Rockhounding at Herkimer Diamond Mines, New York

Rockhounding · New York, HerkimerVerified Researched by Rachel Mower

ALLOWED

No permit required

Digging at Herkimer Diamond Mines needs only an admission ticket, and you keep every crystal. Hand tools up to a 12-lb sledge are allowed; no power tools. Rules checked against primary sources in .

Key Conditions

  • Private fee-dig: a day ticket ($19 ages 13+, $16 ages 5–12 on weekdays; +$3/+$2 Friday–Sunday) is the only permission needed, and you keep everything you find
  • Hand tools only, up to a 12-lb sledge. Powered equipment is banned, and closed-toe shoes are required.
  • 2026 season: April 12 to October 31, 9 a.m.–5 p.m. daily. The mine closes during snow, sleet, heavy rain or thunderstorms.
  • The neighboring Ace of Diamonds Mine is closed for the entire 2026 season, so do not plan a two-mine day on NY-28 this year
  • State land is not an alternative: 6 NYCRR § 190.8(g) bars removing rock, minerals or fossils from DEC-managed state land without a permit. Roadside outcrops along NY-28 are highway right-of-way or private land, not DEC land; ask NYSDOT or the landowner first.

Herkimer Diamond Mines · 43.1306, -74.9754

2026: one of the two NY-28 mines is closed all season

Ace of Diamonds Mine, next door to Herkimer Diamond Mines in Middleville, says its mine, campground and gift shop are closed until further notice, and it expects no mining for the entire 2026 season. Earlier in the litigation, a court ruled that the injunction halting its commercial mining had been improperly issued. The case is still pending, though, and the mine says the property may be sold at auction or divided between landowners. Many older trip guides still recommend doing both mines in one day. For 2026, Herkimer Diamond Mines is the walk-up option on this stretch of NY-28.

Herkimer Diamond Mines at a Glance (2026)

None

Permit needed

$19–$22

Adult ticket

Ages 13+, weekday vs. Fri–Sun

Apr 12–Oct 31

Season

9 a.m.–5 p.m.

Hours

12-lb sledge

Tool limit

No powered equipment

All of them

Keep finds?

Herkimer Diamond Fee-Digs Compared (2026 Season)

MineLocationAdult priceBooking2026 status
Herkimer Diamond MinesNY-28 N, Middleville area$19 weekday / $22 Fri–Sun (13+)Walk-up, 9–5Open Apr 12–Oct 31
Ace of Diamonds MineMiddleville, adjacent on NY-28$14 (8+), last postedWalk-upClosed all season
Crystal Grove Diamond MineSt. Johnsville (Fulton County)$16 (12+) non-camperWalk-up; signed Miner's Agreement and daily armbandMid-April–mid-October (campground season)
Diamond Mountain Mining — Wilderness Dig416 Ritter Rd, Little Falls$120 (14+) / $30 (13 and under)Reservation onlyOpen 7 days, 2026 season

Prices and status taken from each operator's own website on September 17, 2026. Fee-dig pricing changes often, so confirm before driving.

Herkimer diamonds aren't diamonds, and they don't come from Herkimer village. They are quartz crystals found in the Little Falls Dolostone, an Upper Cambrian carbonate rock that began forming in a shallow sea roughly 500 million years ago and today crops out across the Mohawk Valley. The crystals grew later, inside cavities (vugs) dissolved in the rock by seeping water. They are doubly terminated, with 18 faces, and clear enough to look faceted; the mine says the clearest are usually those less than 1 inch long.

That geology shapes how you dig. Crystals from the loose fill on the surface have usually been picked over. The unbroken slabs are where the reward is, and splitting them along the bedding plane is how the vugs get opened. Similar quartz fee-digs run on the same ticket-is-permission model at the Mount Ida quartz crystal mines in Arkansas and Emerald Hollow Mine in North Carolina.

From a legal standpoint, this is one of the simplest pages on the site. The mine is private property, admission is the permission, and nothing you find has to be declared, weighed or reported. The legal trap is the idea that you can skip the fee: dolostone that shows in roadcuts and outcrops is private land, highway right-of-way or DEC-managed state land, where § 190.8(g) bars removing any mineral without a permit.

Why the free roadcut isn't free

Under 6 NYCRR § 190.8(g), no person may "deface, remove, destroy or otherwise injure" any "rock, soil, fossil or mineral" found on State land. That rule covers DEC-managed state land, not highway roadcuts. Its only exceptions are personal consumption and a permit issued jointly by the DEC Commissioner and the Commissioner of Education; neither fits a weekend crystal hunt. Roadside outcrops along NY-28 are highway right-of-way or private land, so ask NYSDOT or the landowner first. Digging on private land without the owner's permission is trespass. The fee-digs exist because they're the one place where the landowner's permission comes with the ticket.

What to Bring to the Mine

When to Dig

Spring (Apr 12–May)

Good

The season opens April 12. The mine closes during snow, sleet, heavy rain or thunderstorms.

Summer (Jun–Aug)

Fair

Friday–Sunday tickets cost $3 more for adults and $2 more for kids. Bring water and sunscreen, and dress for the weather.

Fall (Sep–Oct 31)

Good

Cooler, thinner weekday crowds and weekday pricing. The season ends October 31, and cold rain can close the mine on short notice.

Winter (Nov–Apr 11)

Closed

Mining is closed. With Ace of Diamonds also closed for 2026, there's no walk-up alternative on NY-28 until the spring 2027 openings.

Scan the surface after rain

Crystal Grove, a fee-dig in nearby St. Johnsville, says scanning the ground for exposed crystals is most effective on a sunny day immediately after a rainstorm, which washes away the dust and makes the crystals sparkle. Walk the base of the piles slowly before you swing a hammer at all. Keep in mind that Herkimer Diamond Mines closes during harsh rain and thunderstorms, so the rain has to have stopped before you go.

Who Sets the Rules Here

Permits & Licenses

PermitRequired?Notes
Mining admission (day ticket)YesThis is an admission ticket, not a government permit. No reservation is needed: sign in at registration any time between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. The ticket covers all-day prospecting, collection bags and the use of a rock hammer, which is loaned in exchange for an ID.
State or county rockhounding permitNoNone is needed for digging on private fee-dig ground with the owner's permission. We found no New York statewide recreational mineral-collecting license.
DEC state land collectingYesRemoving rock, soil, fossils or minerals from DEC-managed state land is barred under 6 NYCRR § 190.8(g). The rule's only exceptions are personal consumption and a permit issued jointly by the DEC Commissioner and the Commissioner of Education; neither fits recreational crystal collecting.

Time & Seasonal Restrictions

Equipment Notes

What People Find Here

Penalties for Violations

← Scroll to see all columns

ViolationStatutePenalty
Using power tools or tools heavier than 12 lb in the mining areaHerkimer Diamond Mines posted mine rulesPrivate-property rule; the operator can require you to stop or leave the mining area
Removing rock, minerals or fossils from DEC-managed state land without a permit6 NYCRR § 190.8(g)Violation of DEC state land regulations, enforced by DEC Forest Rangers and Environmental Conservation Officers under the Environmental Conservation Law. We could not confirm the exact fine schedule for this subsection, so contact DEC before assuming a figure.
Entering posted or fenced private land, or a closed mine, without the owner's permissionN.Y. Penal Law § 140.05 (trespass)Trespass is a violation: up to 15 days in jail (Penal Law § 70.15(4)) and/or a fine of up to $250 (§ 80.05(4))

Etiquette & Leave No Trace

Distances are straight-line, not driving distance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a permit to dig for Herkimer diamonds?

No. Herkimer Diamond Mines is a private fee-dig, and the day ticket is the only permission required. We found no New York recreational mineral-collecting license that would apply.

Is Ace of Diamonds Mine open in 2026?

No. As of September 2026, Ace of Diamonds says its mine, campground and gift shop are closed until further notice, and it expects no camping or mining for the entire 2026 season. The mine hasn't published a reason for the closure, but its site also describes ongoing litigation in which the property may be sold at auction or divided between the current landowners. Its online store is still open.

Can I collect Herkimer diamonds from roadcuts along NY-28 or on state land?

State land is not an alternative: § 190.8(g) bars removing rock, minerals or fossils from DEC-managed state land without a permit. Roadside outcrops along NY-28 are highway right-of-way or private land, not DEC land; ask NYSDOT or the landowner first. That leaves the fee-digs as the only reliably legal places to hunt.

How much does Herkimer Diamond Mines cost in 2026?

$19 for ages 13 and up and $16 for ages 5–12 on weekdays, with $3 and $2 added Friday through Sunday. Kids 4 and under get in free. A rock hammer is included.

Where in the pile are the best crystals?

Inside unbroken dolostone. The crystals grew inside cavities (vugs) dissolved in the rock by seeping water, and the mine names a 2- to 3-lb crack hammer and a bull point chisel as the most popular tools for breaking them out. Crystal Grove adds that scanning the surface works best on a sunny day immediately after a rainstorm.

Can I bring my own sledgehammer?

Yes, up to 12 lb, along with chisels, screens, small shovels and buckets. Anything powered is banned.

New to This? Start Here

Disclaimer

Information is provided for general guidance only. Regulations change frequently. Always verify current rules with the official jurisdiction before relying on this information for legal decisions. Permitted Pursuits is not a substitute for official agency guidance. Report an error.

Sources

Last verified: · Last updated: