- What was wrong
- The Cape May page said Cape May Point State Park requires a "Special Use Permit" for metal detecting, that the permit fee "varies" and is "often not granted regardless of fee", and that the city's beach tag is needed all day from Memorial Day to Labor Day, at a flat $40 per season with free tags for veterans only. It gave the penalty for tag violations only as a "municipal citation; fine" and didn't mention the 10 p.m.–6 a.m. beach closure. It said the Borough of Cape May Point surrounds the state park, that a detectorist near the lighthouse could be on City of Cape May land, that Cape May Point is "a few miles south", that Battery 223 sits near Sunset Beach where the state park and borough meet, that the whole city is a National Historic Landmark, and that the Borough of Cape May Point's rules had to be confirmed locally. It called Sunset Beach a Lower Township beach without saying it is privately owned, called the SS Atlantus a WWII ship, said no New Jersey law governs keeping beach finds, and listed 19th-century and WWII-era finds without a source. The New Jersey overview said Cape May's city beaches sit between the state park and the Borough of Cape May Point, and neither it nor the Asbury Park and Island Beach pages mentioned New Jersey's lost-property law; the Asbury Park page implied ordinary finds are yours to keep.
- What it says now
- Detecting in a state park needs a permit from the park Superintendent or designee, which may limit location, hours and days; none is issued for areas of significant historical or other value or where detecting would harm the resource or interfere with public use (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.16). Most of Cape May Point State Park is the Cape May Point Natural Area, so the page says we'd expect a refusal, as our reading of those criteria, and to ask the park office about cost. Digging up or removing soil, rock, historic or fossil material in the park needs the written permission of the Director of Parks and Forestry (N.J.A.C. 7:2-2.10(c)). On city beaches, tags are required 10 a.m.–5 p.m. (City Code § 158-6), in 2026 from Saturday, May 23 to Labor Day, September 7; a season tag is $30 if bought December 1–April 30 and $40 after, with $25 weekly, $20 three-day and $10 daily tags, free under 12 and for active military and their families, active New Jersey National Guard and veterans with documentation (§ 158-3). Nobody may be on the beach or in the adjacent water from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., year-round (§ 158-9B(17)), or in the dunes or sand fencing (§ 158-12C); violations carry up to a $1,250 fine, 90 days in jail or 90 days' community service, each day a separate violation (§ 158-15; Ch. 1, Art. III). The city's beach and digging rules don't restrict detecting: Chapter 158 has no detector rule and Chapter 368's park digging ban excludes beaches (§ 368-2). West of the city lie The Nature Conservancy's South Cape May Meadows (beach use limited to nature viewing March 15–August 31), then the state park, then the Borough of Cape May Point; near the lighthouse there is no city land. The borough's code (Ch. 58) has no detecting rule; it requires its own beach tag for anyone 12+ in season ($40 season before May 31, $50 after, $25 weekly, $10 daily), gives city tag holders transit-only access, fines dune violations $2,000 each and doubles fines from 11 p.m. to 6 a.m. Battery 223 stands on the state park's beach (NJDEP). Sunset Beach is privately owned (Hume family / Sunset Beach Gift Shops), so detecting there needs the owner's permission; Higbee Beach WMA bans detecting. The SS Atlantus was a World War I-era concrete ship launched November 21, 1918, that went aground June 8, 1926. The National Historic Landmark is Cape May's historic district (1976). New Jersey's lost-property law requires a finder to make reasonable efforts to return lost property, lets the finder claim it only if the owner doesn't reclaim it within 120 days, and for buried or hidden lost property lets the landowner, not the finder, claim title (N.J.S.A. 46:30C-3, -4); keeping an item when you know whose it is can be theft (N.J.S.A. 2C:20-6). The unsourced find claims were removed. The New Jersey overview, Asbury Park and Island Beach pages now carry the lost-property rule, and the overview gives the shoreline order correctly.
- Sources
- N.J. Admin. Code § 7:2-2.16 — Metal detectors
- N.J. Admin. Code § 7:2-2.10 — Damage to property/tampering
- City of Cape May, NJ — Chapter 158, Beach Tags; Regulations; Beach and Sand Dune Protection
- City of Cape May, NJ — Chapter 1, Art. III, Penalty
- City of Cape May, NJ — Chapter 368, Parks and Recreation Areas
- City of Cape May — 2026 Beach Tags
- Borough of Cape May Point, NJ — Chapter 58, Beaches
- NJDEP — Cape May Point State Park
- The Nature Conservancy — South Cape May Meadows
- Sunset Beach — SS Atlantus, the Concrete Ship
- N.J.S.A. 46:30C-3 (FindLaw)
- N.J.S.A. 46:30C-4 (FindLaw)
- New Jersey Courts — Model Jury Charge, Theft of Property Lost, Mislaid or Delivered by Mistake (N.J.S.A. 2C:20-6)