It used a 50-year threshold for what finders may keep. It placed Sand Key County Park at the south end of the Clearwater Beach island, said the beach runs north toward Clearwater Pass, and listed the county park permit as required while its notes said no permit is needed. It gave the dune penalty as a civil fine under § 161.053, named Pinellas County Code Chapter 90 "Parks and Recreation", called Caladesi Island ferry-only, and gave alternatives distances of 6, 23 and 28 mi.
What it says now
Clearwater City Code § 22.28(3) expressly allows minor excavations to recover lost artifacts on the public beaches if they are immediately refilled and create no safety hazard; § 22.28(4) bars excavating, disturbing or removing historic or prehistoric cultural artifacts, bones, shells or geological specimens on city-owned or managed land without written permission. Chapter 22 violations carry a fine up to $500 and/or up to 60 days (§ 1.12). Chapter 267 has no age threshold. Sand Key County Park is on the north tip of Sand Key, across Clearwater Pass to the south; the city beach runs south toward Clearwater Pass and north toward Dunedin Pass. No permit is required there (County Code § 90-7(p), Chapter 90 "Parks and Conservation Resources"). Violating § 161.053 is a first-degree misdemeanor (§ 161.053(7)), with DEP fines up to $15,000 per offense and liability for damage (§ 161.054); sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242. Caladesi has no road or bridge and is reached by ferry or private boat. Distances are now straight-line (4.2, 18.2 and 25.4 mi).
1 page corrected

National forest foraging: 36 CFR 223.279 was never in force; the legal basis is the 1999 statute and 36 CFR 261.6(h)

What was wrong
The USFS foraging guide, the national-forest foraging comparison, the Oregon and Washington foraging overviews and 11 forest pages cited 36 CFR § 223.279 as the regulation that makes personal-use foraging free in national forests and lets each forest set its personal-use level, and the guide quoted its text. That section, like all of 36 CFR Part 223 Subpart G (§§ 223.275–223.283), never took effect: the 2008 rule (73 FR 79386) was delayed indefinitely in 2009 (74 FR 26091). A 2026-10-02 correction had wrongly made § 223.279 the stated legal basis. The guide also still said that wilderness areas prohibit all personal-use foraging and that you must choose a different location if your target area is in a wilderness, wording the 2026-10-02 correction had retired. The guide's table and the Olympic National Forest page's comparison table still gave Olympic National Forest's limit as 1 gallon per person per day.
What it says now
Personal-use harvest below each forest's personal-use harvest level is free under Pub. L. 106-113, § 339, printed as a note to 16 U.S.C. § 528: "The Secretary of Agriculture shall establish a personal use harvest level for each forest botanical product, and the harvest of a forest botanical product below that level by a person for personal use shall not be subject to a fee." Removing any forest product is prohibited except as authorized (36 CFR § 261.6(h)). Each national forest sets its own limits and decides whether a free permit is needed through its own published rules. Penalty rows now cite 36 CFR § 261.6(h). The Wilderness Act bars commercial enterprise in wilderness but does not itself ban personal-use picking; some forests restrict it. Olympic National Forest allows 1 gallon per mushroom species per year and berries at 1 gallon a day and 3 a year.
16 pages corrected

Ocala National Forest foraging: yellow star-anise, wilderness, size and permit type

What was wrong
The Ocala National Forest foraging page called yellow star-anise (Illicium parviflorum) federally endangered and listed Endangered Species Act penalties of up to $25,000 civil or $50,000 criminal. It said all wild orchids and all pitcher plants, sundews and bladderworts are Florida-listed and may not be collected under any circumstances. It said the forest's three wilderness areas ban all foraging, missing Little Lake George, and made up a 100-foot no-collecting buffer around archaeological sites. It called Ocala the largest national forest east of the Mississippi at about 607,000 acres, called the commercial harvest permit a Special Use Permit under 36 CFR 261.6(a), described personal use as "incidental quantities", and put Apalachicola National Forest 185 miles away.
What it says now
Yellow star-anise is not listed under the ESA (USFWS gives it as a resolved taxon). Florida lists it as endangered (FAC 5B-40.0055), so harvesting it on public land needs the landowner's written permission and an FDACS permit (Fla. Stat. § 581.185(3)(a)); a violation is a first-degree misdemeanor (§ 581.211). Many orchids and several pitcher plants and sundews are state-listed, not all, and bladderworts are not on the index; for endangered plants the law requires permission and a permit rather than banning collection outright. None of them is edible material, so the personal-use allowance doesn't cover them. Ocala has four wilderness areas (Alexander Springs, Billies Bay, Juniper Prairie, Little Lake George); the Wilderness Act bars commercial enterprise but does not itself ban personal-use picking. Archaeological sites may not be dug or disturbed (36 CFR 261.9), with no distance rule. The Forest Service gives Ocala 384,657 acres of National Forest System land; established in 1908, it was the third national forest east of the Mississippi, and Apalachicola is the larger forest. Commercial collecting needs a forest-products permit from the District Ranger, and unpermitted removal falls under 36 CFR 261.6(h). Personal use is gathering edible material for your own consumption, as National Forests in Florida puts it. Apalachicola is about 199 miles away.
1 page corrected

Dinosaur National Monument fossil hunting: map location, address, penalties, PRPA and quarry facts

What was wrong
The Dinosaur National Monument page placed its map pin in Moffat County, Colorado, about 16 miles east of the Quarry Exhibit Hall, and gave the Exhibit Hall's address as 1625 E 400 N, Jensen. It cited the Antiquities Act as 16 U.S.C. § 433 with a fine of up to $500 and/or 90 days, and described it as covering objects of scientific interest such as fossils. It said PRPA criminalizes casual fossil collecting on all federal land, and folded 36 CFR § 2.1 into PRPA's 2-year penalty row instead of giving its own penalty. It said the quarry wall holds bones of 11 species including Brachiosaurus altithorax and Camarasaurus supremus, and that about 350 tons were excavated between 1909 and 1924. It said fossils are visible in the canyon walls on the Colorado side and along the Yampa, told visitors never to touch the fossils, and limited the drone ban to fossil-bearing areas.
What it says now
The pin is now at the Quarry Exhibit Hall in Uintah County, Utah (40.4406, -109.3013). NPS gives an address only for the Quarry Visitor Center (11625 E 1500 S, Jensen, UT 84035); the Exhibit Hall is a separate building a 3-minute drive away, reached by free shuttle in summer and by private vehicle from October to April. The Antiquities Act is now 54 U.S.C. §§ 320301–320303 and is the law under which the monument was proclaimed in 1915; its penalty (18 U.S.C. § 1866(b)) covers objects of antiquity, so the page no longer lists it as a fossil penalty. PRPA requires a permit to collect on federal land but lets BLM, Reclamation and the Forest Service allow casual collecting of common invertebrate and plant fossils (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-3(a)(2)); that exception does not reach NPS land, and PRPA's criminal penalties apply to knowing violations. A violation of 36 CFR § 2.1 is a federal petty offense under 36 CFR § 1.3 and 18 U.S.C. § 1865: up to 6 months and a fine of up to $5,000. NPS says about 1,500 bones from 8 species remain in the wall; Brachiosaurus is not on its list of Quarry dinosaurs and the quarry's Camarasaurus is C. lentus. The Carnegie Museum's excavations ran from 1909 to 1922 and removed over 300 tons. NPS says dinosaur fossils are not visible in the Colorado portion of the monument. The Exhibit Hall has several places where visitors may touch real fossils; climbing on the rock face is prohibited. The 2026 compendium bans drones throughout the monument unless approved in writing and prohibits off-trail hiking in the Fossil Discovery Trail drainage. The San Rafael Swell is about 137 miles southwest.
1 page corrected

Venice Beach metal detecting: verdict changed from "allowed" to "unclear"

What was wrong
The Venice Beach metal-detecting page said detecting was allowed with no permit because the City of Venice code has no ordinance prohibiting it. It cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 alone as a year-round dune ban with a "civil fine; restoration costs" penalty, and said Caspersen Beach was closed. It said the Peace River, which it said empties near Venice, deposits the shark teeth. It stated the Florida Fossil Permit rule without limiting it to state lands and exempted only shark teeth, not ray teeth. It put the beach on Harbor Drive South between the pier and the South Jetty, with the map pin about 0.3 mile inland, and put Siesta Key Beach 30 miles away.
What it says now
City of Venice Code § 46-62(a)(12) bars anyone from digging, moving or removing sand, fossils, artifacts or other materials in every city-owned, leased or operated park and beach, with no exception for recovering lost items; § 46-62(b)(1) exempts only shells, shark teeth and other natural materials that wash up. No Venice code section mentions metal detectors, so the verdict is "unclear" until the city says whether digging a target is a violation. A violation is punishable on conviction by a fine up to $500 and/or 60 days in jail (§§ 46-61, 1-14). Damaging dunes seaward of the coastal construction control line is prohibited (§ 161.053(2)(a)), a first-degree misdemeanor (§ 161.053(7)) with a DEP fine up to $15,000 per offense (§ 161.054), and sea oats and sea grapes on public land are protected by § 161.242. Caspersen Beach is open to pedestrians and bicycles, with no vehicle parking. The teeth come from the Peace River Formation exposed just offshore; the Peace River enters Charlotte Harbor. The Florida Fossil Permit covers vertebrate fossils on state lands, and shark and ray teeth are exempt. Venice Beach is at 101 The Esplanade, the west end of West Venice Avenue, with the South Jetty about a mile north and the pier about two miles south; the pin was moved there. Siesta Key Beach is about 12.8 miles away in a straight line.
1 page corrected

Clearwater Beach: the city requires a metal detector permit

What was wrong
The Clearwater Beach page said no permit is needed on the City of Clearwater public beach, citing City Code § 22.28(3). That was published in the re-verification earlier the same day, which read the city code but not the city's beach rules page.
What it says now
The City of Clearwater's beach rules page says "Metal detectors are allowed by permit-only" and links to the city's online permit application, which sets the permitted area and conditions. The verdict changed from allowed to permit-required. City Code § 22.28(3) still requires every dig to recover a lost item to be refilled immediately.
3 pages corrected

St. Pete Beach: city dune and turtle-lighting rules, dune penalty, Pass-a-Grille date, distances

What was wrong
The St. Pete Beach page cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 alone as the dune rule, with a "civil fine" penalty, and said no city rule other than general beach use applied. It omitted the city's Land Development Code dune rules and its nighttime sea turtle lighting rule, and told readers not to dig in nesting zones at night and to check an FWC turtle nest map that doesn't exist. It said Pass-a-Grille was settled or platted in 1892, that St. Pete Beach occupies the southern half of Long Key, and that Egmont Key is about 4 miles offshore. It called the Don CeSar's beach frontage private without the mean high-water qualifier, and named Chapter 267 the "Historical Resources Act". Its alternatives gave Clearwater Beach as 23 mi and Fort De Soto as 10 mi away; Fort De Soto's page also said St. Pete Beach is 10 miles north, and Honeymoon Island's put it at 20 mi.
What it says now
Neither the City of St. Pete Beach Code of Ordinances nor its Land Development Code mentions metal detecting; the verdict (allowed, no permit) stands. The city bars crossing dunes except at marked crossovers and disturbing dune vegetation (LDC § 25.5(d)), and excavating or damaging a dune without DEP and city permits (LDC § 25.9(a)); City Code violations with no specific penalty carry up to $500 and/or 60 days (§ 1-14). From May 1 to October 31 the city bars transient lighting, flashlights included, that purposely and flagrantly illuminates nesting turtles or hatchlings at night (LDC §§ 44.2, 44.3(c)). State law: damaging dunes seaward of the CCCL is a first-degree misdemeanor (§ 161.053(2)(a), (7)) with DEP fines up to $15,000 per offense (§ 161.054); sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242. The Phillips family homesteaded Pass-a-Grille in 1886 (Florida historical marker F-606). The city covers all of Long Key; Egmont Key is about 7 miles south of Pass-a-Grille's tip. Dry sand above mean high water in front of hotels may be private; the city repealed its customary-use ordinance in 2019. Chapter 267 is the Florida Historical Resources Act. Distances are now straight-line: Clearwater Beach 18.2 mi, Fort De Soto 7.3 mi, Honeymoon Island 25.3 mi.
3 pages corrected

Siesta Key Beach: verdict changed from allowed to unclear — county code bars digging and removal

What was wrong
The Siesta Key Beach page said Sarasota County Code § 90-33 permits recreational metal detecting on county beaches without a permit, that the ordinance restricts only geological and archaeological material and not modern lost items, and that violations bring a fine and possible removal from the park. It cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 as the dune rule, gave Venice Beach and Caspersen Beach as 30 and 32 miles away, said the county ordinance does not apply at Venice Beach, and called Caspersen Beach closed because of Hurricane Helene.
What it says now
Verdict changed from allowed to unclear (no permit exists). Chapter 90 never mentions metal detecting. § 90-33(a)(16) prohibits "digging, harmfully disturbing or removing" sand, soil, fossils, minerals, plants, cultural resources, "artifacts, or other materials" on county parks and beaches, expressly including the Siesta Key beaches from Palmer Point Park to the City of Sarasota limits and the foreshore. Its only beach exceptions are sand sculpting and collecting shells, sharks' teeth and other natural materials that wash up, unless other law prohibits it; nothing excepts detecting or lost property. Violations are second-degree misdemeanors, up to 60 days and $500 (§ 90-38(3)). The page now tells readers to ask Sarasota County Parks (311 or 941-861-5000) before detecting. Sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242; the county's sea turtle ordinance bars lighting nesting turtles or hatchlings from sunset to sunrise in nesting season (§ 54-758) and harming turtles (§ 54-760). The county article applies inside cities unless a city ordinance conflicts (§ 90-39). Caspersen Beach's Harbor Drive access washed out in the 2024 storm season and it has been open to pedestrians and cyclists only. Distances are now straight-line (Venice Beach 12.7 mi, Caspersen Beach 16.0 mi).
1 page corrected

Volusia County beaches: no metal-detecting permit, and the driving lanes are off-limits while open

What was wrong
The Daytona Beach and New Smyrna Beach pages, and a separate permit page, said metal detecting on Volusia County beaches needs a free annual permit from Volusia County Beach Safety, obtained by phone at (386) 239-6484, and that detecting without it violates the county's Chapter 20 Beach Code. No ordinance, county page or agency source establishes such a permit, and every web mention of it traced back to this site. The pages also said beach safety officers enforce Chapter 20, that Chapter 20 requires holes to be filled, that you can detect in the driving lanes if you watch for traffic, and that you need a vehicle beach permit to detect in driving zones. They limited the county-park ban to "inland" parks, cited § 161.053 alone for dune vegetation, put the Canaveral National Seashore boundary at the entrance station's address and called its detector ban "absolute", and gave no federal penalty. The Flagler Beach, Panama City Beach and Florida overview pages repeated the permit claim, and Flagler Beach put the Volusia county line about 18 miles south, near Beverly Beach.
What it says now
Volusia County Code Chapter 20 never mentions metal detecting, and the county's beach-rules page lists no detecting rule, so the verdict is now "allowed" with no permit (confirm with Beach Safety, 386-239-7873). The Volusia Sheriff's Office enforces Chapter 20 (§ 20-9), with a fine up to $500 and/or 60 days (§ 1-7(c)). Walking in the driving area while vehicles are allowed is unlawful except to cross it (§ 20-174(10)), and no sand may be removed from the beach (§ 20-124). The vehicle access fee applies only to vehicles (§ 20-202). Detecting is banned in "any Volusia County park", beachfront parks included (§ 82-34: trespass). The dune rules now cite §§ 161.053(2)(a) and 161.242 and Volusia § 20-272(b)(2). Canaveral National Seashore's boundary meets the beach just north of the Apollo Beach entrance station, a broken-down, packed detector may be carried (36 CFR 2.1(a)(7)(i)), and a violation carries up to $5,000 and 6 months (36 CFR 1.3; 18 U.S.C. § 1865). The permit page was deleted and redirects to Daytona Beach. The claim was removed from the other three pages, and the county line is about 3 miles south of Flagler Beach. Map pins were moved from the mainland to the beach, and distances were recalculated.
5 pages corrected, 1 removed

Caspersen Beach: the park is open to walkers and cyclists, and § 90-33 doesn't allow detecting

What was wrong
The Caspersen Beach page said the park had been closed to public access since Hurricanes Helene and Milton, told readers not to attempt access, listed a trespass penalty for entering a closed county park, and gave a possible 2027 reopening and a contractor selection with no county source. It said Sarasota County Code § 90-33 permits metal detecting on county beaches, and gave the penalty as a county code fine. The pin was about 2.2 miles north of the beach, in the City of Venice; Siesta Key Beach was given as 32 miles away (it is about 16), and a comparison row put Manasota Key in the 'Casey Key area' under Charlotte County rules. Chapter 267 was called the 'Historical Resources Act' and § 161.053 the 'Coastal Construction Control Line Act'. The Englewood Beach page also called Caspersen closed and said detecting is allowed on Sarasota County beaches.
What it says now
Sarasota County Parks lists Caspersen Beach Park as open to pedestrian and bicycle access, 6 a.m. to 10 p.m., with no vehicle parking: its Harbor Drive access washed out in the 2024 storm season, and the parking, restrooms and playground are closed until repairs can be made. Access is from South Brohard Park or the Venetian Waterway Park Trail. The closed-park penalty, the reopening timeline and the contractor claim were removed. No Sarasota County ordinance mentions metal detecting; § 90-33(a)(16) bars digging, harmfully disturbing or removing sand, fossils, artifacts or other materials in county parks and on county beaches, with an exception for washed-up shells, sharks' teeth and other natural materials, so the verdict stays 'unclear' on that basis, as at Siesta Key Beach. Violations are second-degree misdemeanors, up to 60 days and $500 (§ 90-38(3)). The pin is now on the beach, distances are straight-line, the Manasota Key row was replaced, Chapter 267 is the Florida Historical Resources Act, and dunes cite § 161.053(2)(a) and § 161.242.
2 pages corrected

Englewood Beach: Charlotte County's code names metal detectors, and found property must be reported

What was wrong
The Englewood Beach page said no Charlotte County ordinance addressing metal detecting had been found, and cited 'Facility Rules (Ordinance 2016-027)', which appears nowhere in the county code or the county's park rules, with an unsourced 'removal and fine' penalty. It said modern lost items 'may generally be kept'. It cited § 161.053 as banning detecting and digging in the dunes with a 'civil fine', and the 2000-033 ordinance for dogs. The pin was about 2.5 miles away on the mainland, in Sarasota County, and the phone number (941) 743-1900 appears on no county page.
What it says now
Charlotte County Code § 1-11-51 (Ord. No. 2023-049): 'Except for sandy beaches, the use of metal detectors or other similar equipment is prohibited in/on county parks and recreation facilities, unless specifically authorized by the board by means of a special use permit.' The verdict stays 'allowed' on the sandy beach, now on that express provision; the rest of the park needs a special use permit. § 1-11-53 bars excavations on county parks without written permission, which the page now notes. Violations are punishable under § 1-1-8(b): up to $500, 60 days, or both. Lost property is governed by Fla. Stat. ch. 705 (§ 1-11-56): a finder must report it to a law enforcement officer (§ 705.102(1)), and keeping it is unlawful and counts as theft (§ 705.102(3)–(4)). Dunes now cite § 161.053(2)(a) and § 161.242, with the § 161.053(7) first-degree misdemeanor; dogs cite § 1-4-36. The pin is on the park, distances are straight-line, and the county phone is 941-743-1200.
1 page corrected

Petrified Forest National Park: invented "Petrified Forest Act" citation, penalty, Antiquities Act, shop wood and location

What was wrong
The Petrified Forest National Park page cited "16 U.S.C. § 1866(b), the Petrified Forest Act (1962)" as a law specifically banning petrified-wood collection, in the excerpt, a condition, the jurisdictions, the penalty row, an FAQ, the warning box and the sources; the petrified-wood material page repeated the "Petrified Forest Act" claim. It said fines run "up to $325". It cited the Antiquities Act as 16 U.S.C. §§ 431–433 and said it covers natural objects. Its ARPA row gave only two penalty tiers. It said gift-shop wood comes from BLM land or BLM land "under permit" and called BLM land near Holbrook a known collecting locality. It repeated a figure of 12 tons of wood stolen a year, said rangers check vehicles at park exits and that the park holds logs up to 200 feet long (also on the material page), said Congress passed the Act in 1962, and gave the elevation as 5,400 feet. It placed the page in Navajo County, listed Quartzsite (215 mi) and Vulture Mine (195 mi) as the nearest alternatives, and linked a guide slug that doesn't exist.
What it says now
16 U.S.C. § 1866 is a shark-feeding provision; no Petrified Forest statute bans collecting. The 1958 Petrified Forest National Park Act (Pub. L. 85-358, 72 Stat. 69; 16 U.S.C. §§ 119–119a), effective December 9, 1962, requires the park to be run under the general National Park System laws, so the ban rests on 36 CFR § 2.1(a)(1)(iii)–(iv). NPS sets a minimum fine of $325; the maximum under 36 CFR § 1.3 and 18 U.S.C. § 1865 is $5,000 and/or 6 months. The Antiquities Act is now 54 U.S.C. §§ 320301–320303, and its penalty (18 U.S.C. § 1866(b)) covers objects of antiquity, not natural objects. ARPA penalties now match the three tiers in 16 U.S.C. § 470ee(d). NPS says shop wood comes from private land outside the park; BLM free-use petrified wood can't be sold or bartered (43 CFR § 3622.4(a)(3)). The park says the 12-ton figure has no known origin; the vehicle-check, 200-foot and Holbrook-BLM claims had no source and were removed. NPS gives an average elevation of 5,800 feet. The pin is in Apache County; the nearest alternatives are now Black Hills Rockhound Area (153 mi) and Lynx Creek (154 mi), with Vulture Mine at 190 mi and Quartzsite at 271 mi. The related link now points to the BLM personal-use collecting guide. The verdict, prohibited, is unchanged.
2 pages corrected

Pensacola Beach: no SRIA shovel ban or 2-foot hole limit; national seashore boundary and penalties corrected

What was wrong
The page said Santa Rosa Island Authority rules ban metal shovels and holes deeper than 2 feet, with a penalty row for using a metal shovel. It placed the eastern Gulf Islands National Seashore boundary just beyond Portofino, said the seashore's detector ban had no exceptions, and gave its penalty as a fine with "equipment confiscation". It cited § 161.053 alone for dune vegetation, said SRIA was established by Escambia County, and dated NAS Pensacola to 1826. The map pin was in the Gulf, about 0.25 mi offshore.
What it says now
No SRIA page or Escambia County Code section bans metal shovels or limits hole depth; SRIA's own blog recommends a shovel for the beach. The county's beach rules (Escambia Code § 74-36) let lifeguards order a person to stop digging a hole that endangers anyone (§ 74-36(18)(e)(4)), with penalties of up to $500 and/or 60 days (§ 74-39), and SRIA asks visitors to fill holes for sea turtles. The seashore's Santa Rosa Area begins about 2 miles east of Portofino. 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) exempts a detector broken down and packed to prevent use; violations carry up to 6 months and a $5,000 fine (36 CFR 1.3; 18 U.S.C. § 1865). Dunes are covered by Fla. Stat. § 161.053(2)(a) (seaward of the coastal construction control line) and § 161.242 (sea oats and sea grapes). SRIA was created by the Florida Legislature in 1947 (Ch. 24500); the Navy Yard dates from 1826 and naval aviation from 1914. The page now states the § 705.102 lost-property rule, and the pin is on the beach at Casino Beach.
1 page corrected

Big Cypress: commercial harvest is prohibited, and the visitor-center details were wrong

What was wrong
The Big Cypress foraging page said commercial harvest of any preserve product needs a Special Use Permit from the superintendent. It listed a 'Big Cypress Visitor Center' at 33100 Tamiami Trail E, (239) 695-2000 (the headquarters address and phone), and the Oasis Visitor Center at 'milepost 50' with phone (239) 695-1201, which appears on no NPS page. It called Loop Road 27 miles long and named it and Turner River Road as persimmon and blueberry habitat without a source, omitted the October 1 to April 1 closure of the Birdon Road environmental education field-use areas, and said Fla. Stat. § 581.185 bans collecting all wild orchids, all Tillandsia, and carnivorous plants including Utricularia and Dionaea from any public land. It also listed unsourced Wilderness Study Area and restoration-area restrictions. The alternatives' distances were 175 and 340 miles.
What it says now
36 CFR 2.1(c)(3)(v) prohibits 'Sale or commercial use of natural products', and the compendium's list of activities that require a permit has no harvest permit, so the page now states the prohibition and the permit entry is gone. The Nathaniel P. Reed Visitor Center is at 33000 Tamiami Trail East (239-695-1168) and the Oasis Visitor Center at 52105 Tamiami Trail East; NPS says the Oasis phones are down and to call the Reed Visitor Center. Both are open 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. daily (compendium). NPS describes Loop Road as 24 miles through mostly cypress swamp; the unsourced habitat claims were removed, and the Birdon Road closure is now stated. FAC 5B-40.0055 lists specific species (many orchids, six Tillandsia species but not Spanish moss or ball moss, several pitcher plants and two sundews; no Utricularia or Dionaea), and § 581.185(3) requires the landowner's written permission, plus an FDACS permit for endangered plants, rather than banning collection outright; in the preserve, the ban on removing these plants comes from 36 CFR 2.1. The unsourced restrictions were replaced by the compendium's closure of Miccosukee and Seminole religious and ceremonial sites (¼ mile around designated sites), with tribal rights under 16 U.S.C. § 698j. Straight-line distances are 227.2 miles (Ocala NF) and 368.6 miles (Apalachicola NF). The verdict (berries, citrus and bananas allowed for personal consumption) is unchanged.
1 page corrected

Cleveland-Lloyd Dinosaur Quarry: legal basis of the closure, penalties and visiting details

What was wrong
The Cleveland-Lloyd page said the quarry's National Natural Landmark status was what closed it to invertebrate and plant fossil collecting, never mentioned Jurassic National Monument, and said BLM land surrounding the quarry was open to casual collecting. It cited 16 U.S.C. 470aaa-9 for fines of up to $100,000 and 2 years, and $250,000 and 5 years for trafficking. It called the site free, open Friday to Sunday from Memorial Day to Labor Day, with only a short unpaved road section, and described active excavation visitors could watch. It gave 16+ species and listed Barosaurus, Diplodocus, Brachiosaurus and Torvosaurus, said the quarry has more Allosaurus than all other sites combined and called the predator trap the leading hypothesis. The Utah fossil-hunting overview also attributed the closure to the landmark designation.
What it says now
BLM's Price Resource Management Plan (2008) closes the Cleveland-Lloyd Dinosaur Quarry recreation area, about 2,800 acres, to collecting natural products including fossils except by permit (REC-30, REC-37, ACEC-11), and 43 CFR 49.805(a) excludes land closed by a land use plan from casual collecting. The quarry is the core of Jurassic National Monument (P.L. 116-9, § 1252), where BLM may allow only uses that further the monument's purposes; the RMP manages the 80-acre landmark under the same rules. PRPA's penalties are in 16 U.S.C. 470aaa-5: a fine under Title 18 and up to 5 years in prison, or up to 2 years if the value plus repair costs is $500 or less. Entry costs $5 per person aged 16 and up; hours are Thursday to Sunday, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.; the last 11 to 13 miles of road are graded gravel. The quarry building has been closed for replacement since April 30, 2026. The quarry has yielded over 12,000 bones from at least 74 animals in at least nine genera; scientists have proposed several explanations for the Allosaurus concentration. The pin now sits at BLM's map marker, and distances to the alternatives are straight-line.
2 pages corrected

St. Augustine Beach: the county Beach Code governs the city beach, the historic city's rule and penalty, and the map

What was wrong
The St. Augustine Beach page said the beach was governed by the city's 'Chapter 5 (Beach, Pier and Waterway Use)' and didn't list the St. Johns County Beach Code. It said the historic City of St. Augustine bans detecting on all city-owned property 'without exception', with an unsourced penalty ('possible trespass or archaeological ordinance violation'), and that walking north from St. Augustine Beach toward the fort brings you into the historic city. It placed St. Augustine Beach 5 miles south of the historic city, and its pin was about 0.6 mile inland on a residential street. It said detecting at Fort Matanzas is 'absolutely prohibited' with 'equipment confiscation', described County Ordinance 2005-114 only as an archaeological-site rule, cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 alone for the dunes, and didn't mention the Beach Code's sand-removal ban, the city's Ocean Hammock Park digging ban, the county's nesting-season flashlight ban or Florida's lost-property law.
What it says now
City Code § 5-7(a) makes the St. Johns County Beach Code (Ord. 2007-19) apply on the city beach and control over the city code; neither code, nor the county's beach-rules page, mentions metal detecting or a permit, so the verdict stays 'allowed' with no permit. Beach Code § 3.12 bans removing beach sand. The historic city's Code § 6-7 bars using a probe or metal detector to search for artifacts on public property without written permission granted at the city's sole discretion, and its FAQ says it issues no permits; violations carry up to $500, 60 days, or both (§§ 6-14, 1-8). Walking north on the beach takes you into Anastasia State Park, where Florida State Parks policy limits detecting to the beach between the toe of the dune and the high-water line as designated by the park manager, never in the water. City Code § 5-35(f) bars digging in Ocean Hammock Park; County Parks Ordinance 2005-114 § 7(b) requires the Parks Director's written approval to dig on county park property (whether it covers sand at the county's Ocean Pier is unresolved). Fort Matanzas: 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) exempts a detector broken down and packed; violations are federal petty offenses under 36 CFR 1.3 and 18 U.S.C. § 1865 (up to $5,000, 6 months, or both). Dunes now cite § 161.053(2)(a) and § 161.242; the page adds the county's May 1 – Oct 31 flashlight ban and Fla. Stat. § 705.102. St. Augustine Beach is about 4 miles southeast of the historic district, the pin is on the beach by the pier, and Vilano Beach is 4.4 miles away.
1 page corrected

Vilano Beach: no source for a GTM Reserve detecting ban, the Conservation Zone, and the map

What was wrong
The Vilano Beach page said detecting is 'not permitted' in the Guana Tolomato Matanzas Research Reserve and that the reserve begins just north of the beach access at a marked boundary; no reserve rule or page says so, and the reserve's Guana visitor center is about 7.7 miles north-northwest. It said metal detecting is allowed 'under Ordinance 2007-19' (the Beach Code doesn't mention it), that 'all holes must be filled' under the county beach code (no such provision), and gave an unsourced county-ordinance penalty. It placed Vilano 3 to 5 miles north of the historic city, put the Guana River estuary directly north of the beach, called the St. Augustine Inlet the 'Matanzas Inlet', and its pin was about 1.4 miles west on the river side. It gave an FPAN phone number, (904) 209-5180, that FPAN doesn't list, cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 alone for the dunes, and didn't mention the Beach Code's Conservation Zone or sand-removal ban, the county Parks Ordinance digging rule, the nesting-season flashlight ban or Florida's lost-property law.
What it says now
The verdict stays 'allowed' with no permit: the St. Johns County Beach Code (Ord. 2007-19) and the county's beach-rules page have no detecting rule. The page now states the GTM Reserve's rules don't address detecting and tells readers to ask the reserve at (904) 380-8600. Beach Code § 7.01 bars all pedestrian activity in the Conservation Zone (15 feet seaward of the dune toe, 30 feet along Porpoise Point at the St. Augustine Inlet), and § 3.12 bans removing sand; violations are non-criminal citations with fines set by the county fee schedule (§§ 10.01–10.03). County Parks Ordinance 2005-114 § 7(b) requires the Parks Director's written approval to dig on county park property such as Vilano Beach Oceanfront Park (whether it covers sand inside the park is unresolved); LDC § 3.01.07.A.3 bars knowingly disturbing a Cultural Resource on county property, with penalties 'as allowed by Florida law' (§ 10.05.02). Hole-filling is now advice. Dunes cite § 161.053(2)(a) and § 161.242; the page adds the county's May 1 – Oct 31 flashlight ban and Fla. Stat. § 705.102. Vilano is about 2 miles northeast of the historic district, the pin is on the beach at the Oceanfront Park, St. Augustine Beach is 4.4 miles away, and FPAN's St. Augustine office is (904) 819-6476.
1 page corrected

Amelia Island: Nassau County bans digging in its beachfront parks, and beach driving is for residents only

What was wrong
The Amelia Island page said no Nassau County or Fernandina Beach ordinance affecting metal detecting had been found, and missed the county's ban on digging in county parks, including its beachfront parks. It said out-of-county visitors could drive on the beach with a $5/day or $25/year vehicle permit. It routed city and county questions to (904) 491-7333, a number on no county page, and applied the county's $100 dog fine to the city beach (the city's is $75). It cited § 161.053 alone as the dune-vegetation law, called the American Beach area a public Nassau County beach without mentioning the National Park Service's NaNa dune, and its eight-flags list named seven flags. The pin was inland on South 8th Street, about 1.9 miles from the beach, and the Vilano Beach distance was 65 miles.
What it says now
Nassau County Code § 23½-4(a)(2) bars anyone in a county park from digging or removing 'any soil, rock, sand', and county parks include 'beach front parks and parking areas' and contiguous county-controlled property (§ 23½-2(g)(6)); the penalty is up to $500, 60 days, or both (§ 23½-4(d)). The page now says so for Peters Point, Scott Road, Burney Park and the Southend and Summer Beach walkovers, and says that whether the ban reaches the beach in front of a park is unconfirmed (Nassau County Parks & Recreation, (904) 530-6120). The verdict stays 'allowed' for the open beach, where neither the county's beach article nor City Code Ch. 90 mentions detecting or digging. Beach driving on the unincorporated beach is limited to county residents and property owners (§ 23½-11(c), Ord. 2025-037); there is no visitor permit. City beach questions go to Fernandina Beach Ocean Rescue, (904) 310-3157; city and county dog, glass and fire rules are listed separately (§§ 90-40, 90-42, 90-45; §§ 23½-14, 23½-16, 23½-22). The NaNa dune is NPS land in Timucuan Preserve, where detectors are prohibited (36 CFR 2.1(a)(7)); Amelia Island State Park's Critical Wildlife Area status, the lost-property rule (§ 705.102) and the dune rules (§§ 161.053(2)(a), 161.242) were added. The flag list was removed, unsourced local claims were deleted, the pin is on the beach at Main Beach Park, and distances are straight-line (Vilano Beach 52.1 mi).
1 page corrected

Fernandina Beach City Parks: Central Park's location, a nonexistent 1975 ordinance, and the page's scope

What was wrong
The Fernandina Beach City Parks page described Central Park as 'a small historic square in the downtown district' in the core of the National Register Historic District. It cited a city '1975 Historic Preservation Ordinance' that appears in neither the city code nor the Land Development Code, placed the city's pre-1821 Spanish-period history downtown, called Chapter 267 the 'Archaeological and Property Act', and said the Egans Creek Greenway falls under Parks & Recreation and 'Florida wetland protection rules'. It also repeated beach and Fort Clinch rows that belong on the Amelia Island page.
What it says now
Central Park is an active sports park at 1200 Atlantic Avenue (tennis, pickleball and petanque courts, with Buccaneer Fields behind it). The historic districts are governed by Land Development Code Ch. 8 (Historic District Council design review), whose archaeological-discovery section (8.03.05) is reserved; on Environmentally Sensitive Lands, LDC 3.02.04.F requires anyone discovering an archaeological or historic site to notify the Planning and Conservation Department. The city places the original Spanish town (the 1811 plat) in Old Town, not downtown. Chapter 267 is the Florida Historical Resources Act (§ 267.011). The Greenway is a Planning & Conservation area whose posted rules say 'please stay on the trails at all times'. The verdict stays 'unclear': City Code Chs. 58, 65, 70 and 90 and LDC Chs. 3 and 8 have no rule on detecting or digging in parks. The page now covers inland city parks only and links to the Amelia Island page for the beaches and Fort Clinch.
1 page corrected

Garnet Hill: legal basis, map location, nearby mining claims and the permit for collecting for sale

What was wrong
The Garnet Hill page based collecting on 43 CFR 8365.1-5(b) alone, although that paragraph begins 'Except on developed recreation sites and areas' and Garnet Hill is a developed recreation area. Its map pin (39.2699, -114.9197) marked a different 'Garnet Hill' peak by Deuce Mine, about 2 miles from BLM's site and among 34 active lode claims. It did not mention the active claims mapped beside the recreation area. It said a 'mineral materials permit' was needed for 'anything beyond a reasonable personal-use amount', added an unsourced 'civil liability' penalty, said Nevada and BLM law allow open carry with 'no discharge near developed areas', said the garnets crystallized from the melt, in sizes up to 12-15 mm, and could be collected 'by the bucketful', and gave Quartzsite as 415 miles away. Rye Patch said the road needs 4WD after rain; Virgin Valley put Garnet Hill 310 miles away.
What it says now
Collecting rests on BLM's designation: BLM calls Garnet Hill 'the only designated rock hounding area in the Ely District', and its fact sheet says the 1,280-acre area 'was designated on December 22, 1970'; amounts are 'reasonable' with no published pound limit. The pin is now BLM's site marker (39.2851, -114.9512). The page names the seven active lode claims mapped on MLRS just west of the parking area and points to the MLRS Research Map. Collecting for sale or barter needs a BLM contract or permit (43 CFR 8365.1-5(c)); the penalty is 43 CFR 8360.0-7 only. Firearms: no discharge on developed recreation sites unless authorized (43 CFR 8365.2-5). Garnets occur as single crystals attached to small cavities in the rhyolite and most are not of perfect gem quality (BLM); collecting is described as BLM does (searching the surface and drainages, or careful rock breaking). The page notes BLM's 2023 recreation area plan and its campgrounds' 'potential fee use area' status; BLM still lists no fee. Quartzsite is ~390 mi straight-line. Rye Patch now says BLM rates the road suitable for sedans; Virgin Valley gives ~277 mi. The verdict stays 'allowed'.
3 pages corrected

Galveston Island State Park: the detector rule, its permit clause, the beach managers and the map pin

What was wrong
The Galveston Island State Park page said 31 TAC § 59.134 bans detecting by prohibiting the collection or disturbance of 'any natural feature, cultural resource, or historical item' without written authorization, titled the source 'Natural and Cultural Resources', and said there were 'no exceptions, no permit pathway' and that authorizations go only to research or educational institutions. It called East Beach / R.A. Apffel Park a Galveston County park, put Stewart Beach at 201 Seawall Blvd and East Beach at 1923 Boddeker Rd, said the Seawall had free access with no fees, gave the penalty as 'fine up to $500', said state park rules 'supersede' Open Beaches Act rights, and placed the map pin in Jamaica Beach, about 1.4 miles west of the park.
What it says now
The detector rule is its own subsection, 31 TAC § 59.134(i) ('Rules of Conduct in Parks'): 'It is an offense for any person to operate or use a metal detector, except as authorized by permit.' TPWD publishes no recreational detecting permit, so the verdict stays 'prohibited'; the page tells anyone who lost an item to ask the park office. Disturbing rocks, soil, minerals or fossils needs the director's permit and disturbing historic resources or artifacts the director's written order (§ 59.134(l)(2)–(3)). The penalty is a Class C Parks and Wildlife Code misdemeanor, $25–$500 (§§ 13.112, 12.406). The Open Beaches Act (§ 61.011) protects access and is now stated without the supersession claim. Stewart Beach (401 Seawall Blvd) and East Beach / R.A. Apffel Park (1929 Boddeker Rd) are city-owned and managed by the Galveston Park Board (City Code § 26-54(a)(1), (5)); since May 1, 2026 both charge $15 per vehicle to park, and most Seawall parking is paid. The pin is now inside the park (29.2019, -94.9676) and the alternative is 14.1 miles away.
1 page corrected

Galveston Public Beaches: an invented hole-filling ordinance, the beach manager, and Florida turtle rules

What was wrong
The Galveston Public Beaches page said City of Galveston beach ordinances require beach users to leave no holes open, called East Beach / R.A. Apffel Park a Galveston County park (with county and 'Parks Department' phone numbers), gave old addresses and fees ('typically $10–15', a pedestrian fee, free Seawall access points between 6th and 61st Streets), said the Antiquities Code covers 'the public beach easement' and that 'post-1960s' finds are not covered, said lead sinkers are 'legally permitted to collect', banned collecting near lifeguard stations and swimming zones without a code basis, and gave sea turtle rules borrowed from Florida (a May–September season, flagged nests, TPWD monitoring). The map pin sat on the Pleasure Pier.
What it says now
No city code section requires filling holes; § 8-27 is about personal property left on the beach overnight, so hole-filling is now advice. Stewart Beach and East Beach / R.A. Apffel Park are city-owned and managed by the Galveston Park Board (City Code § 26-54(a)(1), (5); 409-797-5000). Since May 1, 2026 parking there is $15 per vehicle per entry; Seawall parking is $2 an hour except listed free stretches. The Antiquities Code covers state tidelands (§ 191.091) and city-owned land (§ 191.092), not the easement over private sand, and has no age cut-off. The finds note now says Texas has no general finder statute but keeping someone's property can be theft (Penal Code § 31.03). Lifeguards may restrict beach activities when conditions are dangerous (§ 8-1(c)). Turtles: USFWS asks beachgoers to report nesting turtles and nests March–September to 1-866-TURTLE-5; the Park Board's rules say not to disturb turtle nests; the penalty cites Parks and Wildlife Code ch. 68 and 16 U.S.C. § 1540. The verdict stays 'allowed'. The pin is now on Stewart Beach.
1 page corrected

Succor Creek: the state park's collecting cap, digging permission, penalty citations and location

What was wrong
The Succor Creek page said personal-use collecting inside the state natural area was allowed with no limit, and that shallow hand-tool digging was fine there. It cited ORS 390.121 (the parks commission's powers) and "43 CFR Part 3600" as the penalty law for commercial collecting, with a possible "permit ban", and called removing archaeological objects a "Class A misdemeanor to felony" under ORS 358.905 (a definitions section). The map pin was about 31 miles south of the park, near Jordan Valley, so nearby-site distances were wrong (Quartzsite 700 mi; Glass Buttes 195 mi). It said water was available at the campground, gave directions south of US-95, an unconfirmed Oregon Parks phone number and the wrong BLM Vale hours, and listed obsidian nodules and BLM-ridgeline collecting with no source.
What it says now
Oregon Parks and Recreation allows "limited souvenir collecting by rock hounds" in the park: up to 1 gallon per person per day and no more than 3 gallons per person per year (OAR 736-010-0055(3)). Digging up or removing rock beyond that needs written permission from park staff (OAR 736-010-0055(2)(a)); collecting for sale needs written permission on state land and a BLM contract or permit on BLM land (43 CFR 8365.1-5(c)). Park violations that disturb or damage park resources are Class A violations (OAR 736-010-0022(3)), with a fine of up to $2,000 and no jail term (ORS 153.018). BLM violations carry up to $1,000 and/or 12 months (43 CFR 8360.0-7). Removing archaeological objects is a Class B misdemeanor under ORS 358.920(8); in the park it needs an ORS 390.235 permit (OAR 736-010-0055(1)), and on BLM land ARPA and 43 CFR 8365.1-5(a)(1) apply. The pin is at the park (43.4538, -117.1202); distances are straight-line (Quartzsite 694.1 mi, Glass Buttes 147.1 mi). The park has no water; it is reached by a rough 15-mile dirt road from Oregon 201; Oregon Parks' number is 800-551-6949 and BLM Vale's hours are 8:00am-4:30pm. Unsourced obsidian, ridgeline and quality claims were removed, and the thunder-egg material page and the Oregon overview now give the park's cap.
3 pages corrected

Glass Buttes: fire obsidian is on private ground, and the leftover ARPA penalty line

What was wrong
The Glass Buttes page said rare fire obsidian lies on the open BLM surface on "East Butte" and that taking a few pieces is legal. Its warning box still gave the first-offense ARPA penalty as up to $20,000 and 2 years, and a restriction called the penalties "federal felony level", after the 2026-10-05 correction fixed other lines. It said the site was quarried for 10,000 years with obsidian traced to California, Nevada, Washington and Idaho; stated an unsourced "no digging" rule and a "designated roads" travel plan; gave a "Glass Buttes Road (County CR-5E)" route that turned south from Bend and north from Burns; set the commercial permit as not required while saying it was; and cited a bare USGS homepage. The obsidian material page placed Glass Buttes in BLM's Burns District.
What it says now
GIA's Gems & Gemology (Summer 2023) says fire obsidian "has been found in only one site within the Glass Buttes region", and the miner it profiles worked it on private property; the page no longer places it on BLM land, and "East Butte" (a name no source uses) is gone. A first ARPA offense carries up to $10,000 and/or 1 year, rising to $20,000 and/or 2 years only where value plus restoration and repair costs exceed $500 (16 U.S.C. § 470ee(d)); surface arrowheads are outside ARPA's penalties (§ 470ee(g)) but BLM's own ban still applies (43 CFR 8365.1-5(a)(1); up to $1,000 and/or 12 months, 43 CFR 8360.0-7). Glass Buttes has been a toolstone source for at least 14,000 years, and its obsidian has been traced from the northern California coast through Oregon and southern Washington to southwest British Columbia (Stueber & Skinner 2015). Digging into an archaeological site is an ARPA violation; BLM's guide limits excavations to four feet. Off-road vehicle penalties are under 43 CFR 8340.0-7. Directions are general, with straight-line distances; a mining-claim (MLRS) check was added; the commercial permit is marked required (43 CFR 8365.1-5(c)). Glass Buttes is in BLM's Prineville District.
5 pages corrected

Willamette National Forest: truffles prohibited, no free matsutake, permit tiers, riparian and fire-closure bans

What was wrong
The Willamette National Forest foraging page said truffles (Oregon white and black) could be collected under the standard personal-use rules and gave tips for finding them. It said 1 gallon a day of mushrooms and berries was free under 'Willamette Ranger District policy' with no exception for matsutake, and that anything above that or for sale needed a free commercial permit. It recommended riparian areas for morels and fiddleheads, listed Boulder Creek among Willamette's wildernesses, cited 36 CFR 261.57 for harvesting in wilderness, put the alternative Mt. Hood page 65 miles away, and repeated unsourced details (a 1-gallon berry limit, a 100-foot archaeological buffer, and the forest's extent from Santiam Pass to Crater Lake).
What it says now
Truffle harvesting is prohibited on the Willamette (four-forest mushroom rules for the Umpqua and Willamette). Free personal-use collection of matsutake is not allowed on any of the four participating forests, so matsutake needs a matsutake permit ($8 a day with a 3-day minimum, $100 half season, $200 full season). Other mushrooms: under one gallon a day needs no permit and must be cut in half at harvest; a Free Use permit (no fee) allows 2 gallons a day on any 10 days a year; a Commercial/Personal Use permit costs $2 a day with a $20 minimum, or $100 a year. Mushroom picking is not allowed in riparian areas (streams, ponds, wetlands) or inside fire closures. The forest's eight wildernesses are Diamond Peak, Menagerie, Middle Santiam, Mt. Jefferson, Mt. Washington, Opal Creek, Three Sisters and Waldo Lake (Boulder Creek is on the Umpqua); gathering there is allowed only for on-site use, and the citation is 36 CFR 261.6(h) with penalties under 36 CFR 261.1b and 18 U.S.C. 3571. Willamette publishes no berry limit, and the page now says to ask the district. The Mt. Hood alternative is 74.8 miles pin to pin.
2 pages corrected

Mount Hood National Forest: yearly caps, no commercial berry permit, road-corridor closures, eight wildernesses, pin moved

What was wrong
The Mount Hood National Forest foraging page gave a flat 1 gallon a day for mushrooms, berries and greens with no yearly cap, said berries above that or for sale needed a free commercial permit, and listed five wildernesses. It recommended the Lolo Pass, Ramona Falls and Highway 26 areas, didn't mention the truffle ban, cited 36 CFR 261.57 for harvesting in wilderness, named a 'Multnomah Falls RNA', gave only two of the four ranger districts, and placed the map pin 0.2 miles from the summit inside the Mount Hood Wilderness.
What it says now
Incidental use (no permit) is limited per person to mushrooms 1 gallon a day and 10 gallons a year, berries 1 gallon a day and 3 gallons a year, and greenery and cuttings 20 pounds a year, for personal use only. Mt. Hood offers no commercial berry permit, and selling or bartering berries from the forest is illegal. Truffle hunting or harvest is prohibited. Harvest is prohibited in all eight wildernesses (Mount Hood, Badger Creek, Bull of the Woods, Clackamas, Lower White River, Mark O. Hatfield, Roaring River, Salmon-Huckleberry), the Tilly Jane Proposed Wilderness, the Camp Baldwin area, recreation sites, riparian areas and municipal watersheds, and along Highways 26, 35, 216 and 224 and Forest Roads 18 (Lolo Pass), 42, 50 and 2645; the page no longer recommends those corridors. The citation is 36 CFR 261.6(h) with penalties under 36 CFR 261.1b and 18 U.S.C. 3571. All four districts are listed (Zigzag, Clackamas River, Hood River, Barlow), and the pin now marks the Zigzag Ranger Station (45.3429, -121.9418), outside wilderness.
2 pages corrected

Oregon national forests: commercial foraging permits are not free

What was wrong
The Oregon foraging overview, the USFS personal-use foraging Guide's Oregon rows, and the Willamette, Mount Hood, Deschutes, Umpqua, Siuslaw and Rogue River-Siskiyou pages said commercial (or above-limit) foraging permits were free.
What it says now
Deschutes, Umpqua and Willamette (with Fremont-Winema) share a mushroom program: a Commercial/Personal Use permit costs $2 a day with a 10-day ($20) minimum, or $100 a year, and a matsutake permit $8 a day with a 3-day ($24) minimum, $100 half season or $200 full season; only the Free Use permit (2 gallons a day, 10 days a year, personal use) is free. Mount Hood charges $1 a gallon for commercial mushroom permits ($4 a gallon including matsutake), with a $20 minimum, and offers no commercial berry permit. Siuslaw's commercial mushroom permit costs $20 for 10 days, $40 for 30 days or $100 a year, and its commercial matsutake permit $200 (2026). Rogue River-Siskiyou sets its fees in its Product Price List; the page now says to ask the district for the current cost.
8 pages corrected

Honeymoon Island: park phone, pet beach, ferry dock, park history, fees and distances

What was wrong
The Honeymoon Island page gave the park phone as (727) 469-5942, put the pet beach at the north end with a $2 per pet fee, and said the Caladesi ferry leaves from the park's north beach. It said the park is named for its osprey population and became a state park in 1982. It listed the Dunedin Causeway corridor as off-limits under Florida State Parks policy and named Pinellas County as governing it. It said Clearwater Beach had no restriction or fee, without the city's permit requirement, and put Caladesi Island 1.0 mi, Clearwater Beach 6.0 mi and Fort De Soto 20 mi away. It told readers to check an FWC turtle nest map that doesn't exist, left out the extra-passenger and sunset fees, the seasonal shorebird nesting closures and the April 2024 cut across the north sandspit, and its map pin was in the Gulf.
What it says now
The park phone is 727-241-6106. The pet beach is on the southern tip of the island, and leashed dogs are also allowed on the nature trail; Florida State Parks lists no pet fee. The ferry leaves from the ferry dock on the bay side near the park entrance, by the ferry ticket office. The island got its name in 1939 from the honeymoon-cottage development (first honeymooners May 8, 1940); Honeymoon Island State Recreation Area was created on Dec. 7, 1981. The causeway is outside the park, so park policy doesn't govern it, and the county attribution was removed. The City of Clearwater requires a metal detector permit. Distances are now straight-line: Caladesi Island 3.2 mi, Clearwater Beach 7.2 mi, Fort De Soto about 33 mi. Entry fees add $2 per extra passenger and a $4 per vehicle sunset fee from one hour before closing. Portions of the beach may be closed for shorebird nesting, and since April 9, 2024 a temporary cut separates the northernmost mile of the sandspit; the park says not to venture into or through the water. The pin was moved onto the beach. The verdict (allowed in designated beach areas, no permit) stands.
1 page corrected

Hell Creek: PRPA criminal penalties need a knowing violation; private land, Corps land, geology and map pin corrected

What was wrong
The Hell Creek page said PRPA's penalty applies to unknowing removal the same as deliberate theft, and that entering Montana private land without written permission is criminal trespass. It pointed collectors to the Bearpaw Shale "directly below" the Hell Creek Formation, cropping out "throughout the region", as the main legal target, said vertebrate research permits come from the Miles City Field Office, go only to institution-affiliated paleontologists and cover commercial collecting, and listed Petroleum County as Miles City Field Office land. It didn't mention the Corps of Engineers land around Fort Peck Reservoir, including the Hell Creek Recreation Area. Its map pin sat on private land in Jordan, and the distances to San Rafael Swell (750 mi) and Miles City (120 mi) were wrong, as were the distances to Hell Creek on the Judith River (190), Badlands (400) and Como Bluff (600) pages.
What it says now
PRPA's criminal penalties (fines and up to 5 years, or 2 years at $500 or less) apply to anyone who knowingly violates it (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-5(c); 43 CFR 49.400(a)); a mistaken removal is still a prohibited act that can bring civil penalties (§ 470aaa-6) and forfeiture (§ 470aaa-7). Montana law requires no written permission: privilege to enter comes from the owner's explicit permission or the owner's failure to post, and posted land is closed without explicit permission (Mont. Code Ann. § 45-6-201); fossils belong to the surface owner (§ 1-4-112). The Bearpaw Shale is overlain by the Fox Hills Sandstone and then the Hell Creek Formation, and near Hell Creek it crops out mainly along the Fort Peck Reservoir shoreline (USGS Water-Supply Paper 1999-F), much of it Charles M. Russell NWR land, where removing fossils and petrified wood is prohibited, or Corps of Engineers land. The Hell Creek Recreation Area is Corps land operated by the Little Shell Chippewa Tribe; PRPA doesn't cover Corps land, where removing paleontological resources needs the District Commander's written permission (36 CFR 327.14(a)), with a fine of up to $5,000 and/or 6 months (36 CFR 327.25(a)). Permits go to the bureau managing the land (43 CFR 49.115), require a relevant degree or demonstrated training and experience (43 CFR 49.110), and are issued only for research or public education (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-3); none allows commercial collecting. Petroleum County was removed. The pin now marks BLM land on Hell Creek about 17 miles north of Jordan (T21N R37E sec. 20). Distances: San Rafael Swell 632 mi, Miles City about 80 mi straight-line, Judith River 123, Badlands 359, Como Bluff 409 (pin to pin). The PRPA guide now states that criminal penalties require a knowing violation (43 CFR 49.400), and the Badlands and Como Bluff notes no longer send readers to Hell Creek for Bearpaw ammonites.
5 pages corrected

Hampton Butte is a petrified-wood site: limit, location and county corrected

What was wrong
The Hampton Butte page described a picture- and dendritic-jasper site with thunder eggs and chalcedony in "decomposed rhyolite", and applied BLM Oregon/Washington's car-trunk, under-250-lb standard as the limit. No source describes Hampton Butte as a picture-jasper, thunder-egg or chalcedony locality. Its map pin sat on private land in Deschutes County; it gave Bend and Burns as ~75 and ~60 miles away, Glass Buttes as ~50 miles east, Garnet Hill as ~250 miles south, and marked winter as "closed". It still carried the old first-offense ARPA penalty (up to $20,000 and 2 years), cited a travel plan and 43 CFR 8341.1 with a "citation" for off-road penalties, marked the commercial permit as not required while saying it was, and named a "Prineville Field Office". The jasper and thunder-egg material pages listed Hampton Butte (as the headline picture-jasper site), the Oregon overview called it a picture-jasper site, and the Spectrum Sunstone page labelled it "(jasper)".
What it says now
DOGAMI's Ore Bin (1961) says the silicified wood in the Hampton Butte area "is frequently colored in green or carnelian shades and therefore is highly prized by hobbyists", and BLM's Prineville District listed the site as "Hampton Butte (Petrified Wood)". The page is now about petrified wood, and the limit is 43 CFR 3622.4: 25 lb plus one piece per person per day, no more than 250 lb a year, no pooling, no power equipment, and no sale or barter to commercial dealers (BLM Oregon/Washington's guide repeats the limits). The pin moved about 9.5 miles north-northeast to BLM land in Crook County (BLM surface management map), at the location commonly given for the site and consistent with BLM's archived directions; the page says roads may cross private land and that the section DOGAMI named in 1961 is private today. Straight-line distances were recomputed from pins (Bend about 55 mi, Burns about 63, Glass Buttes about 22). Geology follows DOGAMI: a Clarno Formation locality with a flora closer to the John Day flora, middle to upper Oligocene. ARPA penalty tiers follow 16 U.S.C. § 470ee(d), off-road penalties 43 CFR 8340.0-7, the commercial permit is marked required (43 CFR 8365.1-5(c)), and the office is BLM's Prineville District Office. Hampton Butte was removed from the jasper and thunder-egg pages and added to the petrified-wood page.
6 pages corrected

Deschutes National Forest: any mushroom picking needs a permit; five wildernesses closed to picking; closures, penalties and pin corrected

What was wrong
The Deschutes National Forest foraging page gave the verdict 'allowed' and said mushrooms, berries and common edible plants could be picked without a permit up to 1 gallon a day, with matsutake not excepted. It listed six wildernesses (including Waldo Lake and Drift Creek, which are on other forests, and omitting Mt. Thielsen) and said personal foraging was allowed in them. It omitted Newberry National Volcanic Monument, Pringle Falls Experimental Forest and the other areas closed to picking, still described commercial permits as 'free' in one box, gave Bend-Fort Rock Ranger District's phone as (541) 383-4000 and left out Crescent Ranger District, cited 36 CFR 261.13 and the Wilderness Act for wilderness vehicle use with 'confiscation' and 'suspension of permit privileges' as penalties, presented camas and yampa as foraging opportunities, placed the map pin on the Sunriver Airport apron (private land outside the forest), and gave Willamette as 45 miles and Mt. Hood as 120 miles away.
What it says now
Verdict changed from allowed to permit-required. Deschutes says 'A valid permit is required for both free use and commercial/personal use collection of general mushroom species': the Free Use permit is free and allows 2 gallons a day on any 10 days per calendar year (all species except matsutake); pickers must be 18 or older, carry the permit and a harvest area map, and cut each mushroom in half lengthwise at harvest. The Commercial/Personal Use permit costs $2 a day ($20 minimum) or $100 a year; matsutake always need a matsutake permit ($8 a day, $24 minimum; $100 half season; $200 full season), there is no free matsutake picking, and matsutake harvest isn't allowed on the Sisters Ranger District. Deschutes publishes no berry limit or permit; the page now says to ask a district. The five wildernesses are Mt. Jefferson, Mt. Washington, Three Sisters, Diamond Peak and Mt. Thielsen; the harvest maps close them to mushroom picking and the forest allows gathering there only for personal on-site use. Newberry National Volcanic Monument, Pringle Falls Experimental Forest, research natural areas, late-successional reserves, developed recreation areas, campgrounds, the Oregon Cascades Recreation Area and other posted areas are closed to picking. Bend-Fort Rock is 541-383-5300 and Crescent (matsutake) 541-433-3200. Penalties are 36 CFR 261.6(h), 261.9(d) and 261.18 with 36 CFR 261.1b and 18 U.S.C. 3571 (up to $5,000 and 6 months). The forest's native-plant rules prohibit camas and other lilies, and yampa isn't on its collection list. The pin now marks Wanoga Sno-Park on national forest land (43.9842, -121.5439); Willamette is 32.8 miles and Mt. Hood 95.9 miles away in a straight line. The Umpqua/Willamette-only truffle ban and riparian closure do not apply to Deschutes.
3 pages corrected

Osceola National Forest foraging: ranger district, federal penalty, listed plants, size and distances

What was wrong
The Osceola National Forest foraging page named the "Lake City Ranger District" in six places. It gave the federal penalty for "exceeding personal-use limits" or unpermitted commercial collecting as a fine of up to $500, though no personal-use limit is published. It said all carnivorous plants (pitcher plants, sundews, bladderworts) and all state-listed plants may not be collected under "Florida Endangered and Threatened Species rules" and USFS policy, with "significant fines", and cited the FWC threatened-species page, which covers animals. It gave the forest 200,000 acres and Columbia County alone, linked a retired fs.usda.gov/osceola page, said commercial fees are "based on quantity and location", and put Apalachicola National Forest 95 miles and Ocala 70 miles away. The Apalachicola page put Osceola about 110 miles away and repeated the fee wording.
What it says now
The office is the Osceola Ranger District, 24874 US Highway 90, Olustee (386-752-2577). A violation of 36 CFR 261.6(h) is punishable by up to six months in prison and/or a fine under 18 U.S.C. 3571, up to $5,000 for an individual (36 CFR 261.1b). Several pitcher plants, sundews and butterworts are state-listed, not all, and bladderworts are not on the Regulated Plant Index (FAC 5B-40.0055); harvesting a listed plant on public land needs the landowner's written permission, plus an FDACS permit for endangered species (Fla. Stat. § 581.185(3)), and a violation is a first-degree misdemeanor (§ 581.211). None of them is edible material, so the personal-use allowance doesn't cover them. The forest has about 160,040 acres of National Forest System land, split almost evenly between Baker and Columbia counties. The current National Forests in Florida pages don't publish commercial fees, so both pages now say to ask the district. Straight-line distances are about 144 miles to Apalachicola and 82 miles to Ocala. The page now also notes Big Gum Swamp Wilderness (no commercial harvest; listed as temporarily closed), the plant-removal ban in Olustee Battlefield Historic State Park (FAC 62D-2.013(4)(b)) and the Osceola Wildlife Management Area rules (FAC 68A-15.004(12)(a), 68A-15.062(5)).
2 pages corrected

Bradenton Beach: county and city codes bar digging beach sand; verdict changed from allowed to unclear

What was wrong
The page said metal detecting was allowed with no permit and that no city or county ban had been found. It described Coquina as the only county-managed section, put the pin on the mainland in Cortez, placed the Holmes Beach line near the 4500 block of Gulf Drive, showed Holmes Beach as "allowed", said sand scoops were permitted, gave the dune penalty as up to $10,000 a day under § 161.053, and listed Clearwater Beach as 20 miles away.
What it says now
The verdict is now unclear, with no permit program. Cortez Beach (South 3rd to South 13th Street) and Coquina Beach (South 13th Street to the city limit) are Manatee County parks, where County Code § 2-24-3(1)(b) bars digging or displacing beach sand without a permit from the parks director, and § 2-24-3(1)(c) bars metal hardware-store shovels and holes deeper than one foot on the sandy Gulf beach (up to $500 and 60 days, § 2-24-56). City Code § 46-36 bars digging, removing or displacing beach sand in city parks, which include city beaches. Neither code mentions detecting. The Bradenton Area CVB's statement on VISIT FLORIDA (the ordinances "rule out metal-detecting" but Parks and Recreation "generally overlook" it) is reported as the bureau's account, not law. The pin is now on the Gulf beach (27.4665, -82.6995); the Holmes Beach line is about 2.5 miles north of Coquina with Holmes Beach's own sand-removal and hole rules (§ 66-26); the dune penalty is a first-degree misdemeanor (§ 161.053(7)) and a DEP fine up to $15,000 per offense (§ 161.054), with §§ 161.053(2)(a) and 161.242 cited for the dune rules; Clearwater is 36.2 miles and Siesta Key 16.6 miles straight-line. Unsourced claims (sand scoops permitted, the 1958 causeway, the Coquina find-concentration tip) were removed, and the § 705.102 lost-property rule and 2026 dredging and renourishment were added.
1 page corrected

Longboat Key: the beach is public along the whole island; trespass, county line, hours and Town rules corrected

What was wrong
The page said most of Longboat Key's Gulf beach was private resort or condominium frontage reachable only by about 12 recorded easements, that detecting on that frontage was trespass under Fla. Stat. § 810.08, that the county line was near Longboat Club Road, that detecting after sunset was not permitted, that the island was 12 miles long, and that the dune penalty was up to $10,000 a day under § 161.053. It said no county code applied and cited no Town rule.
What it says now
The Town of Longboat Key says "Longboat Key beaches on the seaward side of the erosion control line (ECL) extend along the length of the island and are available for public use", and land seaward of an ECL is state land (§ 161.191(1)); the private-frontage premise and the § 810.08 row (a statute on structures and conveyances) were removed. The verdict stays allowed with no permit. The county line is at the 4000 block of Gulf of Mexico Drive (Town); the beach and accesses are closed 11 p.m. to 5 a.m. (Town Code § 92.02(B)); the Town bars taking or disturbing plants or animals (§ 92.05(D)) and abandoning deep holes (§ 100.09(C)); the island is about 10 miles long; the dune penalty is a first-degree misdemeanor (§ 161.053(7)) and a DEP fine up to $15,000 per offense (§ 161.054). The page now says it is unresolved whether Sarasota County § 90-33(a)(16) reaches Town beaches on the Sarasota side (§ 90-39). The county field now matches the pin (Manatee), alternative distances are straight-line, the § 705.102 lost-property rule was added, and unsourced claims about find values and resort development were removed.
1 page corrected

Siuslaw National Forest: four wildernesses and scenic areas closed to permit harvest; berries need a permit; matsutake permit terms, penalties and pin corrected

What was wrong
The Siuslaw National Forest foraging page said the forest has no designated wilderness and that every part of it is open to picking, and it never mentioned the scenic areas, research natural areas and botanical areas where harvest is prohibited. It said berries and other edible plants could be picked without a permit or fee under the same 1-gallon rule as mushrooms. It described 36 CFR 261.6(f) as a 'commercial permit requirement', gave the penalty for picking over the limit as a $5,000 fine with confiscation, gave ESA penalties as fixed dollar figures, said the commercial mushroom permit allows unlimited quantities without saying it covers only listed species, and recommended raking for truffles. It omitted that 2026 commercial matsutake permits are sold in person, run through December 31 and allow picking only in the Oregon Dunes NRA and Central Coast Ranger District. It named the Mapleton Ranger District (which no longer exists) and gave no district phone numbers, omitted the snowy plover dry-sand closures in the Oregon Dunes NRA, placed the map pin on a residential road north of Florence that is not national forest land, and gave Willamette as 45 miles and Mt. Hood as 110 miles away. The Oregon foraging overview said every Oregon national forest on the site, including the Deschutes, allows picking under one gallon of mushrooms a day without a permit.
What it says now
The verdict stays allowed for mushrooms: Siuslaw needs no permit for one gallon or less a day of any kind except matsutake, and for up to 6 matsutake a day per person, each cut in half lengthwise immediately after picking. Siuslaw has four wildernesses (Cummins Creek, Devil's Staircase, Drift Creek and Rock Creek), and its permit pages say 'Harvesting is prohibited in Botanical Areas, Research Natural Areas, wilderness areas, scenic areas, and land other than designated on the map received with your permit' (Cape Perpetua Scenic Area and Cascade Head National Scenic-Research Area are on the forest); the page notes this is worded for permit holders and tells readers to ask a district about personal picking there. Berries need Siuslaw's berry permit (10 cents a pound, supplemental request form, not available on the Hebo Ranger District, gathering at least 200 feet from recreation sites and streams); the forest publishes no permit-free amount. Selling personal-use mushrooms is cited as 36 CFR 261.6(f) as the forest cites it; picking beyond the no-permit amounts is 36 CFR 261.6(h), with penalties under 36 CFR 261.1b and 18 U.S.C. 3571 (up to $5,000 and 6 months); ESA penalties are under 16 U.S.C. 1540. The commercial mushroom permit ($20 for 10 days, $40 for 30 days, $100 a year) covers only the listed species. The 2026 commercial matsutake permit costs $200, is sold in person (Reedsport from Sept. 8, then Reedsport and Waldport), is valid through Dec. 31, 2026, allows picking only in the Oregon Dunes NRA and Central Coast Ranger District, and the forest asks pickers not to dig or rake. Truffle raking advice was removed. The districts are Hebo ((503) 392-5100) and Central Coast (Waldport (541) 563-8400; Oregon Dunes NRA, Reedsport (541) 271-6000). Forest Order 06-12-04-25-02 closes the snowy plover dry-sand areas from March 15 to September 15. The pin now marks national forest land on Forest Service Road 2610-721, Lane County (44.05, -123.9806); Willamette is 95.6 miles, Mt. Hood 134.2 miles and Deschutes 121.2 miles away in a straight line. The Oregon overview now says the Deschutes requires a permit for any mushroom picking.
4 pages corrected

Fakahatchee Strand: interior access is not tour-only; Big Cypress alternative limited to berries, citrus and bananas; park facts corrected

What was wrong
The page said ranger-led wet-walk tours were the only authorized way to reach the interior strand, and told readers that Big Cypress National Preserve allows personal-use foraging of non-protected species. It quoted FAC 62D-2.013(4)(b) without its "except as provided herein" qualifier, gave the park phone as (239) 695-4593 and an unverified DEP law-enforcement number, called Janes Scenic Drive a 20-mile road that may close and needs four-wheel drive, put the ghost orchid bloom at July–August on cypress trunks, called the preserve the most documented US ghost orchid population and the world's largest native royal palm stand, gave about 85,000 acres, and placed the pin about 3.8 miles inside the preserve on the West Main Tram.
What it says now
Tours are run by the Friends of Fakahatchee, and the old logging trams serve as trails open to all visitors. Big Cypress's compendium designates only berries, citrus fruits and bananas, picked by hand for personal consumption; mushrooms, nuts and palmetto berries are prohibited there. The rule is now quoted in full ("No person shall transplant or remove any plant life from any park, except as provided herein"); its only provision is the Division's invasive-exotic control, so the prohibited verdict stands. The park phone is 239-961-1925. Janes Memorial Scenic Drive runs about 11 miles from the ranger station to Picayune Strand State Forest, about 6 open to vehicles. Ghost orchids flower May to August, mainly on Florida water ash and pond apple; the preserve has one of three main US populations (230 ± 50 plants, USFWS), and the species is endangered in Florida and proposed endangered federally. The preserve has the largest native royal palm population in the United States and covers about 80,180 acres. The pin now marks the start of Janes Memorial Scenic Drive at State Road 29; alternative distances are straight-line. The § 258.008(1) noncriminal infraction and neighbouring state forest (FAC 5I-4.005) and refuge (50 CFR 27.51) rules were added; unsourced wildlife-timing and road-closure claims were removed.
1 page corrected

Flagler Beach: verdict changed from allowed to unclear; county and city codes ban digging beach sand

What was wrong
The page said metal detecting was allowed at Flagler Beach with no permit and that no Flagler County ordinance applied, and that the ocean beach strand of Gamble Rogers Memorial State Recreation Area was open. It cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 alone for dunes, said modern finds were "yours to keep", gave the start of nesting season as March 1 in the seasonal guide, gave a $5 vehicle fee as the only Gamble Rogers fee, said the pier was first built in 1925 and gave pier-fishing advice, said the Florida East Coast Railway reached Flagler Beach in the 1890s, called Beverly Beach unincorporated, said the comparison table was verified with county parks offices, put the county line about 3 miles south, gave St. Augustine Beach as 35 miles away, and placed the pin on a house about 0.4 mile inland.
What it says now
Neither code mentions metal detectors and no permit exists, but Flagler County Code § 7-1(c)(1) says "any activities or uses prohibited in public beachfront parks are also prohibited in the dry sand beach", and § 23-2(2) bars anyone in a park to "dig or remove any soil, rock, sand" or "make any excavation by tool"; City Code § 6-73(2) has the same ban for city parks and recreation areas, whose rules also govern the beach. The verdict is now unclear, with no permit; readers are told to ask the City of Flagler Beach (386-517-2000) or Flagler County Parks & Recreation (386-313-4020), and the page notes that VISIT FLORIDA's "no restrictions" quote is a tourism council's statement that conflicts with the codes. Penalties: County §§ 23-7, 1-6 (up to $500 and 60 days) and City § 6-78 (warning, $100, $150, then up to $500 or a trespass notice). Customary use of privately owned dry sand excludes detecting and night access (County § 7-1(c); City § 6-11(c)). Gamble Rogers allows detecting only in beach areas the park manager designates between the toe of the dune and the high-water line, and charges $2 for pedestrians and cyclists. Dunes now cite §§ 161.242 and 161.053(2)(a) and City Code § 6-9; § 705.102 replaces "yours to keep"; nesting season starts May 1. The pier, first built in 1928, has been closed since Hurricane Ian (2022) and demolition began in January 2026. The railway claim and the unrecorded county-parks contact were removed, Beverly Beach is an incorporated town, the county line is about 3.5 miles south, the pin moved to the beach at the pier, and alternative distances are straight-line from it (St. Augustine Beach 27.3 miles).
1 page corrected

Fort Myers Beach: verdict changed from "allowed" to "unclear"; Town and Lee County codes added, Times Square beach is a Lee County park

What was wrong
The page said detecting was allowed on the Town beach with no permit because no ordinance banning it had been found. It treated the Times Square and pier beach as Town beach, said Lee County's code had no detecting rule, gave Bowditch Point's parking as $5 per vehicle, listed a 50-year Florida antiquities threshold, cited § 161.053 alone for dunes, said a Town code required holes to be filled, said Lovers Key allowed detecting on "the ocean beach" and covered "part of North Fort Myers Beach Island" at the south end of Estero Island, and said Ian made landfall near Fort Myers with 12–18 feet of surge.
What it says now
No Town or County code mentions detecting on the Town beach, but Town LDC § 14-3(a)(7) bars operating "any battery or electrical powered vehicle, machine, or implement" on the beach, which literally covers a detector, and § 14-3(a)(8) bars anyone to "Excavate, mine, and remove, or haul sand or soil"; Town Code § 18-24(d) bars excavation by tools in Town parks without the town manager's permit. The verdict is now "unclear" (no permit required) until the Town says how it applies these. The Times Square beach is Lynn Hall Memorial Park, a Lee County park (Town Beaches page), temporarily closed since April 6 for post-Ian improvements. Lee County Code § 20-28(k) allows detectors in county parks except on athletic fields, environmentally sensitive areas and hazard areas (fines $75/$150/$300), while § 20-23(a) bars excavation without the Director's permit. Bowditch parking is $2 an hour (lot closed from September 8, 2026). The 50-year line (a State Parks policy, not law) was removed; dunes now cite §§ 161.242 and 161.053(2)(a); hole-filling is advice; Lovers Key detecting is limited to designated beach areas between the toe of the dune and the high-water line, south of Big Carlos Pass and off Estero Island. Ian made landfall on Cayo Costa, with 10–15 ft of inundation at Fort Myers Beach (NHC). The pin moved to the beach, alternative distances are straight-line, § 705.102 and the Little Estero Island Critical Wildlife Area were added, and unsourced find and local-traffic claims were removed.
1 page corrected

Sanibel Island: verdict changed from "allowed" to "unclear"; city beach code, refuge citations and Turner Beach jurisdiction corrected

What was wrong
The page said detecting was allowed on City of Sanibel beaches with no permit because no ordinance banning it had been found. It cited 50 CFR § 27.61 as a ban on "digging and excavation" on refuges, gave refuge penalties as "fines up to $5,000", said the refuge was about 6,400 acres and that refuge and SCCF land covered nearly 40% of the island, cited § 74-2 for live shells, called Turner Beach county-managed, said Calusa midden sites at Lighthouse Beach and the museum had physical markers, gave causeway tolls as payable by card or cash, beach parking as $5/hour or $25/day with 20 Gulfside spaces, and placed the 1715 Fleet 80 miles north.
What it says now
No city code or page mentions detecting, but Sanibel Code § 74-182 bars, on any beach in the city, anyone to "Excavate, mine, or haul sand or soil from the beach or dune" (14) and to operate "any battery or electrical powered or assisted … implement" (12), with no exception for detecting; the verdict is now "unclear" (no permit required) until the City says how it applies them. The refuge stays prohibited: 50 CFR 27.62 (objects of antiquity), 27.63(a) (no searching for buried treasure without a permit) and 27.61 (disturbing or removing natural objects); penalties are under 16 U.S.C. § 668dd(f) (up to 1 year for a knowing violation, otherwise up to 180 days). The refuge is 6,470+ acres, about 2,620 of them wilderness; the island-share claim was removed. The live-shell rule is § 74-183. Bowman's and Turner are county-owned and city-run, and Turner lies just outside the city limits, where Lee County's park code (§§ 20-23(a), 20-28(k)) applies. The SCCF ban became an owner's-permission rule; the midden-marker and 1715 Fleet claims were removed. Tolls are all-electronic ($6 two-axle, + $3 by plate); parking is $5 an hour, 24 hours a day; Gulfside has 46 spaces. Dunes now cite §§ 161.242 and 161.053(2)(a); the pin moved to Bowman's Beach, alternative distances are straight-line, and § 705.102 and the City's buried-debris warning were added.
1 page corrected

Naples Beach metal detecting: pier closed, Barefoot Beach Preserve digging rule, Delnor-Wiggins zones and distances

What was wrong
The Naples Beach metal-detecting page called the base of the Naples Pier the most productive spot and gave the pier's length as 1,015 feet. It listed Barefoot Beach Preserve as allowed and said Delnor-Wiggins Pass State Park allowed detecting on the whole ocean beach, about 6 miles north on Vanderbilt Drive. It said most Gulf Shore Boulevard frontage was private resort property with no public right of access. It gave Lowdermilk Park parking as free and Barefoot as $8 per vehicle, and cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 alone as a year-round dune ban. It said FWC monitors patrolled the beaches. In its alternatives, it said Venice Beach and Siesta Key allowed detecting with no ordinance, at distances of 65 and 75 miles. It also made unsourced claims about the visitors' wealth, the sand's mineralization and longshore drift.
What it says now
The Naples Pier, which the city says is 1,000 feet long, is closed for the Naples Pier Rebuild Project, which began in January 2026. The closure covers the pier, its stairs, restrooms and showers, and 12th Avenue South west of Gulf Shore Boulevard South, for about 18 months. Detecting on the rest of the city beach stays allowed with no permit, because neither the Naples nor the Collier County code mentions detectors. The page now quotes Naples LDC § 52-33(b), which bars excavating or removing beach material seaward of the coastal construction setback line without a city permit; it reads as a construction rule. Barefoot Beach Preserve is now "unclear": Collier Code § 54-334(d)(1) bars digging in any area of county preserve land without a special permit, and the preserve is state land leased to the county (AGO 2001-42). Delnor-Wiggins, at 11135 Gulfshore Drive about 10 miles from the page pin, allows detecting only between the toe of the dune and the high-water line as the park manager designates, never in the water, and posted closures apply. The public may use the beach under customary-use ordinances (Naples § 42-114; Collier § 146-94 at Vanderbilt, with a 15-foot buffer under § 146-95). City beach parking needs a permit or pay-by-space, and Collier beach parks charge $10. Dunes are now cited to § 161.242 and § 161.053(2)(a), and turtle monitoring to Collier County Parks & Recreation staff. Venice and Siesta Key are noted as unclear, at 77.8 and 90.6 miles. A § 705.102 lost-property line was added, and the unsourced claims were removed.
1 page corrected

Lynx Creek: the mineral withdrawal area's equipment and digging rules

What was wrong
The Lynx Creek page didn't mention the Lynx Creek Mineral Withdrawal Area. It said hand-operated sluice boxes and non-motorized rocker boxes were allowed, and that suction dredges needed a Forest Service special-use authorization plus an ADEQ Aquifer Protection Permit (with ADEQ penalties of up to $10,000 a day). It recommended digging garnets from schist outcrops upslope of the creek. It cited 36 CFR § 228.81 for a "Commercial Mineral Materials Permit", put the creek in T13N R2W and T14N R2W, and still said collecting on a claim "violates federal mining law", that disturbing claim markers is a "federal offense" and that willful claim trespass risks criminal charges. The pin was 3 miles south-south-west of the Gold Pan Day Use Area, and the page called Lynx Creek the source of Arizona Territory's first documented placer gold in 1863.
What it says now
Prescott National Forest says that inside the withdrawal area only gold pans, metal detectors and hand tools such as picks and shovels may be used; any other motorized or mechanical equipment or mining aid is prohibited (36 CFR 261.53(e)–(f)), with a fine of up to $500, up to 6 months' imprisonment, or both. Pick-and-shovel digging is allowed only with panning or detecting, below the high-water mark, and holes must be filled. The forest's map marks two No Panning zones (below Lynx Lake dam and at the old CCC camp). The forest also says no collecting is allowed in areas withdrawn from mineral entry, so the page now tells readers to ask the Bradshaw Ranger District before collecting garnets or other specimens inside the withdrawal. Elsewhere on the forest, digging and suction dredges need Forest Service authorization, and commercial collecting needs authorization; the ADEQ permit, § 228.81 and the unsourced penalties were removed. The creek is in T13N R1W and T14N R1W. The retired claim wording was replaced with civil liability under 30 U.S.C. § 26. The pin now marks the Gold Pan Day Use Area, alternative distances were recomputed, and the unsourced history and gem claims were removed.
1 page corrected

Alamo Lake: state park rule, Army Corps land, State Trust Land and the refuge's location

What was wrong
The Alamo Lake page cited "ARS § 37-1022", a section that doesn't exist, for the state park collecting ban, with a fine of up to $2,500 and confiscation. It left out that the lake and shore are Army Corps of Engineers project land and that State Trust Land lies next to the park. It said the Bill Williams River National Wildlife Refuge adjoins the lake downstream of Alamo Dam (as did the copper minerals, jasper and agate pages and the Arizona overview), put the Rawhide Mountains Wilderness east of the river, and kept a "25 lb + 1 specimen" daily limit and a claim penalty of "potential criminal charges". It said the road from Wenden was about 24 miles of unpaved road, the park fee was $15 a vehicle, and the Planet Mine was 20 miles east.
What it says now
Arizona State Parks rule A.A.C. R12-8-103 bars removing any geological object in a state park; violating it is a class 2 misdemeanor (R12-8-126), with a fine of up to $750 for an individual (A.R.S. § 13-802(B)). The lake is Army Corps project land leased to Arizona State Parks, where 36 CFR 327.14(a) bars removing mineral deposits (penalty under 36 CFR 327.25: up to $5,000, six months, or both). BLM Arizona says rockhounding isn't allowed on State Trust Land, which lies south-east of the lake. The refuge is on the lower Bill Williams River about 20 miles west of Alamo Dam, not next to the lake. Rawhide Mountains Wilderness is west and south-west of the lake and Arrastra Mountain Wilderness north and north-east. BLM Arizona's limit is 25 lb a day and 250 lb a year with no extra specimen; BLM penalties are under 43 CFR 8360.0-7 and claim trespass is a civil matter. The park road from Wenden is paved for 33 miles, the fee is $10 or $20 a vehicle, Planet is about 20 miles west, and the county is La Paz.
6 pages corrected

St. George Island: designated beach areas, Franklin County's hole rule and the closed campground

What was wrong
The St. George Island State Park page said metal detecting was allowed on "the ocean beach face only" without saying the park manager designates the areas, and didn't say to call ahead. It said there was no after-hours access "without a primitive camping permit" and assumed the campground was open. It said Confederate saltwork sites lie in the park's upland areas and that Apalachicola fell under Union control in April 1862, with no source. It didn't mention Franklin County's Leave No Trace ordinance, and its comparison table listed Cape San Blas's county beaches as "permit unconfirmed".
What it says now
Florida State Parks allows detecting at coastal parks only "within certain beach areas located between the toe of the dune and the high-water line, as designated by the park manager", never in submerged areas, and recommends calling the park ahead. The park's campground has been closed for renovations since July 13, 2026. The unsourced Civil War saltworks claims are removed. Franklin County Code § 5-133 requires holes dug on the beach to be attended and filled to natural grade before leaving, a second-degree criminal misdemeanor, but § 5-132 limits it to the public beach on the St. George Island Gulf Beaches Units 1–3 plats, not the state park. Cape San Blas has no detecting permit in the park or on Gulf County's beaches.
1 page corrected

Cape San Blas: Gulf County beach rules, the Wilderness Preserve and directions

What was wrong
The Cape San Blas page said the county beaches were "north of the park boundary" and that Gulf County had no relevant ordinance. It called the Wilderness Preserve a 9-mile area where Rule 62D-2.013(2) bars all disturbance "with no exception", and didn't mention the Wilderness Permit. Its directions said to turn south on "SR-30E" and put the park 17 miles south of Port St. Joe. Its comparison table labelled Gulf Breeze a county, and an FAQ said modern finds can be kept.
What it says now
Gulf County's Leave No Trace ordinance covers the county beaches from the Indian Pass boat ramp to the park's southern boundary (Gulf County Code § 8-32). Holes must be attended and completely filled and restored to their original level the same day (§ 8-36), unattended unfilled holes are a public nuisance (§ 8-33(d)), and no beach sand may be removed from any county beach (§ 8-44); there is no detecting ban or permit. Florida State Parks describes a 1,700-acre Wilderness Preserve, seven miles to the tip, that needs a Wilderness Permit from the ranger station; whether any of its beach is designated for detecting is the park's call. The route is US-98 to C-30A, then C-30E (county roads), about 19 miles by road and about 7 miles west-southwest of Port St. Joe in a straight line. Gulf Breeze is a city in Santa Rosa County. Lost or abandoned property must be reported to a law enforcement officer (Fla. Stat. § 705.102). The map pin, which sat in St. Joseph Bay, now marks the park ranger station, and the distances to St. George Island and Panama City Beach were recomputed.
1 page corrected

Brevard County beaches: the 1949 special act that bans digging beach sand

What was wrong
The Cocoa Beach and Satellite Beach pages said metal detecting was allowed on the city beaches. Cocoa Beach said no city or county rule restricted it and cited the city's 2018 customary-use ordinance findings, which list metal detecting, as support. Satellite Beach said no city ordinance restricted it. Neither page, nor the Melbourne Beach, Lori Wilson Park or Sebastian Inlet State Park pages, mentioned Brevard County Special Act § 262-28, which bans digging sand on every ocean beach in the county. The Cocoa Beach page also left out the city's hole-depth and fill rule, its bans on removing or moving beach sand, and that the enacted customary-use rule leaves metal detecting off the uses allowed on privately owned dry sand. The Lori Wilson Park page said the Cocoa Beach city beach was open to detecting, and the Melbourne Beach page called Cocoa Beach and Satellite Beach confirmed allowed.
What it says now
Brevard County Special Act § 262-28(a) (Laws of Fla. ch. 25703, 1949) makes it "unlawful, except as hereinafter provided, for any person to dig sand upon or excavate earth from any of the ocean beaches lying in the county of Brevard", to "prevent waste in beach lands and erosion"; its county permit covers only excavating the shore banks, and it has no exception for beaches inside cities. It doesn't mention detecting. Cocoa Beach and Satellite Beach are now unclear (were allowed), with no permit required. In Cocoa Beach, City Code § 5-34(c)(4) lets a beach ranger stop digging deeper than 18 inches and requires the hole to be filled, § 5-54 bans removing sand or earthen material from the beach, § 15-16 bars moving sand from a public beach without the city's consent, and § 5-61(e) doesn't list detecting among the uses of privately owned dry sand. Satellite Beach City Code § 26-1(c) expressly lists metal detecting as a permitted use on privately owned dry sand, but a city code can't authorize what the special act prohibits, and § 30-737(c) bans excavation seaward of the coastal setback line. Melbourne Beach stays unclear and Lori Wilson Park prohibited, with the act added. Sebastian Inlet State Park stays allowed: the act covers the park's beach north of the inlet, while the state park rule allows detecting in the areas the park manager designates, so the page says to ask the park.
5 pages corrected

Cocoa Beach and Vero Beach: modern finds aren't automatically yours to keep

What was wrong
The Vero Beach Jaycee Park page said modern items such as recent coins, jewelry and phones "are yours to keep", and the Cocoa Beach page answered "yes" to whether you can keep modern losses such as rings, coins and phones.
What it says now
Fla. Stat. § 705.102(1) requires anyone who finds lost or abandoned property to report its description and location to a law enforcement officer, and § 705.102(3) makes it unlawful to appropriate it for your own use. Both pages now say so and advise reporting valuable or identifiable finds.
2 pages corrected

Panama City Beach: metal-shovel ban, two-foot hole limit and the scoop

What was wrong
The Panama City Beach page left out the city's beach digging rules. It said a long-handle stainless sand scoop was "essential" and required gear, and gave "all holes must be filled" as a city and county code rule that is "actively enforced", though no city or county code section requires it. It also listed a ban on detecting around the Russell-Fields Pier footings that no code contains, cited a city web page that no longer exists, and said Tyndall Air Force Base begins immediately east of St. Andrews State Park.
What it says now
PCB Code § 7-10(a) says "No person shall possess on or about the Sandy Gulf Beach a metal shovel of the type customarily sold in hardware stores (not a children's toy)", and § 7-10(b) bars digging a hole "deeper than two (2) feet below surrounding grade". Violations are Class 3 civil violations under § 7-503: $50, $100, then $200 ($25, $50, $150 if not contested). § 16-3(b)(9) bans digging inside beach accesses, and Bay County Code § 5-27 sets the same two-foot limit on county sand beaches. The code doesn't say whether a detecting scoop counts as a hardware-store metal shovel; the page now says so and suggests asking Panama City Beach Police. Filling holes is now given as advice. Tyndall land lies east of the park across the St. Andrews Bay pass.
1 page corrected

Gulf Breeze: paid parking, park location, unpublished park rules and the 50-year claim

What was wrong
The Gulf Breeze page said Shoreline Park had a free lot of about 25 spaces, gave its address as 715 Shoreline Dr with a map pin about 0.7 miles east of the park, and said the Bob Sikes Bridge was immediately west of it. It said no city ordinance affected detecting without mentioning that the city code adopts unpublished park rules, said any find over 50 years old must be reported under Chapter 267, said bringing a detector into Naval Live Oaks is a federal offense, cited a city web page that returns an error, and in its comparison table listed Pensacola Beach as a city beach and Navarre Beach's permit status as unconfirmed.
What it says now
Shoreline Park South (801 Shoreline Dr) requires an annual pass or paid hourly parking: non-resident vehicles are free for 30 minutes, then $1 an hour up to $10 a day; annual passes are free for residents and $75 for non-residents. The Bob Sikes Bridge is about 1.3 miles east of the park, and the pin now sits on the park. City Code § 12-2(a) adopts park regulations "on file in the clerk's office"; they aren't online, so the page suggests asking Parks & Recreation (850-934-5140). The verdict stays allowed with no permit. Chapter 267 gives the state title to historic objects on state-owned land and sovereignty submerged land, with no age threshold or reporting duty. 36 CFR 2.1(a)(7) allows a detector that is broken down and packed. Pensacola Beach is Escambia County land managed by the Santa Rosa Island Authority, and Navarre Beach needs no permit.
1 page corrected

Oregon Sunstone Public Collection Area: name, location, directions, facilities and geology

What was wrong
The sunstone page called the BLM area the "Spectrum Sunstone Public Collection Area", which is the name of a private fee-dig mine. Its map pin was about 14 miles south of the area, so its distances to Glass Buttes (115 mi) and Hampton Butte (94.3 mi) were wrong. It routed visitors from Lakeview by OR-140 west, said the area was 55 to 60 miles from Lakeview and paved to Plush, and attributed its road conditions to BLM Lakeview "as of June 2026" when BLM had published no such statement. It said there were no restrooms or shade structures, gave the camping limit as 14 days without the 28-day period, and dated the lava at 15 to 40 million years. It also gave a $100 to $200 a day fee-dig price with no source, claimed red stones were concentrated at depth and rare in the public area, and called the deposit one of the only copper-bearing gem feldspar deposits in the world. It said claims were marked by wooden posts or PVC pipes, and it and the Hampton Butte page said collected material was subject to confiscation under 43 CFR 8360.0-7.
What it says now
BLM calls the area the Oregon Sunstone Public Collection Area; the Spectrum Sunstone Mine is a separate private fee-dig mine. The pin now sits on BLM's coordinates (42.7234, -119.8607), so Glass Buttes is 59.8 miles away and Hampton Butte 80.8 miles. Plush is northeast of Lakeview. BLM's route runs north from Plush on the Hogback Road (County Road 3-10), County Road 3-11 and BLM roads 6155, 6115 and 6195, about 24 miles, with pavement ending 4 miles out. DOGAMI puts the area about 25 miles north of Plush and 80 miles northeast of Lakeview. BLM lists a pit toilet, picnic tables and a shade structure, and allows camping anywhere in the area; BLM Oregon/Washington's supplementary rules allow 14 days in any 28-day period at one site. BLM dates the lava at 13 to 14 million years, from a Steens Mountain eruption. BLM marks the boundary with orange plastic posts and BLM triangles at the corners. Fee-dig prices are left to the operators, and the unsourced claims about red stones and world rarity are replaced with DOGAMI's color and copper figures. 43 CFR 8360.0-7 sets a fine of up to $1,000 and/or 12 months' imprisonment and says nothing about confiscation. The verdict stays allowed with no permit.
4 pages corrected

Huntington State Beach: verdict changed from "allowed" to "unclear"; Bolsa Chica isn't next door

What was wrong
The page said detecting was allowed on the sandy state beach with no permit "under CDPR rules", and that CDPR regulations distinguish recreational surface detecting from prohibited excavation (no source says so). It placed Bolsa Chica Ecological Reserve "immediately north" of the state beach, with a signed boundary on the sand, and said the state beach ran from Magnolia Street to the Santa Ana River. It described the nesting closure as seasonal CDFW rope enclosures (about March 1 – September 30), with entry a Migratory Bird Treaty Act violation. It advised detecting from 5 a.m. and cited NOAA's Los Angeles gauge as the nearest. It also described five rock groins on the beach, gave US Open of Surfing attendance as 500,000+ in a week with spill-over onto the state beach, and pinned the page on the city beach at the pier. The Newport Beach page put Huntington State Beach 12–15 miles away and called Bolsa Chica Ecological Reserve adjacent to it, and the California overview put the reserve "next door" to Huntington.
What it says now
No Orange Coast District posted order mentions metal detectors, and no detecting permit exists. However, 14 CCR § 4307(a) bars disturbing or removing sand in every state park unit, and District Order 925-23-11(B) bars disturbing geological formations. California State Parks hasn't said how it applies either rule to digging targets, so the verdict is "unclear" and the page says to ask the park first. Breaking a regulation or posted order is a misdemeanor (up to 90 days and/or $1,000) or an infraction (up to $1,000) under PRC § 5008(d). The state beach runs from Beach Boulevard south to the Santa Ana River. The 3.5-mile city beach lies between it and Bolsa Chica State Beach, and the ecological reserve is inland of Bolsa Chica State Beach, about 2.5 miles from the state beach's northern end. The California Least Tern Preserve at the south end is closed year-round (Order 925-23-23), and the beach is closed from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. (Order 925-23-03). The groin, wind and other unsourced local claims were removed. The nearest tide station is now cited, and the pin was moved onto the state beach. US Open attendance now reads close to 400,000 over nine days at the pier (city beach). California Civil Code § 2080.1 (finds worth $100 or more go to the police) was added. On the Newport Beach page, Huntington State Beach is now about 3.7 miles away and the reserve about 9 miles. The California overview's Huntington line now matches the new verdict.
3 pages corrected

Topaz Mountain: state trust land, mining claims, county and directions

What was wrong
The page treated the whole collecting area as BLM land and never mentioned the state trust section on the south side of the mountain. It called the adjoining mining claims "private claims". It put the site in Millard County and said Delta was about 50 miles southeast via "US-6/50 west then Delta Road north" on county gravel roads. It said the crystals fade "within minutes" because of iron impurities. Its penalty rows added "confiscation of material (and equipment)", which 43 CFR 8360.0-7 doesn't provide. It also made unsourced claims: an 1872 discovery by William Holden, "one of only a handful of localities in the world", crystals over 50 mm, that "varicolored" rhyolite is the productive kind, and a collecting elevation of about 6,500 ft.
What it says now
The Utah Geological Survey lists School Trust Land (state land) in Section 16, T13S R11W, next to the popular south-slope collecting area. Collecting there needs a Utah Trust Lands rockhounding permit: $25 for an individual or family, allowing 25 lb plus one piece per person per day and 250 lb a year, by hand. Removing minerals without one is a class B misdemeanor with treble damages (Utah Code 53C-2-301). BLM records show five active topaz placer claims in Section 10, just east of the collecting area. They are unpatented claims on public land, where the claimant holds the topaz (30 U.S.C. § 26), not private land. The site is in Juab County. BLM gives the route as "55 miles west of Delta via US Hwy 6 and paved county road", which is about 37 miles of paved SR-174 (Brush Wellman Road) and then a few miles of dirt. BLM says the crystals become colorless after "extensive exposure" to sunlight and gives no timescale or cause. The penalty is a fine of up to $1,000 and/or 12 months; confiscation was removed. The unsourced history, rarity, size and rock-color claims were replaced with BLM and UGS wording (UGS: "white rhyolite", crystals "usually less than an inch long"). The elevation is about 5,800 ft (USGS).
2 pages corrected

Dugway Geode Beds: geology, minerals, distances and a wrong penalty citation

What was wrong
The page said the geodes formed in place in volcanic tuff and limestone. It said calcite and selenite interiors are common, which the material page and the Rock Corral page repeated, and recommended a UV light for them. It gave sizes from fist-sized to over 12 inches and said geodes are heavier than solid rock of the same size. It cited 43 CFR 3602.10 as the penalty for commercial collecting; that section covers applying for a mineral materials sales contract. It said Dugway Proving Ground borders the beds and that its boundary is fenced and signed. It put Topaz Mountain about 80 miles away and Simpson Springs about 10 miles east, and named Grantsville and Tooele as the nearest services. It gave the elevation as about 4,700 ft and didn't mention mining claims.
What it says now
The Utah Geological Survey says the geodes formed in cavities in rhyolite 6 to 8 million years ago, and that Lake Bonneville's waves later eroded that rock and redeposited the geodes at Dugway as lake sediments. BLM and UGS name quartz as the most common mineral: clear, purple (amethyst) and pink (rose). Some geodes are filled with banded quartz. Neither source mentions calcite or selenite. BLM gives sizes of 2 to 4 inches, UGS says most are 2 to 3 inches, and UGS calls them lightweight. Commercial collecting is covered by 43 CFR 8365.1-5(c), with a penalty under 43 CFR 8360.0-7 of up to $1,000 and/or 12 months. On OpenStreetMap the Proving Ground's nearest boundary is about 13 miles northwest. Topaz Mountain is 13.7 miles south and Simpson Springs about 21 miles east-northeast, both straight-line. UGS names Fish Springs National Wildlife Refuge for bathrooms and water and Dugway for gas. The elevation is about 4,900 ft (USGS). BLM records show filed lode claims about a mile south-southwest and an active tunnel site about a mile north, so the page now says to check MLRS.
3 pages corrected

Rye Patch: land status, map location, mining claims, finds and distances

What was wrong
The Rye Patch page described all the land around the reservoir as BLM land, with BLM collecting areas beginning at the state recreation area boundary; its map pin (40.4670, -118.2900) was on private land. It listed thundereggs, picture jasper, Miocene petrified wood, chalcedony and carnelian, explained them with a Lake Lahontan origin, and called Lahontan larger than Lake Erie, none of it from a source. It said claims 'can be dense in certain drainages', cited 43 CFR 3809 as a basis for claim liability, added 'excess material may be confiscated' to the 43 CFR 8360.0-7 penalty, said the recreation area has water 'only for registered campers', did not mention gold prospecting or metal detecting, and put Exit 129 about 90 miles from Reno and 80 from Winnemucca. Its Virgin Valley distance was 110 miles.
What it says now
BLM's surface-management map shows a checkerboard of BLM and private sections, with most of the strip just east of the reservoir private and Reclamation land at the dam; Reclamation transferred parts of the dam and reservoir lands to the State of Nevada and local agencies in 2013-2017. Collecting is allowed only on unclaimed BLM sections; the recreation area bans removing any rock (NRS 407.250), and Reclamation land bars removing natural resources and metal detectors without a permit (43 CFR 423.29). The pin now marks an unclaimed BLM section about 6 miles east of the dam (40.4670, -118.1970). MLRS maps about 1,000 active claims in the hills east and south-east of the reservoir; BLM Nevada says gold, silver and opals found on claims 'belong to the claim holder' and common rock 'may be collected for private use on unclaimed sites'. The claim penalty rests on 30 U.S.C. 26 (civil liability to the claimant), not 43 CFR 3809, and the confiscation line was removed. BLM Nevada allows gold prospecting 'with hand tools including pans and metal detectors'; the park hosts the annual Rye Patch Nugget Shoot. The unsourced finds and geology were removed; the USGS geologic map shows Triassic Koipato Group volcanic rocks and Star Peak Group carbonates. Exit 129 is about 116 I-80 miles from Reno and 47 from Winnemucca; Virgin Valley is about 104 miles straight-line and Garnet Hill about 190. The verdict stays 'allowed'.
4 pages corrected

Olympic National Forest: commercial permit is paid; wilderness closed to harvesting; 261.6(h)

What was wrong
The Olympic National Forest foraging page still said in places that the commercial harvest permit is free from three ranger districts, and its checklist still gave a 1-gallon daily limit. It said hand harvesting remains allowed in the forest's wilderness areas. It cited 36 CFR 261.6(f) for selling personal-use harvest and 261.6(e) for commercial harvest without a permit, and said selling is treated as commercial harvest. It cited RCW 17.10 (the noxious-weed law) as protecting plants and said beargrass needs a free commercial permit. Its map pin sat on the Quinault Indian Reservation, and it steered pickers to the Hoh valley, which is national park land.
What it says now
The forest's commercial mushroom permit costs $50 for 50 gallons (14 days), $80 for 80 gallons (30 days) or $120 for 120 gallons (calendar year), bought by appointment at a Forest office (Quilcene, Forks or Quinault); commercial berry picking isn't allowed. Without a permit the limits are 1 gallon per mushroom species a year and berries 1 gallon a day, 3 a year. The forest's berry and fiddlehead pages prohibit harvesting in designated wilderness, botanical and research natural areas, timber-sale locations and the Quinault Special Management Area. Mushrooms must be cut, not pulled, and rakes are prohibited. Unauthorized removal falls under 36 CFR 261.6(h) (penalty 36 CFR 261.1b); the forest's own pages say personal-use mushrooms may not be sold or traded. The forest says harvesting rare, threatened or endangered plants is illegal; the RCW 17.10 and beargrass claims were removed. The pin now sits on national forest land in Jefferson County, and unsourced local detail was removed.
1 page corrected

Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie: permit validity, charged personal permits, separate limits and district phones

What was wrong
The Mt. Baker-Snoqualmie foraging page read the forest's "2 weeks to 1 month" as permit processing time and said a commercial permit costs $25 per 12.5 gallons, processed in 2 business days. It applied the 5-gallon household cap to everything picked, said to ask about wilderness rules while elsewhere saying wilderness was closed, and listed five of the forest's nine wildernesses. It gave wrong ranger district phone numbers, named a White River district, said the permit is issued only in person, and said the SR 20 winter closure cuts off part of the forest. It cited 36 CFR 261.6(f) and an unnamed regional order, and labelled 36 CFR 261.6 a Pacific Northwest rule. It applied North Cascades National Park's 1-quart daily limit to fungi as well as berries, and gave the Olympic National Forest limit as 1 gallon a day with wilderness open. The Washington foraging overview carried the processing-time reading and said North Cascades allows a quart of berries and fungi, none in subalpine meadows.
What it says now
A free-use permit is valid for 2 weeks to a month, depending on the district. Its limits are 5 gallons of mushrooms per household a year, 5 gallons of wild berries a year and 5 pounds of fiddleheads and other forest greens a year. The $25-for-12.5-gallon tier (up to $125 for 62.5 gallons, matsutake excluded) is a charged personal permit; commercial quantities are priced individually at appraised value. Gathering is prohibited in legislated wilderness (Alpine Lakes, Boulder River, Clearwater, Glacier Peak, Henry M. Jackson, Mt. Baker, Noisy-Diobsud, Norse Peak and Wild Sky), research natural areas and experimental forests. The four ranger districts are Mt. Baker (360) 854-2553, Darrington (360) 436-1155, Skykomish (360) 677-2414 and Snoqualmie (425) 888-1421. Unauthorized removal falls under 36 CFR 261.6(h). North Cascades' 2026 compendium limits fruits and berries to 1 quart per person per day and requires fungi to be cut, not pulled; it has no subalpine-meadow rule for them. The SR 20, in-person-only and unsourced local claims were removed; the pin now sits on national forest land in King County.
3 pages corrected

Umpqua National Forest: matsutake permit, halving rule, truffle ban and closed areas

What was wrong
The Umpqua page said the 1-gallon no-permit limit covered matsutake, berries and plants as one combined total, and that Umpqua had no rule requiring mushrooms to be cut in half. It said personal-use harvest rules applied in the forest's wildernesses, didn't mention the truffle ban, the riparian closure or the one-third-of-caps rule, and placed the 2021 Bootleg Fire in the southern Umpqua. It said Oregon's state plant list applied on federal land, and in places that Crater Lake National Park bans all collecting. Its comparison table said the Umpqua, Willamette and Deschutes had no rule beyond the 1-gallon limit, and an alternative said Siuslaw has no wilderness.
What it says now
No permit or fee is needed for mushrooms under one gallon per person per day "unless you are collecting matsutakes", and "all mushrooms collected must be cut in half". Any matsutake needs a paid permit ($8 a day, $24 minimum; $100 half season; $200 full season). A free Free Use permit covers up to 2 gallons a day on 10 days a year. The forest publishes no no-permit berry amount; foliage needs a paid permit even for personal use, and seed and cutting collection isn't allowed. The four-forest mushroom rules prohibit truffle harvest, require leaving one-third of caps, and close wilderness, Late Successional Reserves, Research Natural Areas, developed recreation areas and riparian areas to mushroom picking. The Bootleg Fire burned on the Fremont-Winema. Oregon's listed-plant rules apply on non-federal public land. Crater Lake allows four berries, 1 quart per person per day each. The Deschutes requires a permit for any mushroom picking, and Siuslaw has four wildernesses. The Willamette distance is now 71.7 miles.
1 page corrected

Rogue River-Siskiyou: Oregon Caves gathering allowances, matsutake permit, yearly caps and closed areas

What was wrong
The Rogue River-Siskiyou page and the Oregon foraging overview said Oregon Caves National Monument prohibits all plant and fungal collecting. The forest page gave a 1-gallon daily limit covering mushrooms, berries and most plants with no yearly cap and no matsutake exception, said beargrass fell under the 1-gallon allowance, and said personal-use collecting was allowed in the Kalmiopsis Wilderness. It named the Illinois Valley Ranger District, cited 36 CFR 261.10(c) for exceeding the limit and 261.6(f) for selling, put its map pin on private land, and gave straight-line distances of 65 and 130 miles to the Umpqua and Willamette. The overview also said Crater Lake prohibits all foraging.
What it says now
Oregon Caves National Monument and Preserve's compendium (revised May 4, 2026) allows hand-gathering for personal use of berries (1 quart per person per day), apples (5 per day), tanoak acorns (1 quart per person per day) and edible fungi (1 quart per day, no mechanical means or soil disturbance); other collecting is prohibited under 36 CFR 2.1. Crater Lake allows four berries, 1 quart per person per day each. The forest's Incidental Use Guide allows mushrooms and berries at 1 gallon a day and 5 gallons a year each, beargrass and other foliage at 2 pounds a day and 20 pounds a year, and no matsutake; the forest requires a permit before removing any amount of matsutake. Harvest is not allowed in wilderness, botanical areas, research natural areas or administrative sites, or within 200 feet of a building, campground, state highway or water body. The district is now the Wild Rivers Ranger District (same phone). Removal beyond authorized amounts is 36 CFR 261.6(h). The pin is now on national forest land near Bolan Lake, and distances are 100.0, 169.7 and 142.4 miles.
2 pages corrected

Treasure Coast pages: penalty for recovering material from offshore wrecks

What was wrong
Eight Treasure Coast pages gave the penalty for "unlicensed recovery" from an offshore wreck in state waters as a third-degree felony with all equipment and material forfeited, citing Fla. Stat. § 267.13(1)(b) alone.
What it says now
§ 267.13 sets two tiers: removing an archaeological specimen from state land, including sovereignty submerged land, without excavation is a first-degree misdemeanor; by excavation it is a third-degree felony. Equipment is forfeited only "if it is determined by any court of law that the vehicle or equipment was involved in the violation", and finds are forfeited. § 267.13(2)(a) also lets the Division of Historical Resources impose an administrative fine of up to $500 a day for exploring for or salvaging treasure trove or wrecks on state land without its written permission. Florida issues permits, not licenses.
8 pages corrected

Martin County beach parks: county code, Stuart Beach's manager and location

What was wrong
Jensen Beach and Stuart Beach said no county rule restricted hobbyists and left out Martin County's park code. Stuart Beach said the City of Stuart manages it and placed it at the St. Lucie Inlet, with Bathtub Reef Beach 1.5 miles north; Bathtub Reef Beach's page repeated both claims. Jensen Beach's map pin was about 1.65 miles west of the park, on the mainland side of the causeway, and Stuart Beach's about 2.4 miles off. Both pages cited § 161.053 for dune vegetation.
What it says now
Martin County Code § 17.9.D names Stuart Beach, Jensen Beach, Bathtub Reef and Hobe Sound Beach as county full-service beach parks, and § 17.9.A.2.p bars disturbing or removing "any cultural or natural resource including vegetation" from a county park without the county's written permission; a cultural resource is "any item, area or artifact of historical or cultural significance" (§ 17.8). Violations are misdemeanors (up to 60 days and/or $500, § 17.4.A). No county ordinance mentions metal detecting, so the "allowed, no permit" verdicts stand. Stuart Beach (889 NE Ocean Blvd) is about 3.5 miles north of the St. Lucie Inlet, with Bathtub Reef Beach to its south. Pins moved to OpenStreetMap's park locations. Sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242.
3 pages corrected

South Beach, Fort Pierce: a city beach, not a county one

What was wrong
The page said St. Lucie County manages South Beach, that no county ordinance restricted detecting, and that South Beach had no upland restriction like the state park's across the inlet. It cited § 161.053 for dune vegetation. The Treasure Coast guide also listed the manager as St. Lucie County.
What it says now
South Beach Park and South Jetty Park are City of Fort Pierce parks, and city code counts every beach within city limits as a park area (§ 28-1). The code has no metal-detecting rule, but it allows ground disturbance only on the sandy beach areas of parks (§ 28-31(9)) and bars removing "archaeological or cultural resources", defined to include artifacts and fossils, without the city manager's authorization (§ 28-31(12)). Violations are civil infractions of up to $500, and violators can be ejected (§§ 28-2, 1-99). Sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242.
2 pages corrected

Fort Pierce Inlet State Park: dune rule authority and annual passes

What was wrong
The page said detecting and digging in the dunes is prohibited "under state coastal protection rules", said Annual Pass holders enter free, and said motorized equipment and night digging were banned on the beach without a source.
What it says now
Inside the park the dunes are off-limits because Florida State Parks policy allows detecting only seaward of the toe of the dune and FAC 62D-2.013(2) bars digging; §§ 161.053 and 161.242 separately bar damaging dunes and their vegetation. An Individual Annual Pass ($60) admits only its holder, with companions paying $2 each; the Family pass ($120) covers up to 8. The park also charges $4 for a single-occupant vehicle or motorcycle. The unsourced equipment and night-digging rules were removed (the park closes at sundown).
1 page corrected

Vulture Mine area: BLM Arizona limit, field office, State Trust Land

What was wrong
The page gave the BLM limit as 25 lb a day plus one specimen piece, 250 lb a year; cited 43 CFR 8365.1-5(b)(2) as the penalty for exceeding 250 lb, with material confiscated; called the filing a "Notice of Intent" with the "Phoenix Field Office" at 21137 S. Interstate 10, (623) 580-5500; treated any dry washer under 10 HP as casual use; gave ARPA as fines up to $100,000 with equipment confiscation; and left out State Trust Land.
What it says now
BLM Arizona sets the personal-use limit at up to 25 lb a day and 250 lb a year, with no extra piece ("+1 piece" is the federal petrified-wood rule, 43 CFR 3622.4). Violations of the collecting rules are punishable by a fine up to $1,000 and/or 12 months (43 CFR 8360.0-7). The area is managed by the Hassayampa Field Office (2020 E. Bell Road, Phoenix, 602-867-5400). Exploration beyond casual use needs a Notice (5 acres or less, 43 CFR 3809.21) and mining a Plan of Operations (3809.11); dry washers under 10 HP are casual use only if hand-fed (BLM Arizona IM 2018-012). ARPA: up to $10,000/1 year, $20,000/2 years above $500, $100,000/5 years for a repeat. BLM Arizona says rockhounding and metal detecting are not allowed on Arizona State Trust Land.
1 page corrected

Hutchinson Island: verdict, state park, nuclear plant and county digging rule

What was wrong
The page said county beaches on Hutchinson Island allow detecting without a permit, placed Fort Pierce Inlet State Park on the island's north end, called South Beach a St. Lucie County beach, described a federal nuclear-plant security perimeter extending across the beach to the water with a 10 CFR 73.55 penalty of up to 10 years and $10,000, said the island runs to near North Palm Beach, and cited § 161.053 for dune vegetation.
What it says now
Verdict changed allowed → unclear. St. Lucie County Code § 32-89(c) bars digging beach sand or making any excavation by hand or tool in county parks "unless authorized by permit", and applies to every county-owned park (§ 32-87); no ordinance mentions detecting. The north end is a City of Fort Pierce beach (Code ch. 28) and the south end's Martin County parks fall under § 17.9.A.2.p; both allow detecting. Fort Pierce Inlet State Park is on North Hutchinson Island, across the inlet. The St. Lucie plant is west of SR A1A; the NRC lists Blind Creek and Walton Rocks as county parks inside its property boundary. Entering posted plant grounds is trespass on critical infrastructure, a third-degree felony (Fla. Stat. § 812.141(4)). The island ends at the St. Lucie Inlet. Sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242.
1 page corrected

Bathtub Reef Beach: map location

What was wrong
The page's map pin (27.2100, -80.2144) was on North River Road in Sewall's Point, on the mainland across the Indian River Lagoon, about 3.7 miles from the beach.
What it says now
The pin now marks the beach park on southern Hutchinson Island (27.1860, -80.1605, OpenStreetMap), at 1585 SE MacArthur Blvd.
1 page corrected

Colorado suction dredging: DRMS goes by area disturbed, not nozzle size

What was wrong
The Arkansas River gold-panning page said Colorado's Division of Reclamation, Mining and Safety regulates suction dredging once a nozzle exceeds 4 inches, and required state authorization above that size.
What it says now
DRMS doesn't regulate dredges by size. Under C.R.S. 34-32-103(12), prospecting that disturbs no more than 1,600 square feet in a single block, two such blocks per acre and 5 acres statewide in 24 months is outside regulated prospecting; beyond that, a notice of intent is required. The 4-inch figure is a site rule: BLM's notification for the Arkansas River Point Bar Placer Area limits in-stream dredges to a 4-inch intake and an 8 hp motor. The suction dredging guide's Colorado row was updated to match.
2 pages corrected

South Carolina state parks: detecting isn't limited to lost property

What was wrong
The Myrtle Beach page said SC State Parks allows metal detecting only with a special activity permit for someone searching for a specific, verifiable lost item, and never for general recreational detecting.
What it says now
SC State Parks' metal detection policy says to assume an absolute prohibition, but lets the park manager approve responsible recreational detecting in non-sensitive areas with a signed permit naming the areas, dates and times. Dunes are off-limits, historic artifacts stay in place, modern items such as jewelry are turned over to the park manager, and State Historic Sites (plus listed sites such as the Hunting Island lighthouse complex and the Edisto Beach Spanish Mount shell mound) are closed to detectors.
1 page corrected

Big Cypress: only berries, citrus and bananas may be picked

What was wrong
The Big Cypress page said NPS Management Policies § 4.4.3 allows personal-use collecting of berries, fruits, nuts and mushrooms in national preserves, listed chanterelles and palm hearts as legal finds, and said saw palmetto berries could be harvested with the Park Service's permission and an FDACS permit. It also called the ghost orchid federally listed as threatened. The foraging hobby page and the Fakahatchee Strand page repeated the § 4.4.3 claim.
What it says now
Management Policies § 4.4.3 (titled "Harvest of Plants and Animals by the Public") only allows harvest a superintendent authorizes under 36 CFR 2.1(c). The Big Cypress compendium (approved July 22, 2026) designates berries, citrus fruits and bananas, picked by hand for personal consumption, and prohibits picking palmetto berries. Mushrooms, nuts and other plant parts aren't designated, so removing them is prohibited under 36 CFR 2.1(a)(1). The ghost orchid was proposed for listing as endangered in June 2025; no final rule has been published. The hobby page now says national parks and preserves allow only what each compendium designates.
3 pages corrected

Oregon's protected-plant list doesn't govern national forest land

What was wrong
The Mount Hood and Willamette National Forest pages said Oregon-listed endangered plants may not be collected there under Oregon state law (ORS Chapter 564), with state penalties.
What it says now
The Oregon Department of Agriculture protects state-listed plants on non-federal public land (OAR 603-073), so the state list applies if you cross onto state, county or city land, not on the national forest itself. On national forest land, federally listed endangered plants may not be removed under the Endangered Species Act, 16 U.S.C. § 1538(a)(2)(B).
2 pages corrected

North Cascades: no subalpine-meadow ban on berries and fungi

What was wrong
The Okanogan-Wenatchee National Forest page said gathering berries and fungi in adjacent North Cascades National Park is not allowed in subalpine meadows, and applied the 1-quart daily limit to fungi as well as berries.
What it says now
The park's 2026 superintendent's compendium allows listed berries and edible fungi to be gathered by hand for personal use. The 1-quart-per-person-per-day limit is for fruits and berries; fungi must be cut, not pulled. Its only subalpine-meadow restriction, in § 2.1(a)(4), concerns firewood.
1 page corrected

Venice: the Florida Fossil Permit covers state lands, not all public land

What was wrong
The Venice Beach metal-detecting page said a Florida Fossil Permit is needed to collect vertebrate fossils (other than shark teeth) on any public land.
What it says now
The permit covers vertebrate fossils collected on state lands, which include beaches below mean high water and the sea floor. County and city land is outside the program.
1 page corrected

Badlands: where PRPA applies

What was wrong
The Badlands National Park page said the Paleontological Resources Preservation Act applies on all federal land regardless of the managing agency.
What it says now
PRPA applies to land managed by the Department of the Interior (including NPS and BLM) and to National Forest System land, which includes national grasslands such as Buffalo Gap (16 U.S.C. § 470aaa).
1 page corrected

San Rafael Swell: wilderness rules, Fossil Point and permit details

What was wrong
The San Rafael Swell page placed BLM's Fossil Point Trailhead in the Swell at Spotted Wolf Canyon and said visitors may not touch the bones; named a "Horse Canyon Wilderness"; said fossil collecting is banned in all the Swell's wilderness areas; said vertebrate research permits are issued by the Price Field Office; and cited "PRPA 2009" for a $1,000 off-road vehicle fine. The Hell Creek page repeated the Fossil Point description.
What it says now
BLM puts Fossil Point about a dozen miles south of Green River, east of the Swell, and says its bones are fine to see and gently touch but illegal to take. The 2019 Dingell Act wildernesses here include San Rafael Reef, Sid's Mountain, Mexican Mountain, Muddy Creek, Little Wild Horse Canyon and Horse Valley; there is no Horse Canyon Wilderness. BLM Manual 6340 lets a wilderness plan ban casual fossil collecting, and the plan for these areas isn't final, so the page now says to confirm with the Price Field Office. Utah BLM paleontology permits go to the BLM Utah State Office. The off-road penalty is 43 CFR 8340.0-7: up to $1,000, 12 months in prison, or both.
2 pages corrected

Brevard sea turtle lighting: county rule covers only unincorporated beaches, and runs May 1 – October 31

What was wrong
The Satellite Beach and Melbourne Beach pages said Brevard County's lighting ordinance (Chapter 46, Article III) applies on all Brevard beaches. Both pages said lights visible from the beach are banned from 9 p.m. to 7 a.m. for the whole March 1 – October 31 season. The Melbourne Beach page also said a section south of the 6th Avenue boat ramp may close for nesting season.
What it says now
The county ordinance protects turtles nesting on the unincorporated beaches of Brevard County (Sec. 46-93); incorporated towns have their own. In Melbourne Beach, the town and county lights-out rules run May 1 – October 31 and require beach-visible lights, including flashlights and phones, to be off after 9 p.m. In Satellite Beach, the city's guidance under its Chapter 26, Article X is no visible lights on the beach after dark in nesting season (March 1 – October 31); its 9 p.m.–7 a.m. rule is for beachfront property lighting. Nests are protected from March 1 in both. The town ties the 6th Avenue boat ramp closure to repairs, not turtles.
2 pages corrected

Melbourne Beach: Val M. Steele Park is outside the town

What was wrong
The Melbourne Beach page said Val M. Steele Park is a county park "within the town boundary".
What it says now
The town limits run along Atlantic Street/A1A up to the 2300 block. Val M. Steele Park (formerly Coconut Point Park) and Spessard Holland South Beach Park are county parks just south of that, in unincorporated Brevard; Spessard Holland North is inside the town. All three are covered by the county's park excavation ban (Sec. 78-120).
1 page corrected

Jaycee Beach Park: map location and dune citation

What was wrong
The Jaycee Beach Park page placed the park about 1.6 miles south of its real location (27.6424, -80.3621), cited Fla. Stat. § 161.053 (the coastal construction control line) as the rule protecting dune vegetation, and listed Indian River County as governing "unincorporated beach access areas adjacent to the park".
What it says now
The park is at 4200 Ocean Drive (27.6656, -80.3597), inside Vero Beach city limits. Sea oats and sea grapes are protected by § 161.242, and the city code (§ 54-40) bars removing sand or damaging vegetation in any park, which by § 54-2 includes the beach. No unincorporated county land adjoining the park could be confirmed, so that entry was removed.
1 page corrected

Sebastian Inlet: earlier corrections hadn't reached every line of the page

What was wrong
Although the 2026-10-02 corrections on sea turtle nests, 1715 Fleet salvage and the Florida State Parks detecting rule listed this page, parts of it still said: stay 10 feet from marked nests; salvors work "under state permits"; offshore recovery needs a "state contract"; the wrecks are "archaeological preserves"; and detecting is allowed anywhere on the beach above mean high tide. It also said the park is open 8 a.m. to sunset.
What it says now
No law sets a distance from a marked nest. The 1715 wrecks are under a federal admiralty case, worked only by the court-appointed salvor, and Florida issues no permits for them (FAC 1A-31.0045). Detecting is allowed only on the beach areas the park manager designates, between the toe of the dune and the high-water line. The park is open 24 hours; the South Ranger Station entrance is open 8 a.m. to sunset. The page also now notes the parking-lot closures for the SR A1A bridge replacement, through spring 2032.
1 page corrected

Florida national forests: no permit or published limit for gathering food for your own use

What was wrong
The Apalachicola National Forest page said berries above casual amounts need a free Special Forest Products permit (1 gallon a day, 3 gallons a year, from gp.fs2c.usda.gov, in areas on a harvest map), that mushrooms are limited to 3 gallons a day for 10 days a year, and that all Florida carnivorous plants are state-listed. Those permit figures belong to Gifford Pinchot National Forest in Washington. The Osceola page gave an unsourced limit of 1 gallon per species per day and said commercial collecting needs a free permit; the Forest Service personal-use guide called the commercial permit a Special Use Permit.
What it says now
National Forests in Florida, which runs Apalachicola, Osceola and Ocala, says no permit is needed "when you are gathering edible material (morels, etc.) for your own consumption" and publishes no quantity limit. Commercial collecting needs a permit from the District Ranger, with fees based on quantity and location, and selling anything gathered without one is prohibited (36 CFR § 261.6). Florida's Regulated Plant Index lists many but not all carnivorous plants; none is covered by the edible-material allowance. Apalachicola's area is 567,742 acres, not 635,019.
3 pages corrected

Mining claims: collecting on a claim isn't "federal trespass"

What was wrong
Seven rockhounding and gold-prospecting pages said collecting or prospecting on an active mining claim without permission is a "federal violation" or "federal trespass", with possible criminal charges, or (Garnet Hill, Oregon Sunstone) criminal trespass under state law. Lynx Creek cited 30 U.S.C. § 47 for a federal misdemeanor of moving claim markers.
What it says now
An unpatented claim stays public land; the claimant holds the right to the minerals it was located for (30 U.S.C. § 26). BLM's 2024 FAQ says collecting is generally not allowed where there are active claims, and BLM Wyoming says rockhounds may collect anything but the claimed minerals. Taking claimed minerals exposes you to civil liability to the claimant; we found no federal statute making it a crime. Patented claims are private land, where state trespass law applies. 30 U.S.C. § 47 concerns pre-1870 mining rights and says nothing about claim markers; that penalty row was removed.
7 pages corrected

New Jersey metal-detecting pages: state park penalties and the law on historic finds

What was wrong
The Asbury Park, Cape May and Island Beach pages said equipment may be confiscated for detecting in a state park without a permit. Asbury Park cited the New Jersey Register of Historic Places Act for removing "pre-1978" artifacts from state land, and Island Beach described an unsourced penalty scheme and called Florida's Chapter 267 a blanket 50-year rule.
What it says now
Detecting without the Superintendent's permit (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.16) carries a civil penalty of $50 to $1,500 per offense (N.J.S.A. 13:1L-23). Forfeiture of equipment applies to knowingly removing park property or archaeological findings under N.J.S.A. 13:1L-10(a): fines of $750–$1,500 for a first offense, rising to $5,000, with finds deposited with the New Jersey State Museum. That statute, not the Register of Historic Places Act, governs finds on state park and forest land, and it has no age threshold. Florida's Chapter 267 has no age threshold either; the 50-year figure is Florida State Parks policy.
3 pages corrected

Glass Buttes: the ARPA penalty for a first offense

What was wrong
The Glass Buttes page gave the first-offense ARPA penalty as up to $20,000 and 2 years, without the lower tier.
What it says now
A first knowing violation is punishable by up to $10,000 and/or 1 year, rising to $20,000 and/or 2 years only where the resource's value plus restoration and repair costs exceed $500; a second or later conviction carries up to $100,000 and/or 5 years (16 U.S.C. § 470ee(d)). Civil penalties and forfeiture of vehicles and equipment can also apply.
1 page corrected

Hell Creek, Montana: fossil collecting on state trust land and in the wildlife refuge

What was wrong
The Hell Creek page told readers to check with Montana DNRC about collecting on state land, labelled the Fort Peck Reservoir area as state land, and gave the Charles M. Russell National Wildlife Refuge penalty as an unsourced citation with confiscation of equipment.
What it says now
Fossil collecting is not part of recreational use on Montana state trust land and needs an antiquities permit, which is issued only to institutions (ARM 36.25.145(11)(a); Mont. Code Ann. § 22-3-432), so the page now lists state trust sections as prohibited. The refuge rule is 50 CFR 27.61, with penalties under 16 U.S.C. § 668dd(f) (up to 180 days, or 1 year for a knowing violation, plus fines). The state-park rule is now cited to ARM 12.8.802.
1 page corrected

Oregon beachcombing pages: the ocean shore collecting limits and who owns the beach

What was wrong
The Bandon Beach page and the beachcombing hub put driftwood inside the one-gallon-a-day limit for loose agates and shells. The Agate Beach page said OAR 736-021-0090 prohibits removing sand outright, and that the 1967 Beach Bill affirmed state ownership of both the wet and dry sand. The beachcombing hub also said Olympic National Park beaches allow nothing at all.
What it says now
OAR 736-021-0090 (as amended effective February 28, 2024) sets separate personal-use limits: loose agates, rocks, shells and fossils, one 1-gallon container a day and 3 gallons a year; sand, 5 gallons a day and 20 a year; cobble, 5 gallons a day and 10 a year; driftwood, 1 cubic yard a day and 3 cords a year. Its baseline ban on digging or removing sand, soil, rock or fossil material applies outside those allowances. The state has owned the wet sand between ordinary high tide and extreme low tide since 1947 (ORS 390.615); the 1967 Beach Bill declared a policy of free and uninterrupted public use and vests public easements over the dry sand in the state (ORS 390.610). Olympic National Park allows a handful of unoccupied seashells per person per visit.
3 pages corrected

National park gathering allowances, the federal personal-use foraging rule, and Washington forest limits

What was wrong
Foraging pages said Olympic and North Cascades national parks prohibit all foraging under "36 CFR 2.1(h)", a paragraph that does not exist, and that Crater Lake National Park bans all plant and mushroom collection, including huckleberries. Beachcombing pages, the Washington beachcombing overview, the beachcombing Tip and hub said Olympic National Park beaches allow no shell to be taken. The USFS foraging guide and 13 forest pages cited 36 CFR 261.10(a) (occupancy and use) as the regulation that authorizes personal-use foraging "by implication", and the guide said the Wilderness Act bans personal-use foraging in wilderness. Washington forest pages gave wrong limits: Olympic National Forest as 1 gallon a day of everything, Okanogan-Wenatchee as 1 gallon per species a day with no paperwork, commercial permits as free, and Forest Service penalties as civil.
What it says now
36 CFR 2.1(c) lets each superintendent designate fruits, berries, nuts or unoccupied seashells that may be gathered by hand for personal use. Olympic National Park allows edible fruits, berries, nuts and mushrooms up to 1 quart per person per day (not within 200 feet of nature trails) and a handful of unoccupied seashells per person per visit on its ocean beaches; North Cascades allows listed berries and edible fungi, 1 quart a day, not in subalpine meadows; Crater Lake allows blueberries, huckleberries, serviceberries and thimbleberries, 1 quart a day each, and no mushrooms. Personal-use foraging in national forests rests on 36 CFR 223.279, under which each forest sets its own personal-use harvest level; removing forest products otherwise is barred by 36 CFR 261.6(h), punishable by up to 6 months and/or a fine (36 CFR 261.1b). The Wilderness Act bars commercial enterprise but does not itself ban personal-use picking. Olympic National Forest allows 1 gallon per mushroom species per year and berries at 1 gallon a day and 3 a year without a permit, and sells commercial mushroom permits; Okanogan-Wenatchee allows up to 5 gallons of morels per person per day with its free information sheet in hand.
20 pages corrected

Olympic National Park beach pages: the federal penalty for collecting

What was wrong
The Ruby Beach and Kalaloch Beach pages listed confiscation of anything collected as part of the penalty for removing natural objects under 36 CFR 2.1(a)(1), citing 36 CFR 1.3.
What it says now
36 CFR 1.3 sets the penalty for violating National Park Service regulations as a fine and/or up to 6 months in prison; it does not provide for confiscation. The penalty rows and prose now state the fine and imprisonment only.
2 pages corrected

Nevada rockhounding pages: the state park collecting law and the refuge penalty

What was wrong
The Rye Patch page cited NRS 407.075 and Nevada Admin. Code 407.030 as the ban on collecting in Rye Patch State Recreation Area and gave the penalty as a misdemeanor with a fine of up to $500 and confiscation of material and equipment. The Royal Peacock page gave the penalty for collecting beyond the Sheldon National Wildlife Refuge rules only as a federal citation with confiscation and a fine.
What it says now
Removing natural specimens from Nevada state park land is prohibited by NRS 407.250. Violating it is a public offense scaled to the value removed under NRS 193.155, and never less than a misdemeanor, which carries up to 6 months in jail and/or a $1,000 fine (NRS 193.150). On national wildlife refuges, 50 CFR 27.61 and 27.63 bar removing natural objects and searching for mineral specimens except as authorized, and violations carry a fine under Title 18 and up to 180 days in prison, or up to 1 year for a knowing violation (16 U.S.C. § 668dd(f)).
2 pages corrected

Wyoming fossil pages: PRPA penalties, where the fee quarries operate, and Wyoming’s state permit law

What was wrong
The Fossil Butte page said PRPA violations involving $500 or less carry fine-only penalties. Fossil Butte and Green River said tools and specimens may be confiscated for collecting in a national park unit, without a source. The Green River page said the Kemmerer fee-dig quarries operate on leased BLM parcels. The Lance Creek page gave the casual-collecting limit as "a reasonable personal-use amount" and its penalties only in general terms. None of the Wyoming pages mentioned W.S. 36-1-114.
What it says now
Under 16 U.S.C. § 470aaa-5, a knowing PRPA violation carries fines under Title 18 and up to 5 years in prison, or up to 2 years when value plus restoration costs are $500 or less; penalties can double for a repeat offense. The 36 CFR 2.1 penalty is a federal petty offense of up to $5,000 and/or 6 months. Fossils collected on BLM land can’t be sold, and the fee quarries operate on private land or Wyoming state trust land, where the Office of State Lands and Investments issues commercial fossil permits. The BLM casual-collecting limit for common invertebrate and plant fossils is 25 lb per person per day (43 CFR 49.810). W.S. 36-1-114 requires a State Board of Land Commissioners permit before any excavation of paleontological deposits on state or federal land in Wyoming; violations are misdemeanors, and removing more than $500 worth is a felony (W.S. 36-1-116).
4 pages corrected

Beach pages: sea turtle nest penalties, the "10-foot rule" and nesting-season dates

What was wrong
Florida and North Carolina beach pages gave the federal penalty for disturbing a sea turtle nest as a civil fine of up to $50,000 (often with "significant state penalties" or "state fines up to $5,000"), and none mentioned that Florida treats it as a felony. Many pages said a 10-foot clearance from marked nests is required, or that digging within 10 feet of a nest is prohibited, and some said FWC rangers enforce nesting zones. Flagler Beach and Gulf Breeze gave the nesting season as starting March 1, and several pages compared the Gulf and Atlantic coast start dates incorrectly.
What it says now
Under Fla. Stat. § 379.2431(1)(e), knowingly taking, disturbing, molesting or harassing a marine turtle or its nest is a third-degree felony, plus $100 per egg. Under 16 U.S.C. § 1540, federal penalties are up to $25,000 civil or $50,000 and 1 year criminal for endangered species (leatherback, hawksbill, Kemp’s ridley), and up to $12,000 civil or $25,000 and 6 months criminal for the threatened loggerhead and green turtle (protected through 50 CFR 17.42(b)). In North Carolina, G.S. 113-189 violations are a Class 3 misdemeanor on a first conviction (G.S. 113-135(a)). No statute or FWC rule sets a distance from a marked nest; disturbing the nest is the offense. FWC sets the season by county: March 1 – October 31 in Brevard through Broward counties, and May 1 – October 31 in every other Florida county, including Flagler and Santa Rosa.
39 pages corrected

North Carolina pages: the penalty for detecting in a state park

What was wrong
The Carolina Beach, Kure Beach, Nags Head and Wrightsville Beach pages gave the penalty for using a metal detector in a North Carolina state park as a citation with possible equipment confiscation, without citing a source. The Nags Head page also listed equipment forfeiture as a penalty for detecting in Cape Hatteras National Seashore.
What it says now
Violating a North Carolina state park rule, including the metal-detector rule (07 NCAC 13B .0203), is a Class 3 misdemeanor under G.S. 143B-135.16(a), with a maximum fine of $200 (G.S. 15A-1340.23). Neither provision mentions confiscating equipment. The federal penalty at Cape Hatteras is a fine of up to $5,000 and/or 6 months; 36 CFR 2.1 itself provides no forfeiture.
4 pages corrected

Treasure Coast pages: who may salvage the 1715 Fleet, and how far the wreckage spreads

What was wrong
Treasure Coast metal-detecting pages said recovery from the 1715 Fleet wreck sites requires a formal salvage contract with the Florida Division of Historical Resources, called the offshore sites state archaeological preserves or a "1715 Fleet preserve" with a boundary in the surf, and mentioned a beach detecting permit that does not exist. Two pages put the wreck corridor at about 90 miles. The Florida antiquities guide said salvage of the 1715 and 1733 fleet sites requires state permits.
What it says now
The 1715 Fleet wrecks are under a federal in rem admiralty case filed in 1979 (S.D. Fla. No. 9:79-cv-08266). Exclusive salvage rights were awarded in 1982 and assigned in 2010 to 1715 Fleet–Queens Jewels, LLC with the court’s and the state’s approval; the court divides each year’s finds between the salvor and the State of Florida. Because the case predates April 28, 1988, Florida issues no Exploration or Recovery Permits for these wrecks (FAC 1A-31.0045), and its permits are for commercial salvors in any case. The only 1715 wreck that is a state preserve is the Urca de Lima Underwater Archaeological Preserve off Fort Pierce. The Eleventh Circuit describes the wreckage as spread along forty-one miles of coast. Historic material below mean high water remains state property under Fla. Stat. § 267.061.
10 pages corrected

California metal-detecting pages: archaeological statutes, Crystal Cove and the ecological reserves

What was wrong
The Huntington State Beach, Newport Beach and Ocean Beach pages said removing any pre-contact artifact from public land is a felony under PRC § 5097.99, with Huntington and Newport giving up to 3 years in state prison, $10,000 fines and forfeiture of tools and vehicles. Section 5097.99 covers only Native American artifacts or remains taken from a grave or cairn; general archaeological removal falls under § 5097.5, a misdemeanor. The Newport Beach page said metal detecting is prohibited at Crystal Cove State Park under PRC § 5001.65, which prohibits commercial exploitation of park resources and does not mention detecting. The Huntington page cited Fish and Game Code § 1602 (streambed alteration) for the Bolsa Chica Ecological Reserve. The Pismo Beach page said California State Parks treats recreational detecting as distinct from the excavation barred by 14 CCR § 4307, which has no source.
What it says now
PRC § 5097.5 makes it a misdemeanor (up to $10,000 and/or 1 year in county jail, plus restitution) to knowingly excavate or remove archaeological, paleontological or historic features on any public land, including city beaches. PRC § 5097.99 makes knowingly possessing, or maliciously removing, Native American artifacts or remains taken from a grave or cairn a felony. California State Parks has no statewide detecting rule: districts post unit orders (for example, detectors are banned throughout Folsom Lake SRA and every Northern Buttes District unit), and in every unit 14 CCR § 4307(a) bars disturbing sand and § 4308 bars removing archaeological or historic objects, with penalties under PRC § 5008(d). Crystal Cove is described on that basis, and the state-beach pages now say to ask the unit before digging targets. Bolsa Chica requires visitors to stay on trails (14 CCR § 630), and 14 CCR § 550(g)(1) bars disturbing artifacts or geological formations on CDFW lands; violations are misdemeanors under Fish and Game Code § 12000(a).
5 pages corrected

Florida state parks: where metal detecting is allowed, which rule applies, and the penalty

What was wrong
Twenty Florida metal-detecting pages and the Florida hub cited FL DEP Rule 62D-2.014 as the rule that limits detecting to state park beaches. That rule (Activities and Recreation) never mentions metal detectors and has no paragraph (1)(v) or (1)(k); its subsection (7) is about bathing and swimming. Two pages quoted it as allowing detecting on "ocean, gulf, or bay beaches" (no such text exists), and one credited it with a ban on disturbing archaeological resources. Pages also cited Fla. Stat. §§ 258.007 and 258.037 (the Division’s powers and policy) as penalty provisions, and listed equipment confiscation and misdemeanor prosecution as penalties. The Clearwater Beach page said detecting is prohibited on Caladesi Island State Park, and the Panama City Beach page said it is banned throughout St. Andrews State Park; neither has a source, and both conflict with the statewide policy. The St. Pete Beach page attributed Egmont Key’s detector ban to the state park rule rather than the federal refuge rules, and the Jensen Beach page placed John D. MacArthur Beach State Park on Hutchinson Island.
What it says now
Where detecting is allowed in Florida state parks is set by Florida State Parks policy: it is prohibited on all state park land except coastal parks, where it may happen only within beach areas between the toe of the dune and the high-water line that the park manager designates, never in submerged areas, and visitors may not keep objects over 50 years old. FAC 62D-2.013(2) separately bars digging, disturbing or removing artifacts and other materials in a park. Breaking a park rule is a noncriminal infraction with a fine of up to $500 and ejection from all state park property (Fla. Stat. § 258.008(1)); removing a historic object is a separate crime under § 267.13. Caladesi Island and St. Andrews are coastal parks, so detecting is allowed only in designated beach areas — call each park to find out where. Egmont Key is also a national wildlife refuge whose rules prohibit metal detectors. MacArthur Beach State Park is on Singer Island in North Palm Beach.
21 pages corrected

Florida foraging pages: state park plant rule, plant-protection penalties and ESA fines

What was wrong
The Fakahatchee Strand page cited FL DEP Rule 62D-2.014(1)(k) as the ban on removing plants (that rule covers recreation activities and has no paragraph (k)), cited Fla. Stat. § 258.004 for the penalty, and called a § 581.185 violation a second-degree misdemeanor of up to $500 per plant that escalates on repeat offenses. The Big Cypress and Ocala pages cited a § 581.188 that does not exist and said repeat § 581.185 violations are third-degree felonies, and gave $50,000 as the Endangered Species Act civil penalty. The Osceola page listed the saw palmetto permit's cost as "Varies".
What it says now
Florida's state park plant rule is FAC 62D-2.013(4)(b) ("No person shall transplant or remove any plant life from any park"), and 62D-2.013(7) allows collection permits only for scientific or educational purposes. Collecting plant specimens in a state park without permission is a second-degree misdemeanor with ejection under Fla. Stat. § 258.008(3)(c). A § 581.185 violation is a first-degree misdemeanor under § 581.211(1), with no felony step-up for repeat offenses. The ESA's civil maximum is $25,000 per knowing violation (adjusted for inflation); $50,000 and 1 year is the criminal maximum (16 U.S.C. § 1540). The FDACS saw palmetto permit is free.
4 pages corrected

Florida saw palmetto berries: what the permit is, and the two-plant rule

What was wrong
Florida foraging pages said harvesting saw palmetto berries needs a commercial FDACS dealer license that recreational foragers cannot get, and three of them said there is no personal-use exemption. The Osceola National Forest page cited the theft statute (Fla. Stat. § 812.014) and said any quantity was a felony; the Apalachicola summary also said "regardless of quantity".
What it says now
Fla. Stat. § 581.189 makes it a third-degree felony to harvest saw palmetto berries on public land, or on someone else's land, without both the landowner's written permission and a permit from FDACS. The permit (form FDACS 08025) is free, valid for one year, and is not a dealer license. The statute does not cover someone who legally harvests from up to two plants for home or personal use, but § 581.185 still requires the landowner's written permission even for one or two plants — on a national forest that is the Forest Service, in Big Cypress the National Park Service. The pages now say so and cite the statute and FDACS.
6 pages corrected

Fort De Soto Park: metal detecting is allowed on the beaches, with no permit

What was wrong
The Fort De Soto page gave a verdict of "permit required" and described a free ranger permit, a 6-inch digging limit and a rule that finds must be surrendered. None of these had a source. A separate page described the permit itself, and the St. Pete Beach, Clearwater Beach, Pensacola Beach and Siesta Key pages repeated the claims.
What it says now
Pinellas County Code § 90-7(p) bans metal detectors in county parks "except on beaches in parks", and the county's park-rules page adds only that dug holes must be filled. The verdict is now "allowed" (beaches only, no permit, fill your holes), penalties cite Fla. Stat. § 125.69, the permit page was deleted, and the claims were removed from the other four pages.
5 pages corrected, 1 removed

Florida's antiquities law (Fla. Stat. ch. 267): where it applies, and no duty to report

What was wrong
Florida pages said the state owns any object over 50 years old found anywhere on a beach, and that such finds must be reported. Some cited § 267.061 as the source of a felony penalty, and three pages named "Sovereign Submerged Lands Archaeological Preserves", a designation that does not exist.
What it says now
§ 267.061 covers objects abandoned on state-owned land and sovereignty submerged land, which on the coast generally means seaward of mean high water, not the dry sand of city and county beaches. The statute has no age threshold; "50 years" is Florida State Parks policy for what visitors may keep in state parks. § 267.13 penalizes removal without a Division of Historical Resources permit; there is no duty to report, and reporting is not a defense. Quick answers, penalty rows, prose and FAQs were corrected on the pages below, and the Chapter 267 guide was rewritten.
47 pages corrected, 1 removed

Florida antiquities penalty (Fla. Stat. § 267.13)

What was wrong
36 Florida pages and the Chapter 267 guide's FAQ described the penalty for removing a protected artifact as a misdemeanor punishable by up to $500.
What it says now
Under § 267.13 it is a first-degree misdemeanor if the object was removed without excavation and a third-degree felony if it was excavated; the finds are forfeited and restitution can be ordered. The penalty rows and the guide's FAQ now say so.
37 pages corrected

Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument: verdict changed from "allowed" to "unclear"

What was wrong
The page said casual collecting of common invertebrate and plant fossils was allowed in the monument, up to 25 lb per day and 250 lb per year.
What it says now
The monument has been closed to casual fossil collecting since Proclamation 6920 (1996). Proclamation 11044 (effective September 11, 2026) reduced it to about 181,541 acres in two units, which stay closed. BLM has not yet said how casual collecting will be managed on the roughly 1.69 million acres removed from the monument, so the verdict is "unclear" until it does. The related Utah and Wyoming pages were updated to match.
6 pages corrected

BLM collecting limits: the "25-pound rule" is three different rules

What was wrong
Rockhounding, fossil and gold-panning pages applied a single "25 lb per day, 250 lb per year" limit to all collecting on BLM land, and some cited it to 43 CFR § 3622.2 or "Part 3600".
What it says now
Three federal rules apply. Rocks, minerals and gemstones: "reasonable amounts", with no federal number (43 CFR 8365.1-5(b)(2)); BLM Arizona and BLM California set 25 lb per day and 250 lb per year, BLM Oregon/Washington uses a car-trunk standard, and BLM Nevada, Idaho, Utah, Colorado and New Mexico publish no figure. Common invertebrate and plant fossils: 25 lb per person per day, with no annual cap (43 CFR 49.810). Petrified wood: 25 lb plus one piece per day, 250 lb per year (43 CFR 3622.4). The wrong citations were removed, and references to BLM's retired LR2000 database now point to MLRS.
41 pages corrected

Virgin Valley opal fields, Nevada: the rules come from Sheldon National Wildlife Refuge, not BLM

What was wrong
The page treated Virgin Valley as BLM land open to collecting 25 lb per day under 43 CFR 8365.1-5.
What it says now
Virgin Valley is in Sheldon National Wildlife Refuge, which allows rock collecting by hand from the surface only, up to 7 lb per day, with no digging or tools; digging happens only at private fee-dig mines. The page was rewritten from U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service sources, and the Royal Peacock, Rye Patch, Opal Butte and opal material pages were updated to match.
5 pages corrected

Fossil penalties under PRPA: unsupported "$100,000" fines removed

What was wrong
The Judith River and Badlands pages gave a fixed "$100,000" fine for fossil violations under the Paleontological Resources Preservation Act.
What it says now
The penalty rows now cite the statute itself: 16 U.S.C. 470aaa-5 (criminal penalties) and 470aaa-6 (civil penalties), with the ARPA penalty tiers of 16 U.S.C. 470ee(d) on the Judith River page.
2 pages corrected

Texas: state park rule citation and Antiquities Code penalty

What was wrong
Texas metal-detecting pages cited the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department park rule to 30 TAC, and described Antiquities Code violations as a state jail felony.
What it says now
The park rule is 31 TAC § 59.134(i), a Class C misdemeanor (up to $500, Parks and Wildlife Code § 13.112). Antiquities Code violations are a misdemeanor under Natural Resources Code § 191.171: a $50 to $1,000 fine and/or up to 30 days in jail, with each day a separate offense.
4 pages corrected

Black Hills Rockhound Area, Arizona: the page described the wrong place

What was wrong
The page placed the Black Hills Rockhound Area in western Arizona under the BLM Yuma Field Office, with white opalite, geodes and jasper as the main finds.
What it says now
Rewritten from BLM's page for the site: it is in Graham County, managed by the Safford Field Office, off US-191 near milepost 141, and is known for fire agate. The geode and jasper material pages were corrected, and the site was added to the agate page.
4 pages corrected

Lynx Creek, Prescott National Forest: there is a daily collecting limit

What was wrong
The page said personal-use collecting on Prescott National Forest had no daily weight limit, and contrasted it with a BLM 25-lb rule it cited to 43 CFR § 3622.2.
What it says now
Prescott National Forest says a reasonable amount is generally up to 10 lb per person per day. The limit was corrected and the misapplied BLM citation removed.
1 page corrected